NRoo has West Coast and a harder run coming up.
Don't expect the massive scores to keep coming.
Round 3 Trades
- Thread starter Jiska
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
NRoo has West Coast and a harder run coming up.
Don't expect the massive scores to keep coming.
Beachsleeper
Team Captain
- Jan 23, 2014
- 437
- 1,758
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Anyone trading out Mitchell, Enright, Dangerfield or Gunston, or anyone trading in Mumford or Jaensch, isn't fit to drive.
Lachy Jamison
All Australian
- Feb 3, 2013
- 918
- 423
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Patrick Cripps
Yeah think ill hold Mitchell for now and look to just upgrade or downgrade Higgins.
Hi All,
Just wondering what changes to my supercoach team you would advise this coming week:
mitchell hibberd simpson guthrie mcdonald langdom (cameron, laidler)
ablett, murphy, cotchin, beams, shuey, dunstan, polec, tyson (cunningham, aish)
Sandi, pyke (derrickx, currie)
Danger, martin, mitchell, pavlich, caddy, rohan (impey, mcdonough)
Im thinking, rohan to ambrose as the only trade this week, perhaps maybe guthrie to swallow, what are your thoughts, cheers
Just wondering what changes to my supercoach team you would advise this coming week:
mitchell hibberd simpson guthrie mcdonald langdom (cameron, laidler)
ablett, murphy, cotchin, beams, shuey, dunstan, polec, tyson (cunningham, aish)
Sandi, pyke (derrickx, currie)
Danger, martin, mitchell, pavlich, caddy, rohan (impey, mcdonough)
Im thinking, rohan to ambrose as the only trade this week, perhaps maybe guthrie to swallow, what are your thoughts, cheers
Beachsleeper
Team Captain
- Jan 23, 2014
- 437
- 1,758
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Higgins' BE is 5, for God's sake! Why downgrade him now? Surely you chose him because he was cheap for what you might get and forward rookies were thin. If you stick with him and his good-but-not-great scores for a bit longer you'll be rewarded modestly, but usefully.
- Nov 9, 2012
- 13,665
- 14,851
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- 76ers/Rockies/Colts/West Ham
Still torn on the Enright -> Swallow and Michie -> Tyson trade.
I'd feel right stupid if Mitchell didn't play and Enright did.
However, I need a way to free up cash to get Tyson into the side.
I'd feel right stupid if Mitchell didn't play and Enright did.
However, I need a way to free up cash to get Tyson into the side.
Higgins will improve as the doggies build confidence this season. Should he remain uninjured there is no reason that he couldn't reach 450-480k by the bye.
Is everyone jumping on Taylor due to the DPP, ro was he actually impressive against the Cats? I didn't see any of his game so am not sold.
The influx of Matt Thomas trade-ins could be one of the funnier things we will see go down in Supercoach history.
Is everyone jumping on Taylor due to the DPP, ro was he actually impressive against the Cats? I didn't see any of his game so am not sold.
The influx of Matt Thomas trade-ins could be one of the funnier things we will see go down in Supercoach history.
Gribnoor
THE BEAST
- Feb 28, 2014
- 666
- 627
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Ah, Higgins -> M Thomas, forgot I could even do that?
... How's it work? I can reverse trades if I somehow break it I guess. Killer idea Gingy.As for Webster, depends on his injury report - for mine, I see huge potential in him, could average at least the same as Suckling (was on track before sub vest), and would prefer to keep him. But if too unclear, will play the safer trade yes.
Liking that option though! Wait and assess again Friday.
I think I've talked myself into these two trades.
Going to go with my gut.
Burger > Mummy
Roughead > Zorko
Now leaves me with $222,900 in the kitty.
Keeping Mitchell and Enright, even if one of them misses this week.
Next week can go Rohan > M.Crouch via Taylor mpp and then either Webster > Swallow or Caddy > Chappy.
The more I think about it the more I think these trades are winners.
Yeah some may say I'm chasing points but I can't see Mumford and Zorko slowing down and I think Burger isn't going to be top 3 rucks this year with West in the team and Roughead is going to be too up and down for me. He needs to kick 5 goals just to get a decent score!
My overall ranking isn't going to improve without getting Mumford, Zorko, Pendles, NRoo, Chappy, Selwood and Swallow into my team. I feel you need to get as many of these guys into your team as quickly as possible!
I'm locking my trades in. Its only 2 trades, 27 to go. LOL!
Going to go with my gut.
Burger > Mummy
Roughead > Zorko
Now leaves me with $222,900 in the kitty.
Keeping Mitchell and Enright, even if one of them misses this week.
Next week can go Rohan > M.Crouch via Taylor mpp and then either Webster > Swallow or Caddy > Chappy.
The more I think about it the more I think these trades are winners.
Yeah some may say I'm chasing points but I can't see Mumford and Zorko slowing down and I think Burger isn't going to be top 3 rucks this year with West in the team and Roughead is going to be too up and down for me. He needs to kick 5 goals just to get a decent score!
My overall ranking isn't going to improve without getting Mumford, Zorko, Pendles, NRoo, Chappy, Selwood and Swallow into my team. I feel you need to get as many of these guys into your team as quickly as possible!
I'm locking my trades in. Its only 2 trades, 27 to go. LOL!
Last edited:
Ok so I'm doing the unthinkable of getting rid of a premium for cash. Just need to work out which one....
Trading either Libba or Kennedy > Tyson (Tyson avg higher then both ATM)
So I can upgrade the spud Rohan > Zorko. (This trade can't be done without a downgrade).
Even if either Libba or Kennedy avg 110 and Tyson only 90. I think the upgrade of Rohan to Zorko will make my side at least 50 points better a week on avg.
Thoughts?
Trading either Libba or Kennedy > Tyson (Tyson avg higher then both ATM)
So I can upgrade the spud Rohan > Zorko. (This trade can't be done without a downgrade).
Even if either Libba or Kennedy avg 110 and Tyson only 90. I think the upgrade of Rohan to Zorko will make my side at least 50 points better a week on avg.
Thoughts?
Hi All,
Just wondering what changes to my supercoach team you would advise this coming week:
mitchell hibberd simpson guthrie mcdonald langdom (cameron, laidler)
ablett, murphy, cotchin, beams, shuey, dunstan, polec, tyson (cunningham, aish)
Sandi, pyke (derrickx, currie)
Danger, martin, mitchell, pavlich, caddy, rohan (impey, mcdonough)
Im thinking, rohan to ambrose as the only trade this week, perhaps maybe guthrie to swallow, what are your thoughts, cheers
Just wondering what changes to my supercoach team you would advise this coming week:
mitchell hibberd simpson guthrie mcdonald langdom (cameron, laidler)
ablett, murphy, cotchin, beams, shuey, dunstan, polec, tyson (cunningham, aish)
Sandi, pyke (derrickx, currie)
Danger, martin, mitchell, pavlich, caddy, rohan (impey, mcdonough)
Im thinking, rohan to ambrose as the only trade this week, perhaps maybe guthrie to swallow, what are your thoughts, cheers
I like both trades.
Gribnoor
THE BEAST
- Feb 28, 2014
- 666
- 627
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Agree with this, to an extent. It'll be interesting to see how M Thomas and Higgins play out. I don't believe their will be much middle ground, both high risk - either it will work very well (eg. Higgins returns to his prime, tops out around 450k) or crash (eg. Higgins soft tissue injury in next game). Pick a side of the fence
- part of the charm that is SC
I've got most of the rookies/cash cows already in McDonald, Langdon, Langford, Tyson, Ellis, Polec, Michie, Dunstan, Impey, Ambrose and JKH so I am toying with the idea of Mitchell > Jaensch and D Thomas > M Thomas, I'd guess (optimistically) Jaensch could maintain an average around 90 and M Thomas the same which wouldn't be far off the 2 they replace and it would add a much needed 350k approx into my upgrade fund.
But I also think it could completely backfire and would be a total waste of two trades...
Any thoughts?
But I also think it could completely backfire and would be a total waste of two trades...
Any thoughts?
Gribnoor
THE BEAST
- Feb 28, 2014
- 666
- 627
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
^ this. I won't be jumping on the NRoo train too soon, sure he killed it against the Dees (his defender was injuried when he racked it up) and Giants (defenders didn't completely look up to it). He will come up against significantly better opponent now - wait til he's faced some real opposition and organised defence for mine.
Lachy Jamison
All Australian
- Feb 3, 2013
- 918
- 423
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Patrick Cripps
At a latter date I will not now haha
- Aug 16, 2010
- 10,063
- 6,950
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
I don't want to trade but thinking of turning impey into Taylor. I think that Taylor JS is higher than impey.
Enright > Swallow
Higgins > Zorko
Thoughts?
Higgins > Zorko
Thoughts?
Enright trade not worth it IMO.
He will most likely play this week and if he doesn't he will definitely play next week. Hold!
Try and find another way of getting Swallow in.
For me I'm getting him in next week like this -
Rohan > M.Crouch via Taylor mpp and Webster > Swallow
Big Fozza
Premiership Player
More chance enright won't play then will but should be back next so your point still valid.Enright trade not worth it IMO.
He will most likely play this week and if he doesn't he will definitely play next week. Hold!
Try and find another way of getting Swallow in.
For me I'm getting him in next week like this -
Rohan > M.Crouch via Taylor mpp and Webster > Swallow
Big Fozza
Premiership Player
No to higgins and zorko imo
Yeah i'd prefer to keep Enright and Mitchell.Enright trade not worth it IMO.
He will most likely play this week and if he doesn't he will definitely play next week. Hold!
Try and find another way of getting Swallow in.
For me I'm getting him in next week like this -
Rohan > M.Crouch via Taylor mpp and Webster > Swallow
So I might do
Sutcliffe > Swallow
Higgins > Ambrose
Strengthens defence and means i have 100k spare.
Can't see how that's a bad trade.
Higgins is a stepping stone at best.
Zorko I reckon will be a premium keeper.
I say go for it.
I've read that he will be selected this week.
Reckon that's as good an indication as any that he will play.
- Status
