Opinion 2024 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Veer Right]

I'd go Walsh anyday over Dawson.

Crouch back and Dawson will turn back to poo imo.

Ok you Carlton loving kent! I am sold!

 

[True Blue Saint]

My headache this week is:

Walsh + Adams
vs
Dawson + Macrae

I'd lean to Dawson + Macrae - with the caveat that who knows what Crazy Bevo has planned for him.

I have to get rid of Bramble - my conundrum is Bowes v Dale?

 

[TempletonTheRat]

I have to get rid of Bramble - my conundrum is Bowes v Dale?

should be neither - needs to be upgraded to a full blown Premo. There are 11 defs averaging 105 or more and those 2 aren't

 

[Ed_Gein]

I have to get rid of Bramble - my conundrum is Bowes v Dale?

Yeah I'm looking at Bowes as well. Not getting much feedback on him. His scoring has been great though.

 

[gutsroy]

Macrae + Dawson vs
T Adams + Walsh vs
None of the above?
Basically the same cash-wise

 

[King Max]

Walsh or Miller?
Walsh’s back is iffy but scoring well.
Miller has a good run but competes with other mids.
Was $500 short on Serong, who comes in next round now.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Walsh or Miller?
Walsh’s back is iffy but scoring well.
Miller has a good run but competes with other mids.
Was $500 short on Serong, who comes in next round now.

Walsh.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Macrae + Dawson vs
T Adams + Walsh vs
None of the above?
Basically the same cash-wise

I’ve been going in circles with this, then settled on Dawson & Macrae.

The other two would add too much concerns to my existing injury prone side

 

[Veer Right]

A. Graham on field looped with Howes E

B. Mass on field, no loop

C. Darcy on field, no loop

D. Comben on field, no loop

 

[kyri]

A. Graham on field looped with Howes E

B. Mass on field, no loop

youd have to go with A, although B could be good.

 

[kyri]

khamis vs darcy? khamis has the role, dpp and js.

darcy is a better player and more exciting to watch. but i think his role is being bevo'd.

 

[kaiserchief13]

Wilson or Garcia on field to cover for Reid?

 

[SC fish]

Wilson or Garcia on field to cover for Reid?

I'm looping Wilson ahead of HGarcia, so Wilson

 

[Judd_Magic]

I'm looping Wilson ahead of HGarcia, so Wilson

Isn't Garcia getting mid time?

 

[SC fish]

Isn't Garcia getting mid time?

No idea I thought he was a small forward?

 

[Judd_Magic]

No idea I thought he was a small forward?

My bad.

Says that he played in attack on fanfooty.

Unless he plays mid in the VFL?

 

[A Bit Dusty]

My bad.

Says that he played in attack on fanfooty.

Unless he plays mid in the VFL?

 

[SC fish]

View attachment 1968817

Hmmm might be worth going HGarcia over Wilson then kaiserchief13

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

My bad.

Says that he played in attack on fanfooty.

Unless he plays mid in the VFL?

Fan footy is wrong a lot. Often says a player is being tagged when they aren't too.

 

[jdwood]

H Garcia started forward last week but when the game was lost (and Jones subbed for a forward in Butler) Ross seemed to throw the magnets around and he seemed to play the last quarter almost exclusivily in the middle.

I wouldn't rely on him playing in the guts every week but he seems to have pretty decent scoring potential particularly given the amount he tackles.

 

[Scythe94]

H Garcia started forward last week but when the game was lost (and Jones subbed for a forward in Butler) Ross seemed to throw the magnets around and he seemed to play the last quarter almost exclusivily in the middle.

I wouldn't rely on him playing in the guts every week but he seems to have pretty decent scoring potential particularly given the amount he tackles.

Was in the first CBA. Started in the middle, then shifted forward, before returning to the middle. Attended nearly every CBA after he was subbed on the week prior, too.

Not saying he'll be a full-time mid, but he's definitely not a permanent small forward.

 

[No eye deer]

So who are we playing/looping?
Garcia or Wilson?
Also who to play down back?
Massimo or Draper?
Worried about Massimo being sub.

 

[SC fish]

So who are we playing/looping?
Garcia or Wilson?
Also who to play down back?
Massimo or Draper?
Worried about Massimo being sub.

I'm going HGarcia over Wilson but not convinced

 

[rocker_oz33]

Fan footy is wrong a lot. Often says a player is being tagged when they aren't too.

Monty who runs FF .
Gets kids to run his page .
I can't see him doing 5 nights of footy this week.

 

[LuvtheKangas]

Monty who runs FF .
Gets kids to run his page .
I can't see him doing 5 nights of footy this week.

And those pop-ups are f***ing dreadful.