Opinion 2024 Player X vs Y vs Z

[JY5165]

Cull D'Ambrosio or McKercher to do my upgrade?

d'ambrosio. lost his half back role to amon. if you dont trade him this week youll likely have to next week considering his rising BE

personally trading both out so i can get martin and gawn in

not a fan of mckercher playing in the middle instead of off half back. he likely makes 70k more but martin and gawn's BE will make that this week alone

 

[Petrify]

Merrett vs Rozee + 80k

I think this board will lean toward Rozee instinctively because he just went huge but Rozee has a tendancy to go sub 100. Merrett on the other hand is Mr Consistent and has added 15pts a game to his score via tackling, putting him on Bont-like trajectory. Very hard choice

 

[SC fish]

Merrett vs Rozee + 80k

I think this board will lean toward Rozee instinctively because he just went huge but Rozee has a tendancy to go sub 100. Merrett on the other hand is Mr Consistent and has added 15pts a game to his score via tackling, putting him on Bont-like trajectory. Very hard choice

I think you're right - Merrett for consistency and also Rozee tends to cop the clanger tax

 

[toxic]

Merrett vs Rozee + 80k

I think this board will lean toward Rozee instinctively because he just went huge but Rozee has a tendancy to go sub 100. Merrett on the other hand is Mr Consistent and has added 15pts a game to his score via tackling, putting him on Bont-like trajectory. Very hard choice

Zerrett every day

 

[Ingy]

Hai kents.

Lohmann + $100k w questionable JS

V

Dempsey to sit at F6 until his bye.

If, IF, Ollie can maintain an 80 average he should make another $100-$130k.

All I'm saying here is that I am glad I got Dempsey last week after one price rise

 

[VeinGlorious]

All I'm saying here is that I am glad I got Dempsey last week after one price rise

Unfortunately I am resigned to the fact that he is one that slipped through my grasp.

I was too busy banishing Hayden Young to the twos for a week to facilitate Kerch/Powell/Mass in one fell swoop.

Then, THEN, when I shoulda been getting Dempsey I was too busy roughy-ing H Young back in along with getting Darcy and T Green.

Mea culpa.

Now Lloyd Meek is lookin’ at me kinda funny and I’m searching for a reason to punt Jordon, so, ya know, there’s that.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Merrett vs Rozee + 80k

I think this board will lean toward Rozee instinctively because he just went huge but Rozee has a tendancy to go sub 100. Merrett on the other hand is Mr Consistent and has added 15pts a game to his score via tackling, putting him on Bont-like trajectory. Very hard choice

Zerrett a gun one of the best skippers in the league

 

[Dundalis]

Ned could get Finn this week. Doubt he goes to any of the Gold Coast mids, as Finn does not start in CBA's. Flanders the obvious choice if Finn is selected.

Pretty sure he's tagged Touk in the past though

 

[pieman123]

Steele, Rozee or Rowell worth the extra $$?

 

[Judd_Magic]

Steele, Rozee or Rowell worth the extra $$?

Out of Steele and Rowell for me, toss a coin I reckon.

Steele maybe due to him being cheaper.

 

[Faz 2000]

Zerrett every day

Definitely want Merrett. I'm just hoping he drops in a lower score or two to get affordable. Otherwise he's a late season ultra-premo upgrade. He should be in everyone's final midfield plans. Rozee (who I own) - not so sure. Has a lower floor.

 

[godfather01]

Green vs Steele + 75k?

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

 

[Judd_Magic]

Green vs Steele + 75k?

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

Ideally you'd want both but Steele due to the value still.

 

[No eye deer]

Steele, Rozee or Rowell worth the extra $$?

Steele.

Green vs Steele + 75k?

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

Steele.

Now don’t break him!

 

[St Steady]

i picked steele from start so was fortunate there, i would still get steele in before green , cause i think hes going to have a really consistent scoring year back to premo mode,

maybe not to level green looks like hes on path for but , green wont get out of reach value wise, steele may

(i brought green in after his bye and think prob paid a bit much , but i took touk and steele at start , so did need to premo up in mids, this week i added zerrett)

 

[godfather01]

Thanks. Well now I'm confused, I've had Green all week. Think I'm still burning from starting Steele last year and worried about the potential Crouch factor...

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Steele, Rozee or Rowell worth the extra $$?

 

[Borgan]

English vs Marshall

 

[Scythe94]

English vs Marshall

Depends on what the extra 90k gets you. Still think English likely averages more Marshall, but doubt the gap will be as big as last year (English's ceiling is somewhat capped by sharing duties a bit more this year).

 

[Wellsy35]

Who would you prioritise getting this week?

Flanders v Martin v Young v JHF

 

[Judd_Magic]

Keep Jackson or trade him for Marshall?

Jackson is my R2.

 

[Anythings_sipposible]

Who would you prioritise getting this week?

Flanders v Martin v Young v JHF

I think you've got the order right there

 

[Scythe94]

Keep Jackson or trade him for Marshall?

Jackson is my R2.

Keep, then swing forward when you get the chance.

 

[stevebbb]

Keep Jackson or trade him for Marshall?

Jackson is my R2.

Keep. Inevitable that Darcy gets injured again. Averaged 87 with Darcy in the side last year. He's gotten better around the ground and with his marks, so he'll top that. Think he can go 95 with Darcy in the side. But yeah, Darcy injured again for sure.

 

[Guardian Hawk]

Who would you prioritise getting this week?

Flanders v Martin v Young v JHF

1. Flanders- hardly any good forwards around and he is playing mids and averaging 120. As sure a bet of being top 3-4 in his position as any player in the comp.
2. Martin - new role, underpriced and looking good. Uncharateristic ball use in Round 1 the only reason he is not averaging 120+. Great option but with more good alternative choices in defence than forwards, Flanders still the better pick.
3. Young - basically same arguments as Martin except that Young had 2 average games to start the year due to poor use and Martin only 1.
4. JHF - Is the cheapest of the bunch and scoring (very) well. If he was on track for DPP he'd probably be no 1 but as it looks like he will be mid only, the chances of him being a top 8-10 mid I think are still relatively low (remembering we all knew Port had a dream run of home games to start the season).