MVP Round 6, 2024: Votes vs Fremantle

[WCE_phil]

5 Reid
Daylight
4 yeo
3 waterman
2 barrass
1 Bailey williams

Just wanna say what really puts Reid’s game into perspective is the ranking points and Reid was about 1/3 higher than second place because when the game was up for grabs Reid took it by the horns and kicked 3, waterman was good also with 5 but only didn’t have as much impact as Reid when the game was on the line

You mean other than the 4 goals that Waterman kicked in the first half yeah?

 

[eaglesfan84]

5. Yeo
4. Reid
3. Waterman
2. Barrass
1. Darling

Best game I've seen Darling play for legitimately 3 or 4 years.

 

[InTheWings]

5. Bailey
4. Yeo
3. Waterman
2. Reid
1. Barrass

 

[Monocle]

5. Yeo
4. Waterman
3. Reid
2. Kelly
1. Barrass

 

[Rids]

5 - Yeo
4 - Reid
3 - Barrass
2 - Waterman (Honestly all those top 4 had cases for 5 vote games)
1 - Gov
HM - pretty much everyone - Petch had a rough night I guess and Williams was beaten but fought hard and took some huge marks. Hard to find much to complain about!

 

[larrikin]

Giving my votes based on watching at the ground with no replay.

5 - Barrass - genuinely amazed he got no votes in Glendinning medal. Intercepted or killed everything.
4 - Yeo. Is back.
3 - Harley. Wait till he's actually fit...
2 - Waterman
1 - BWilliams

 

[Quinz]

5. Barrass (Glendenning Medal voting a sham)
4. Reid
3. Waterman
2. Yeo
1. Ginbey

 

[HoneyBadger35]

5. Yeo
4. Reid
3. Waterman
2. TB
1. Cole

HM: Kelly, Hough, Maric’s best for the year

Stunned that Barrass didn’t nick a vote somewhere, despite how good and eye catching Yeo/Reid or five goals from Waterman was.

 

[bombard]

5. Yeo
4. Reid
3. Waterman
2. Barrass
1. Ginbey

 

[Ambrose Burnside]

So many deserved votes, entire backline was immense,

This

It's like after Richmond kicked the first 4 they've clicked and are playing a lot more cohesively as a unit. It's been great to watch.

Pressure up the ground also helps of course.

Enjoying the gameplan too. Reminds me of 2011.

For what it's worth, being at the game I thought Reid was best on ground, or at least equal with Waterman. Was honestly surprised to see Yeo named BOG, but plenty here are doing the same. Hard to see all the in tight contested stuff from the 5th tier.

 

[Off Tap]

5. Yeo
4. Reid
3. Waterman
2. Barrass
1. Williams

Reid unlucky not to get BOG.

The games by Barrass and Williams were both huge. Barrass stopped everything that went his way and Williams did extremely well against a very good combo. Williams really stood up in the 2nd half.

Our backline was awesome. I thought that Duggan played well after quarter time, McGovern solid while Hough played his role superbly.

Finally, need to mention Maric. I thought he did some good things in the 2nd half as well.

 

[Ambrose Burnside]

Finally, need to mention Maric. I thought he did some good things in the 2nd half as well.

Maric's goal on the three quarter time siren. Oh man. It cleared our bench, they stormed the ground like you see in those wild baseball brawls, but it was in celebration.

The boys are a tight group.

 

[Trouto]

5. Yeo
4. Reid
3. Waterman
2. Ginbey
1. Barrass

what a game

 

[Trouto]

Maric's goal on the three quarter time siren. Oh man. It cleared our bench, they stormed the ground like you see in those wild baseball brawls, but it was in celebration.

The boys are a tight group.

yeah, a cracker! he did well last night

 

[fidstar]

5. Reid
4. Waterman
3. Barrass
2. Yeo
1. B.Williams

HM - Almost all of them.

 

[Spod]

5 - Yeo
4 - Reid
3 - Waterman
2 - Barrass
1 - Hough

About 10 players could slot into the 1 and 2 spots there. Impressively even performance.

 

[SloppyJoe]

5. Reid
4. Waterman
3. Yeo
2. Barrass
1. Darling

 

[ArdentEagle]

5. Yeo
4. Reid
3. Waterman
2. Kelly
1. Hough (best game so far for mine)

(TB very stiff to miss. First time in ages I could of had votes for 8+ people)

 

[Broken_Chairs]

5. Yeo
4. Reid
3. TK
2. Waterman
1. Hough

Some pretty bloody good performances when i'm only giving the bloke who bagged 5 goals only 2 votes

 

[Eastcoasteagle]

I dunno, I reckon there were a few games last year where nobody deserved any votes.

Very true

 

[amazingjoshy]

Watched the replay late at night and knowing the result so not sure if that's skewed my perspective but thought Barrass and Harley were the 2 best by a fair way

5. Barrass
4.Reid
3. Waterman
2. Yeo
1.Hough

 

[Bender_]

5: Reid
4: Yeo
3: Reid
2: Barrass
1: Hough

 

[Farang83150]

Yeo
Reid
Barrass
Waterman
BW

Love how Maric's tracking.

 

[Truly Lazuli]

5: Yeo
4: Reid
3: Waterman
2: Barrass
1: Bailey W

 

[Mulldogg]

5. Reid
4. Yeo
3. Waterman
2. Barrass
1. Hough

HM - B Williams, TK