Resource 2024 Squad Selection & Ratings
- Thread starter Dylan82
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Thread starter
- #353
Ok, let's get this back on track 
Whilst things have been getting updated fairly regularly, I've realised I have neglected to post the match selections from the past few rounds...
Here they are then:
Round 2 (vs Greater Western Sydney Giants @ Optus Stadium [Perth Stadium])
Round 3 (vs Fremantle Dockers @ Optus Stadium [Perth Stadium])
Round 4 (vs Melbourne Demons @ Optus Stadium [Perth Stadium])
A debut for Hewett, followed by an unchanged squad selection (the first since Round 7, 2020), which invoked the wrath of the football gods and injury carnage thereafter.
As a consequence, the best available team since Round 3 has fallen back into F rating territory.
Whilst things have been getting updated fairly regularly, I've realised I have neglected to post the match selections from the past few rounds...
Here they are then:
Round 2 (vs Greater Western Sydney Giants @ Optus Stadium [Perth Stadium])
Round 3 (vs Fremantle Dockers @ Optus Stadium [Perth Stadium])
Round 4 (vs Melbourne Demons @ Optus Stadium [Perth Stadium])
A debut for Hewett, followed by an unchanged squad selection (the first since Round 7, 2020), which invoked the wrath of the football gods and injury carnage thereafter.
As a consequence, the best available team since Round 3 has fallen back into F rating territory.
3agles87
Team Captain
- Feb 24, 2019
- 347
- 1,168
- AFL Club
- West Coast
WTF are these ratings. I already have Long as our best player. I did have him as top 5, so that’s a great result.Ok, let's get this back on track
Whilst things have been getting updated fairly regularly, I've realised I have neglected to post the match selections from the past few rounds...
Here they are then:
Round 2 (vs Greater Western Sydney Giants @ Optus Stadium [Perth Stadium])
View attachment 1661986
Round 3 (vs Fremantle Dockers @ Optus Stadium [Perth Stadium])
View attachment 1661987
Round 4 (vs Melbourne Demons @ Optus Stadium [Perth Stadium])
View attachment 1661989
A debut for Hewett, followed by an unchanged squad selection (the first since Round 7, 2020), which invoked the wrath of the football gods and injury carnage thereafter.
As a consequence, the best available team since Round 3 has fallen back into F rating territory.
- Thread starter
- #355
Ratings updated after Round 4.
Injuries continue to take their toll. Despite protestations from elsewhere in the competition, no club currently has as many players unavailable as West Coast.
Ginbey despite only playing 4 matches, is now ranked ahead of Sheed as the 3rd best inside midfielder at the club (behind Kelly and Shuey).
Elsewhere, generational change in the competition appears to be occurring as outside midfielder and small forward ranks are dominated by younger players.
Not sure what caused the dropdown option on that cell to disappear, but it's fixed now
Injuries continue to take their toll. Despite protestations from elsewhere in the competition, no club currently has as many players unavailable as West Coast.
Ginbey despite only playing 4 matches, is now ranked ahead of Sheed as the 3rd best inside midfielder at the club (behind Kelly and Shuey).
Elsewhere, generational change in the competition appears to be occurring as outside midfielder and small forward ranks are dominated by younger players.
Hey Dylan82 there's some kind of bug that won't let you change the selection of Jones on the bench.
I know he's a good player but didn't think he was a lock
Not sure what caused the dropdown option on that cell to disappear, but it's fixed now
- Thread starter
- #356
Squad Selection:
Round 5 (vs Geelong Cats @ Adelaide Oval)
Gather round in Adelaide for a mismatch of epic proportions.
Hurn is managed, whilst Hewett is omitted and Cole goes out with a complication of the injury that killed his 2022.
Making returns are Witherden, Petruccelle and O'Neill.
West is named as the substitute.
The selected squad has an average age of just 24.7
Round 5 (vs Geelong Cats @ Adelaide Oval)
Gather round in Adelaide for a mismatch of epic proportions.
Hurn is managed, whilst Hewett is omitted and Cole goes out with a complication of the injury that killed his 2022.
Making returns are Witherden, Petruccelle and O'Neill.
West is named as the substitute.
The selected squad has an average age of just 24.7
- Thread starter
- #357
Ratings updated after Round 5.
Just fold the club already. 17 players unavailable (with 6 more coming in as "test").
For the first time since this system was implemented in 2015, no West Coast player is represented in the rolling competition best 22.
Elsewhere, C.Oliver moves further ahead of the rest of those on top of the rankings and the key forward drought continues..
No tall playing forward is currently rated as A++ or A+ across the competition.
Just fold the club already. 17 players unavailable (with 6 more coming in as "test").
For the first time since this system was implemented in 2015, no West Coast player is represented in the rolling competition best 22.
Elsewhere, C.Oliver moves further ahead of the rest of those on top of the rankings and the key forward drought continues..
No tall playing forward is currently rated as A++ or A+ across the competition.
So Jeremy Cameron isn’t the best player in the competition after all?
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
- Thread starter
- #360
It's a product of his small number of rated matches (5) and the drop in output from the last two, which as a result are providing 40% of the score for his rating.
Those last two matches have come at an average of 5.5 contested possessions and 101 metres gained, so what that currently weighing as such a large proportion, his rating as an inside midfielder as fallen back dramatically as a result - so much that it is now (likely temporarily) below the ratings of West and Winder in their roles as small forwards.
That said, the Winder rating is preliminary also (based from 3 rated matches), and is skewed significantly by his 3 goal performance in Round 10 last year.
Ah yeah I forgot about Winder's good game last year! Fair enough
- Thread starter
- #362
Squad Selection:
Round 6 (vs Port AdelaideMagpies Power @ Adelaide Oval)
Back into South Australia, what could go wrong.
Four changes to a team that can barely field a side due to the ongoing injury crisis.
Yeo, Hough and Long join the injured ranks, whilst O'Neill suffers the ignominy of being dropped when there are no replacements.
Shuey comes in with duct tape holding his hamstring together and should be good to go for perhaps two quarters before it fails.
Trew and Foley are named for their first appearances this season.
Bazzo, also making his first 2023 showing, is named as the substitute - an interesting choice as he will likely be coming on for Shuey.
Needless to say, the selection isn't rated highly...
The squad might be coming back in barrels at this rate.
Round 6 (vs Port Adelaide
Back into South Australia, what could go wrong.
Four changes to a team that can barely field a side due to the ongoing injury crisis.
Yeo, Hough and Long join the injured ranks, whilst O'Neill suffers the ignominy of being dropped when there are no replacements.
Shuey comes in with duct tape holding his hamstring together and should be good to go for perhaps two quarters before it fails.
Trew and Foley are named for their first appearances this season.
Bazzo, also making his first 2023 showing, is named as the substitute - an interesting choice as he will likely be coming on for Shuey.
Needless to say, the selection isn't rated highly...
The squad might be coming back in barrels at this rate.
- Thread starter
- #363
Playing catch-up with short weeks.
Ratings updated after Round 6.
West Coast still can barely field any squad, lest a competitive one.
After just a handful of games into his second season, N.Daicos is now rated as the best outside midfielder in the competition.
Ratings updated after Round 6.
West Coast still can barely field any squad, lest a competitive one.
After just a handful of games into his second season, N.Daicos is now rated as the best outside midfielder in the competition.
- Thread starter
- #364
Squad Selection:
Round 7 (vs Carlton Blues @ Optus Stadium [Perth Stadium])
Just two changes this week.
Shuey [as expected] got through two quarters against Port last week before succumbing to injury again. Coming in to replace him is Hurn who missed the travels to his home state the past fortnight.
Trew finds himself omitted after just one match for O'Neill, the player he came in replace last week (and didn't even play at all for the reserves).
Bazzo is named as the substitute for the second week running.
The squad looks horrid. Rotham's 50th match seems destined to be a bloodbath.
Round 7 (vs Carlton Blues @ Optus Stadium [Perth Stadium])
Just two changes this week.
Shuey [as expected] got through two quarters against Port last week before succumbing to injury again. Coming in to replace him is Hurn who missed the travels to his home state the past fortnight.
Trew finds himself omitted after just one match for O'Neill, the player he came in replace last week (and didn't even play at all for the reserves).
Bazzo is named as the substitute for the second week running.
The squad looks horrid. Rotham's 50th match seems destined to be a bloodbath.
What ground, OK Coral?
Trew came in as XON was so poor - but Trew proved himself even less worthy. I think we are so outsized in defence we need Bazzo as sub. If fitter he should replace Rotham.
Horrid is what we have available - by spirited, hard working high morale horrid.
Last edited:
- Thread starter
- #366
Squad Selection:
Round 8 (vs Richmond Tigers @ M.C.G. [Melbourne Cricket Ground])
Just two changes, primarily because nobody else is available.
Sheed gets a return after being cleared to play and comes in for the suspended Petrevski-Seton.
Trew replaces concussion-hit Bazzo as the substitute.
Round 8 (vs Richmond Tigers @ M.C.G. [Melbourne Cricket Ground])
Just two changes, primarily because nobody else is available.
Sheed gets a return after being cleared to play and comes in for the suspended Petrevski-Seton.
Trew replaces concussion-hit Bazzo as the substitute.
- Thread starter
- #367
Ratings updated after Round 8.
Things still look decidedly ugly for West Coast.
Elsewhere, injuries are starting to mount their toll as well, particularly the reigning premiers, Geelong.
Things still look decidedly ugly for West Coast.
Elsewhere, injuries are starting to mount their toll as well, particularly the reigning premiers, Geelong.
- Thread starter
- #368
Squad Selection:
Round 9 (vs Gold Coast Suns @ Optus Stadium [Perth Stadium])
More changes forced by injury. There is some light in the news however with many players possibly returning over coming weeks.
Culley's improving season was prematurely cut short with an ACL and Hurn's old body is showing signs of wear and tear.
After being the substitute last week, Trew continues his yo-yoing in and out of the squad - playing rounds 6 & 8, but omitted in 7 & 9.
H.Edwards comes in to make his first appearance of the season, adding necessary height to an otherwise very undersized backline.
Joining him is Jamieson, who is named for the first time since Round 1 and Hough, returning after missing a month with a hamstring injury.
With his loads being managed, L.Edwards is moved out of the 22 and is expected to be named as the substitute.
The selected squad makes a slight improvement to be rated as 'E'.
Round 9 (vs Gold Coast Suns @ Optus Stadium [Perth Stadium])
More changes forced by injury. There is some light in the news however with many players possibly returning over coming weeks.
Culley's improving season was prematurely cut short with an ACL and Hurn's old body is showing signs of wear and tear.
After being the substitute last week, Trew continues his yo-yoing in and out of the squad - playing rounds 6 & 8, but omitted in 7 & 9.
H.Edwards comes in to make his first appearance of the season, adding necessary height to an otherwise very undersized backline.
Joining him is Jamieson, who is named for the first time since Round 1 and Hough, returning after missing a month with a hamstring injury.
With his loads being managed, L.Edwards is moved out of the 22 and is expected to be named as the substitute.
The selected squad makes a slight improvement to be rated as 'E'.
Last edited:
omgfridge
so tired, so wired
- Apr 10, 2011
- 13,540
- 33,582
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Tottenham, 49ers & Scorchers
Know you must have longevity of form in your formula but Allen as a C just seems off. 5th in goals competeion wide in such a s**t side is a great effort.
- Thread starter
- #370
Allen is currently rated as a 'C' in the Tall forward category due to his comparatively lower number of contested marks per game.
In the Small forward category however, he is currently rated as 'A-', despite only being rated across 8 matches.
Have updated the squad selection post above to reflect this.
- Thread starter
- #371
Squad Selection:
Round 10 (vs Hawthorn Hawks @ UTAS Stadium [York Park])
Travelling to Tasmania, F- across the board with an average squad age of 24.0
This was never going to end well.
Round 10 (vs Hawthorn Hawks @ UTAS Stadium [York Park])
Travelling to Tasmania, F- across the board with an average squad age of 24.0
This was never going to end well.
- Thread starter
- #372
Ratings updated after Round 10.
Whatever.
Another week of F-.
Summing up the decline of the club, Gaff falls into a D rating for the first time ever.
Whatever.
Another week of F-.
Summing up the decline of the club, Gaff falls into a D rating for the first time ever.
generous, considering his recent output...
xInfected_Virus
Team Captain
- Apr 23, 2020
- 516
- 2,495
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Wisconsin Badgers Women's Volleyball
What are the Hawks rating in comparison to before the match (or whenever you did the data whether it's before or after the match) compared to us because I'm pretty sure they have the same squad age as we do yet they look much better than we do even in previous matches.
They do have a pretty healthy team at the time unlike us.
