Best player from the 2016 Draft?

[Aristotle Pickett]

I would rate them from now on in this order.

1.Bolton
2.S.Darcy
3. English
4. Marshall
5. Taranto
7. Simpkin
8. Ridley
9. Powell-Pepper
10. McLuggage
11.Stewart
12. J.Daicos
13. McGrath
14. L.Ryan
15. Graham

 

[conrad_437]

I would rate them from now on in this order.

1.Bolton
2.S.Darcy
3. English
4. Marshall
5. Taranto
6. L.Ryan
7. Simpkin
8. Ridley
9. Powell-Pepper
10. McLuggage
11.Stewart
12. J.Daicos
13. McGrath
14. L.Ryan
15. Graham

Insane ranking of Stewart. I'd take 9 years of Stewart and 4+AA's over 15 years of SPP, Ridley, Simpkin and Luke Ryan at the very least.

 

[Lingsface]

If you take Stewart at 1 you have an older player who only has a few years left and who can get long suspensions so Stewart must be down the list imo.
I'd have S.Darcy and Marshall higher.

im talking redraft from initial age. also can get long suspensions is such a weak attempt at a dig lol.

 

[Aristotle Pickett]

im talking redraft from initial age. also can get long suspensions is such a weak attempt at a dig lol.

He's a loose canon. He knocked a bloke unconscious anf he pushed an injured player on the ground.

 

[Lingsface]

He's a loose canon. He knocked a bloke unconscious anf he pushed an injured player on the ground.

HAHA ok what do you call Marlon then?

 

[Aristotle Pickett]

HAHA ok what do you call Marlon then?

Good tough old fashioned footballer.

 

[Lingsface]

Good tough old fashioned footballer.

Like so old fashioned he didnt realise that locks had been invented?

 

[Aristotle Pickett]

Like so old fashioned he didnt realise that locks had been invented?

That's nothing to do with Stewart being a sniper who attacks injured players Marliion is tough but fair, Stewart plays uncontested footy and snipes.

 

[conrad_437]

Ah right. Should've known better than to assume that there was some logic to Stewart's low ranking, and instead it was just Richmond sour grapes over an incident everyone else has moved on from.

Does a rush of blood in an isolated game result in him logically being ranked lower than some comparatively average players?

I fear I am wasting my time with this post.

 

[Aristotle Pickett]

Insane ranking of Stewart. I'd take 9 years of Stewart and 4+AA's over 15 years of SPP, Ridley, Simpkin and Luke Ryan at the very least.

4 more years is another 80 games

 

[conrad_437]

4 more years is another 80 games

So a 200+ game career with at least 4 AAs and a premiership. How can you say any of the others should be ranked above?

 

[Aristotle Pickett]

So a 200+ game career with at least 4 AAs and a premiership. How can you say any of the others should be ranked above?

It is easier to get an All Australian as a defender at Geelong as they play nearly half their games at Kardinia park and the backman play a lot of uncontested footy. Eg Corey, Enright, Scarlett. Good players but about 18 All Australians between them.
Stewarts big game record is good but nothing outstanding.

 

[conrad_437]

It is easier to get an All Australian as a defender at Geelong as they play nearly half their games at Kardinia park and the backman play a lot of uncontested footy. Eg Corey, Enright, Scarlett. Good players but about 18 All Australians between them.
Stewarts big game record is good but nothing outstanding.

 

[Aristotle Pickett]

What an ugly incel type gif .

 

[conrad_437]

What an ugly incel type gif .

I think you’ll find that it’s exactly what the opinion warranted in response. What an incredibly stupid argument to resort to. It would’ve been more beneficial to not have responded at all. Two of the players you named are Hall of Famers. There is genuinely no logical explanation to back up your ranking. This is the embodiment of “throwing s**t at a wall and seeing what sticks”.

It’d be more honourable to admit that you’re a biased Richmond supporter who is sour about Stewart’s cheap shot last year.

 

[TheUnicorn]

I'm certain I have forgotten some people but here we go.

DEFENDERS

1. Stewart (40)
2. Ryan (66)
3. Ridley (22)
4. McGrath (1)
5. Florent (11)

MIDFIELDERS

1. Taranto (2)
2. Daicos (57)
3. McCluggage (3)
4. Simpkin (12)
5. Parfit (26)

FORWARDS

1. Bolton (29)
2. Larkey (73)
3. Marshall (16)
4. Ainsworth (4)
5. Powel Pepper (18)

RUCKMAN

1. English (19)
2. Darcy (38)
3. Cameron (48)

 

[Aristotle Pickett]

I think you’ll find that it’s exactly what the opinion warranted in response. What an incredibly stupid argument to resort to. It would’ve been more beneficial to not have responded at all. Two of the players you named are Hall of Famers. There is genuinely no logical explanation to back up your ranking. This is the embodiment of “throwing s**t at a wall and seeing what sticks”.

It’d be more honourable to admit that you’re a biased Richmond supporter who is sour about Stewart’s cheap shot last year.

Still an ugly juvenile gif to post. Stewart had an average GF and will be retired soon.

 

[conrad_437]

Still an ugly juvenile gif to post.

Yeah right. I’ll take gif advice from the bloke making a mockery of this thread

 

[Aristotle Pickett]

Yeah right. I’ll take gif advice from the bloke making a mockery of this thread

I don't care if you're a trump incel type but I'm entitled to my opinion. Stewart has had his peak years and will start to fade.
In 7 years time he will be down the pecking order from this draft imo, especially with players like Bolton, Darcy, English ready to peak.

 

[Elmer_Judd]

Tom Stewart than McLuggage.

 

[jasonrampage2010]

I would rate them from now on in this order.

1.Bolton
2.S.Darcy
3. English
4. Marshall
5. Taranto
7. Simpkin
8. Ridley
9. Powell-Pepper
10. McLuggage
11.Stewart
12. J.Daicos
13. McGrath
14. L.Ryan
15. Graham

Did u watch last night?

 

[Aristotle Pickett]

Did u watch last night?

Mcluggage has played 1 good game this year.

 

[Elmer_Judd]

Mcluggage has played 1 good game this year.

Could say the same about Bolton.

He was absolutely woeful last night.

 

[My Tilly]

Aristotle's lost the plot.

 

[KissKiss]

Mcluggage has played 1 good game this year.

Definitely started slowly to the year but has been getting back to form the last few weeks. And last night was a great example why he has been rated so highly for so long.

Between his consistent form over his career only really being behind Stewart from this draft, and games like last night show that anyone writing him off down the order for a redraft is nuts. He is still in the well in the argument for the top couple of players in this draft