Roast Should Richmond begin searching for Luke Meehan's replacement immediately?

[SplintWhisky]

I see, the dunk the witch method. If she survives that she is definitely a witch so you hang her. Sadly if she dies in the process of proving she wasn't a witch after all she is just collateral damage for the greater good.

Luke Meehan's job is listed as the Physical Performance Manager at the club. He is the head of the department that is clearly not doing their job. Take the Tarranto injury away but the rest of them fall directly under his mandate. Any organisation that has one department that is failing massively is going to be under scrutiny.

He is the head of the department. If he doesn't have the resources he needs then he is an ineffectual leader who is unable to manage resources. If he has the resources then he is just really s**t at his job. Maybe the guys was fantastic at his job and being a strength and conditioning coach under someone else was as high as he can ever be. Leppa is a perfect example.

 

[tigersnag]

Luke Meehan's job is listed as the Physical Performance Manager at the club. He is the head of the department that is clearly not doing their job. Take the Tarranto injury away but the rest of them fall directly under his mandate. Any organisation that has one department that is failing massively is going to be under scrutiny.

He is the head of the department. If he doesn't have the resources he needs then he is an ineffectual leader who is unable to manage resources. If he has the resources then he is just really s**t at his job. Maybe the guys was fantastic at his job and being a strength and conditioning coach under someone else was as high as he can ever be. Leppa is a perfect example.

He's as good as gone or 30k members will.
Absolutely hecking unacceptable!!!!

 

[TigerImposter]

Luke Meehan's job is listed as the Physical Performance Manager at the club. He is the head of the department that is clearly not doing their job. Take the Tarranto injury away but the rest of them fall directly under his mandate. Any organisation that has one department that is failing massively is going to be under scrutiny.

He is the head of the department. If he doesn't have the resources he needs then he is an ineffectual leader who is unable to manage resources. If he has the resources then he is just really s**t at his job. Maybe the guys was fantastic at his job and being a strength and conditioning coach under someone else was as high as he can ever be. Leppa is a perfect example.

Should’ve been moved on last year

 

[SavDog23]

Call me crazy but I reckon Meehan is a CFL secret agent sent in to destroy us from within.

 

[sante]

Give him a raise. He’s got his work cut out

 

[bd3_]

Not directly related to LukE, but his team of staff! WTF WAS JUDSON CLARKE DOING BACK ON THE FIELD AFTER AN ACL kicking for goal - no s**t he collapsed when he kicked it f*** me man. This is 1970’s stuff

 

[captain blood 17]

Meehan is gonna get us a top 2 draft pick. Brilliant strategy Tiges.

 

[Ancient Tiger]

Bring back Rob Innes?

 

[Cdog71]

Let’s keep him.
Still got a few listed players in the vfl in case anything goes wrong.

 

[prodigy]

This likely wasn't Meehan but just add it to the list of reasons why the whole department needs an overhaul.

 

[SunshineBoy]

Give him a raise. He’s got his work cut out

The only things he has cut out are hamstrings

 

[SunshineBoy]

Not directly related to LukE, but his team of staff! WTF WAS JUDSON CLARKE DOING BACK ON THE FIELD AFTER AN ACL kicking for goal - no s*t he collapsed when he kicked it f** me man. This is 1970’s stuff

The same ones that sent Tom Lunch back on with a broken foot

 

[SunshineBoy]

This likely wasn't Meehan but just add it to the list of reasons why the whole department needs an overhaul.

How the heck did they know it wasn’t done did they do a scan? If it was ok why strap him up like a mummy, club deflecting from scrutiny < piss weak

 

[prodigy]

How the * did they know it wasn’t done did they do a scan? If it was ok why strap him up like a mummy, club deflecting from scrutiny < piss weak

Doctors can typically tell if an ACL is intact by feel or in some other physical test.
I think it's worse that they sent him out after they confirmed no ACL damage. Why risk it?
I've heard stories of people playing with a torn ACL as they know it's going to be their last game for at least a year.

Our club doctors should have put him on ice straight away when he came off. Why tempt fate when we have almost more injured players than fit players.

 

[Mr Magic]

No, what are we sacrificing again??

 

[smasha]

"I have something that needs a raise,my finger blades" Louie Meehan

"That's my boy" CFL.

 

[captain blood 17]

 

[SouthernStripes]

Seems awfully coincidental that Judson went off with a knee problem, came back with it, strapped to high heaven and THEN does a season ending injury to the same knee kicking a set shot?

Maybe, given it was a fairly pointless VFL match taking a cautious approach would have been a better option and he should never have gone back on the ground.

 

[Tiger_4_Life]

How are people still defending this guy!! He used a f*** camel as our mascot with heat saunas and now we’re farked!!

Surely at this point only Johnny Cochrane is defending him

 

[TigerImposter]

"I have something that needs a raise,my finger blades" Louie Meehan

"That's my boy" CFL.

Welcome to the dark side Smasha.

 

[Groupie_]

louie meehan has cost us top 4

the fans knew something was wrong with the new guy last year. alcos on a forum knew it but the club was too stubborn to act

why did the club go the cheap route ?


whats the reason we didnt target the best in the business ? weve got plenty of money

add it to the plethora of benny gale co*k ups after becoming complacent after our dynasty

what do u expect when they tick off a fluro jumper with green, red and blue sponsors... you do that theres clearly something wrong

 

[prodigy]

This is exactly why I've been so abrasive on this issue. Richo explains it perfectly. You can have the best coach in the world but if your head of strength and conditioning is hopeless it's not going to matter.
This is the one position that should be a non-negotiable top liner, no dime spared type of person.

We are doing ourselves a disservice if we don't have the right people in this position as well as right practices.
When people come to the defense of this bloke like he is a relative or something is so bemusing to me. In this role you need to be beyond reproach and Meehan has a laundry list of questions that can be asked of him.

 

[Pattiger]

Doctors can typically tell if an ACL is intact by feel or in some other physical test.
I think it's worse that they sent him out after they confirmed no ACL damage. Why risk it?
I've heard stories of people playing with a torn ACL as they know it's going to be their last game for at least a year.

Our club doctors should have put him on ice straight away when he came off. Why tempt fate when we have almost more injured players than fit players.

What was at stake - a vfl match so important to risk a player that was blitzing them during preseason. When are they going to accept that the Preseason Training Program was absolutely stuffed ! The level of Injuries must reflect on the conditioning programs.

 

[TigerImposter]

Richo two years behind as usual.

 

[A Tiger 4 lyf]

meehan + the bye + a wendesday game = Meehans Grand Final