Mock Draft Results

[The Cotch]

Thanks to efcboy for organising the whole thing After a long 9 days this is how the draft panned out.....

ADELAIDE

10. Adelaide - Jackson Trengove
28. Adelaide - Ryan Schoenmakers
44. Adelaide - Chris Hall
60. Adelaide - Charlie Sharples
76. Adelaide - Phil Davis
92. Adelaide - Glen Dawson

BRISBANE

7. Brisbane - Sam Blease
25. Brisbane - Matt De Boer
41. Brisbane - Tom Rockliff
57. Brisbane - Dayne Beams
73. Brisbane - Jeff White
89. Brisbane - Dayne Zorko

CARLTON

6. Carlton - Jack Ziebell
24. Carlton - Rhys O'Keefe
40. Carlton - James Strauss
56. Carlton - Jayden Post
72. Carlton - Ashley Smith
88. Carlton - Michael Still

COLLINGWOOD

11. Collingwood - Shaun McKernan
29. Collingwood - Steve Gaertner
45. Collingwood - Dan Hannebery
61. Collingwood - Ben Cousins
77. Collingwood - Scott Reed
93. Collingwood - Andrew Renton

ESSENDON

5. Essendon - Hamish Hartlett
23. Essendon - Aaron Cornelius
39. Essendon - Riley Milne
55. Essendon - Zach Senstock
71. Essendon - Alex Stopp
87. Essendon - Aaron Purves

FREMANTLE

3. Fremantle - Nicholas Natanui
21. Fremantle - Michael Walters
37. Fremantle - Hayden Ballantyne
53. Fremantle - Liam Anthony
69. Fremantle - Kieran King
85. Fremantle - Adam Cockie

GEELONG

16. Geelong - Matthew Broadbent
34. Geelong - Clancee Pearce
50. Geelong - Mitchell Friall
66. Geelong - Nathan O'Keefe
82. Geelong - Scott Blesing
98. Geelong - Ranga Edwickirama (nsw scholarship)

HAWTHORN

15. Hawthorn - Nick Suban
33. Hawthorn - David Zaharakis
49. Hawthorn - Ben Speight
65. Hawthorn - Matt Kilpin
81. Hawthorn - Jarryd Blair
97. Hawthorn - Brett Wolfenden

NORTH MELBOURNE

9. North Melbourne - Steele Sidebottom
27. North Melbourne - Nick Heyne
43. North Melbourne - Rory Sloane
59. North Melbourne - Liam Shiels
75. North Melbourne - Tom Gillies
91. North Melbourne - Campbell Heath

MELBOURNE

1. Melbourne -Jack Watts
17. Melbourne - Steven Hill
19. Melbourne - Tom Swift
35. Melbourne - Liam Jones
51. Melbourne - Tom Hill
67. Melbourne - Andrew Browne
83. Melbourne - Pass

PORT ADELAIDE

4. Port Adelaide - Michael Hurley
22. Port Adelaide - Paul Cahill
38. Port Adelaide - Jarred Redden
54. Port Adelaide - Rhys Stanley
70. Port Adelaide - Jay Shannon
86. Port Adelaide - Pass

RICHMOND

8. Richmond - Tyrone Vickery
26. Richmond - Tom Lynch
42. Richmond - Luke Shuey
58. Richmond - Mitch Brown
74. Richmond - Robin Nahas
90. Richmond - Aaron Killian

ST KILDA

13. St Kilda - Mitch Robinson
31. St Kilda - Jordan Roughead
47. St Kilda - Tom Allwright
63. St Kilda - Alex Silvagni
79. St Kilda - Xavier Gotch
95. St Kilda - Tom Simpkin

SYDNEY

12. Sydney - Jordan Lisle
30. Sydney - Mitch Banner
46. Sydney - Damian Hynes
62. Sydney - Josh Nesbitt
78. Sydney - Brodie A'Vard
94. Sydney - Casey Sibosado

WEST COAST

2. West Coast - Daniel Rich
18. West Coast - Chris Yarran
20. West Coast - Jamie Sheahan
36. West Coast - Neville Jetta
52. West Coast - Jake Walsh
68. West Coast - Will Young
84. West Coast - Jordan Jones

WESTERN BULLDOGS

14. Western Bulldogs - Lewis Johnston
32. Western Bulldogs - Ayce Cordy
48. Western Bulldogs - Kade Klemke
64. Western Bulldogs - Jarrod Blight
80. Western Bulldogs - Bart McCulloch
96. Western Bulldogs - Sam McGarry



So, who were the big winners, the big losers and how did you rate each clubs, or your own clubs performance?

 

[whelan=legend]

Hill at 17? Don't know about that...

 

[Prem87]

Westcoast, Melbourne, Richmond & Freo are the winners.

Very happy with Rich, Yarran & Jetta.

 

[sinepari]

If only Yarran were available in the current trial.

Jetta @ 36 is a steal.

 

[Aarick13]

looks pretty good. although i dont think eagles will use any picks after 36. they dont have enough space on the roster. otherwise we need to cut more players. as it is to use pick 36 i still think someone needs to be cut.

ben cousins is going into the pre-season draft i think. so collingwood wont use a draft pick on him.

ayce cordy will be going in the first round. i think at least one team below 14 will bid for him. he is a great yound prospect so it would not make sense to let him go in the 2nd round. if said team gets him with thier pick good for them they got a great prospect if not it forces bulldogs to use thier first rounder on him making them unable to strengthen thier team as much as possible.

and i dont think adam cockie will go so low.

but other then that looks pretty good

 

[smilingassassin6]

doubt very highly that Robin Nahas will get drafted lol

 

[r_boy]

Sidebottom and Heyne would make me very, very happy.

 

[-VC-]

Carlton made everyone their bitches.

 

[Souup]

58. Richmond - Mitch Brown

Steal if it happened.

 

[eskimo123]

Jarrod Blight at 64? I think this kid is much better then that if its the one from SD that im thinking about.
No Alistair Smith from Perth? I believe he is near a certainty to get picked up, but otherwise fun read non the less.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

I see Dave The Man must have been selecting for Collingwood. Not sure how we take Renton after Reed.

 

[Salaryman]

Westcoast, Melbourne, Richmond & Freo are the winners.

Very happy with Rich, Yarran & Jetta.

LOL, you have to be joking, like VicCrow said, Cruiser23 totally wiped the floor for Carlton

 

[Brent24]

Minus the fact we took McKernan, not bad.

 

[jackoisno1]

Adam Cockie Mitch Brown and Kade Klemke are abit of a steal

 

[Lazarus]

Minus the fact we took McKernan, not bad.

i heard north is gonna take mckernan with first rounder

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

Steele and Nick will be great additions to north, how did Shuey drop to 42?.......i though he'd go late 2nd rnd.

Jetta at 36 is a steal

Gaertner at 29.........hmmmmmm thought he'd go a little later than that, but looks good

 

[ant555]

ESSENDON

5. Essendon - Hamish Hartlett - No problems here. Classy mid who is a good fit.

23. Essendon - Aaron Cornelius- Not sure how we end up with another forward who has question marks on his pace and agility. With Gumbleton, Neagle and Daniher as developing forwards already on the list i do not see us taking Cornelius in the second round.To top it of personally i think he is over rated. Given the way the results fell here in this mock i would have been looking at Tom Lynch here.

39. Essendon - Riley Milne- Possibly a bit high. If i went for Lynch second round then this pick would probaly have been a mid. Possibly Speight, Allwright , Klemke .

55. Essendon - Zach Senstock- Not bad for this spot but in saying that Post went with the next pick and i rate him a better prospect.

71. Essendon - Alex Stopp- would be a very good get here

87. Essendon - Aaron Purves- even though he is another forward he would be a good get in this position.

Overall not too bad

 

[efcboy]

ESSENDON

5. Essendon - Hamish Hartlett - No problems here. Classy mid who is a good fit.

23. Essendon - Aaron Cornelius- Not sure how we end up with another forward who has question marks on his pace and agility. With Gumbleton, Neagle and Daniher as developing forwards already on the list i do not see us taking Cornelius in the second round.To top it of personally i think he is over rated. Given the way the results fell here in this mock i would have been looking at Tom Lynch here.

39. Essendon - Riley Milne- Possibly a bit high. If i went for Lynch second round then this pick would probaly have been a mid. Possibly Speight, Allwright , Klemke .

55. Essendon - Zach Senstock- Not bad for this spot but in saying that Post went with the next pick and i rate him a better prospect.

71. Essendon - Alex Stopp- would be a very good get here

87. Essendon - Aaron Purves- even though he is another forward he would be a good get in this position.

Overall not too bad

cheers!

had port not taken hurley that would have changed everything - it was important to hypothetically go safety in numbers with key defenders after missing hurley but i didn't think the available ones warranted pick 5 or 23 at the time.

re cornelius there are no guarantees that any of neagle, gumby or daniher will make it due to injury and/or ability. not sure we can afford to bank on them at present although i am gumbys biggest fan. cornelius could be more the ryan o'keefe type with gumby or neagle closer to the square.

 

[ant555]

cheers!

had port not taken hurley that would have changed everything - it was important to hypothetically go safety in numbers with key defenders after missing hurley but i didn't think the available ones warranted pick 5 or 23 at the time.

re cornelius there are no guarantees that any of neagle, gumby or daniher will make it due to injury and/or ability. not sure we can afford to bank on them at present although i am gumbys biggest fan. cornelius could be more the ryan o'keefe type with gumby or neagle closer to the square.

Just not a big fan of Cornelius. He was passed over last year in a draft that had no real depth in its talls and although he was solid in this years champs he still showed there is questions on his pace and agility. He leads, he marks and he kicks goals inside 40. Don't see him as an okeefe type at all. Do not think he has the motor to play that role.
As far as banking on Gumby , Neagle and Daniher. Well we have drafted them all over the last 3 years so you can not look as an outsider and say we may not be able to bank on them. They will be on our list becasue our recruting staff think they can make it. If you are not banking on them making it then you are probably looking to trade them and not draft more to take their place before they are gone.

 

[Salaryman]

Cornelius was ineligible last year bud

 

[HBF]

CARLTON

6. Carlton - Jack Ziebell
24. Carlton - Rhys O'Keefe
40. Carlton - James Strauss
56. Carlton - Jayden Post
72. Carlton - Ashley Smith
88. Carlton - Michael Still

Ding ding ding - we have a winner.
Strauss at 40 is a massive steal.

 

[Salaryman]

Ding ding ding - we have a winner.
Strauss at 40 is a massive steal.

Yep, cause 72's around the mark for Ash Smith

 

[Dave The Man]

I see Dave The Man must have been selecting for Collingwood. Not sure how we take Renton after Reed.

They did not list him as a NSW Scholaship Player

 

[vlbl]

Carlton is the winner by a mile, they get 3 potential superstars in Ziebell, O'keefe and Strauss with their 1st 3 and then and finish off with some very hand players with the other 3.

 

[CHBench]

props to cruiser23.
extremely well played.

Looking back now i should've gone Cordy in front of Roughead. Cordy completely skipped my mind. I'll be better prepared next time.