denishurley
Debutant
Even from here you can see it looks quite basic, the jumper doesn't even look to have folds like the original
Discussion Jumpers That Never Were
- Thread starter Silent Alarm
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Mero
Norm Smith Medallist
The designers didn't give the club much choice, it's just 2 variations of 2 designs and the first 2 are just training jumpers.
I actually think C would have been the best out of those. It looks less like a stretched sash and more like a red jumper with 2 black triangles which kind of works in a way. Plus it's more effective as a clash jumper.
I actually think C would have been the best out of those. It looks less like a stretched sash and more like a red jumper with 2 black triangles which kind of works in a way. Plus it's more effective as a clash jumper.
BennyW
All Australian
They all look crap
Omegaville
Club Legend
^^ This. It reeks of no-effort.
I actually really like B.Melbourne had a vote between these 2 for their 2009/10 clash jumper.
I preferred A at the time but I'd probably go for B now, even if it is very uninspired.
- Oct 4, 2007
- 5,171
- 1,863
- AFL Club
- West Coast
n they choose D have got one , would not be many of these around
- Oct 4, 2007
- 5,171
- 1,863
- AFL Club
- West Coast
finally found a pic
as yous said. its easy to work out a player issue. normally fabric is totally different. and cut. here is a essendon 07 dreamtime , not the bombers logo in the fabric. this is player worn as it was given personally from the player who wore it other than that i would have no point to prove
- Moderator
- #59
Jonny W in a freo jumper Yuk! and only time hungury jacks would be a freo jumper!
[URL=http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/52/jannyx.png/]
Note here that the red and green panels are reversed. Perhaps an early concept.
Thanks heaps Mero
BennyW
All Australian
I cant beleive Mellbourne didnt go with option B, looks way better and represents their heritage.
Mero
Norm Smith Medallist
I have Matty Lloyd's Clash jumper.
When I say "I", I mean my teenage son.
But I got it for him.
When I say "I", I mean my teenage son.
But I got it for him.
Omegaville
Club Legend
^^ This reeks of no effort - no effort in trying to construct a paragraph.
It was an online poll from memory. It doesn't really matter because their current one is much better anyway.
These were the three clash strip options that Geelong made available on their website for fans to choose from for the 2007 season. Obviously the middle one was selected over the other two.
I think the right choice was made. The one on the left looks like a training guernsey and the one on the right is a bit lazy and only a variation on the 1999-2004 away guernsey.
Mero
Norm Smith Medallist
Was it anything like the StKilda poll?
The jumper I designed, with the chevrons down the sides was leading the poll with one day to go.
And when they announced the decision it was the other jumper by something like 60% to 40%.
My thoughts were they had decided on the one they wanted, and ran the other one to make it look like the fans had a say.
Not bitter, wasn't getting anything out of it, so it doesn't matter, and I don't barrack for StKilda, but I was taking an interest because of the design, and they definitely pulled a swifty.
- Oct 4, 2007
- 5,171
- 1,863
- AFL Club
- West Coast
2nd time you have had a go at somone saying the exact same thing!
If you have nothing posiTive to contribute >> theres the logout button.
N btw wat person who is so good at pointing the finger has a 711 sign as there dp . That has nothing to do with football. Please show a picture relevant to this forum as i can see no effort
gone into that picture u hav just googled a image the slurpee. Forum is thata way sir>>>>
Mero
Norm Smith Medallist
I hated that jumper in the middle.
These were the three clash strip options that Geelong made available on their website for fans to choose from for the 2007 season. Obviously the middle one was selected over the other two.
I think the right choice was made. The one on the left looks like a training guernsey and the one on the right is a bit lazy and only a variation on the 1999-2004 away guernsey.
I went to Rebel at Knox and took a pic of that when it came out.
It was early in the year, because it was hot when I was trying to trace it for the website.
Took me about a week and it looked like crap.
Then I found out about Vector Magic doing beta testing and uploaded it.
Came out pretty much perfect.
I don't remember anything dodgy about it. I think a lot of fans wanted a return of the Demon after they had oversimplified their logo so I'd believe that it won fairly.
With all of these clash jumper options though they never to give the voters much to choose from. A lot of these look like they were designed in half an hour at most without any brainstorming of ideas at all.
tassielions
Debutant
- Nov 12, 2009
- 122
- 35
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Fitzroy Football Club
I concur go roys
I had a cute alien dog thing as my avatar before the designathon. Is that relevant to footy graphic design????? Don't think so, mate.
^^@wce
BennyW
All Australian
I'm glad Geelong chose the middle one, looks much better then the other two. I even bought it. My first ever LEGIT Geelong Jersey <3
