Opinion Which club do you hate the most?

[Irish BlueBagger]

I find it hilarious that Carlton supporters jerk off over having 16 flags but Pies supporters get laughed at when we bring up flags from the same era a century ago. Its a shame Carlton's best season this century resulted in a Collingwood premiership.

We were just happy to see the giant start to awaken again. The Pies flag win was bit of a downer alright!

A club can only sustain itself on past glories from thirty to forty years ago for so long though. Ideally you need to be winning a flag at least once every five years.

 

[Pistol Night]

Look up passionate, joyful and loyal - take these 4 tribes out of AFL and there is NO AFL

Agreed. Without Carlton, Essendon and Richmond a Pies supporters passion would be heavily diluted. Carlton supporters always have a bit of fire in them even in the lean times and get the balance between severe loathing and healthy respect just right. Richmond won 3 flags and still seem over the top insecure for some reason

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

Agreed. Without Carlton, Essendon and Richmond a Pies supporters passion would be heavily diluted. Carlton supporters always have a bit of fire in them even in the lean times and get the balance between severe loathing and healthy respect just right. Richmond won 3 flags and still seem over the top insecure for some reason

It's a big reason why the Hawks are so far down the hatred list for me. Hawthorn winning a flag just doesn't get me as worked up as a Pies, Bombers and Tigers flag!

For both Carlton and Collingwood fans i really think any rivalry with the Hawks, Cats, and Demons, is that bit lower down the richter scale in comparison to our fellow big four rivals.

 

[Beerfish]

My mate, a Pies supporter, simply cannot stand Bombers supporters.

Your mate sounds like a bit of a dickhead.

 

[Giant Pete]

Your mate sounds like a bit of a dickhead.

Yeah I don’t really get it… I’m not wasting my energy on lowly, non competitive clubs.

 

[Pistol Night]

It's a big reason why the Hawks are so far down the hatred list for me. Hawthorn winning a flag just doesn't get me as worked up as a Pies, Bombers and Tigers flag!

For both Carlton and Collingwood fans i really think any rivalry with the Hawks, Cats, and Demons, is that bit lower down the richter scale in comparison to our fellow big four rivals.

Yeah Hawthorn didnt really bother me. Richmond either to be honest. Carlton or Essendon winning a flag would boil my piss so i think that says it all

 

[Beerfish]

Yeah I don’t really get it… I’m not wasting my energy on lowly, non competitive clubs.

Yeah I suppose if you did you might not have any time left to waste on unsuccessful clubs.

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

Yeah I suppose if you did you might not have any time left to waste on unsuccessful clubs.

Unsuccessful clubs that have managed to win at least one finals game in the last twenty years though.

 

[JustaBattler]

Agreed. Without Carlton, Essendon and Richmond a Pies supporters passion would be heavily diluted. Carlton supporters always have a bit of fire in them even in the lean times and get the balance between severe loathing and healthy respect just right. Richmond won 3 flags and still seem over the top insecure for some reason

4 years of schoolboy football played better than any other team could match it or figure out how to run as hard each way against it and then teh Distin Martin factor able to beat better teams all by himself , proved it was no fluke with 2 more - they got all chest puffy as most would.

Enjoy your flag - no other supporting base is celebrating it mumble mumble...

2024 is another year and there are no guarantees for any CLub - competition is getting squeezy tight - so a flag win is gold.

 

[longdonkey]

Yeah Hawthorn didnt really bother me. Richmond either to be honest. Carlton or Essendon winning a flag would boil my piss so i think that says it all

I didn't like the way that Richmond's crowd increased by 50,000 2 weeks after being s**t for 30 years.

 

[Call Me Cake]

My mate, a Pies supporter, simply cannot stand Bombers supporters.

Maybe it's because we haven't won a final in 20 years and we're still level on premierships.

 

[Beerfish]

Unsuccessful clubs that have managed to win at least one finals game in the last twenty years though.

Celebrating a semi final win like a premiership on Lygon Street only helps to remind what Carlton supporters are truly like

 

[Madas]

This poll is so rigged

Obviously not many voters on here have met West Coast Supporters or know much about their s**t toxic club .

If they did the title of this Fred would be “ Why is West Coast the Most Hated Club ?”

 

[Woolly Mammoth]

This poll is so rigged

Obviously not many voters on here have met West Coast Supporters or know much about their s**t toxic club .

If they did the title of this Fred would be “ Why is West Coast the Most Hated Club ?”

Honestly Victorians get the general idea, they can be a seriously nasty lot, but it can't ever hold a candle to our various own crosstown hatreds.

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

This poll is so rigged

Obviously not many voters on here have met West Coast Supporters or know much about their s**t toxic club .

If they did the title of this Fred would be “ Why is West Coast the Most Hated Club ?”

I don't like the Eagles either mate, but for me the Eagles are behind the Bombers, Pies and Tigers in the hatred stakes.

They are my most disliked interstate club by the length of the flemington straight though!

 

[Legend255]

Carlton and Essendon. Hard to split when they are both flying. I’m not sure which one I got more enjoyment from when Elliott sunk them both by a kick. The biggest and best games. I probably hate Carlton the club and tradition more, but the Essendon supporters more. The other clubs I couldn’t GAF about. They are just wins.

 

[TheUnicorn]

Carlton and Essendon. Hard to split when they are both flying. The biggest and best games. I probably hate Carlton the club and tradition more, but the Essendon supporters more. The other clubs I couldn’t GAF about. They are just wins.

Why you hate me?

 

[Beerfish]

Carlton and Essendon. Hard to split when they are both flying. I’m not sure which one I got more enjoyment from when Elliott sunk them both by a kick. The biggest and best games. I probably hate Carlton the club and tradition more, but the Essendon supporters more. The other clubs I couldn’t GAF about. They are just wins.

Tldr; Carlton

 

[JackFlash]

Hate is a pretty strong word, but i do dislike the following:
Adelaide
Brisbane
Carlton
Collingwood
Essendon
Fremantle
Gold Coast
Greater Wester Sydney
Hawthorn
Melbourne
North Melbourne
Port Adelaide
Richmond
St.Kilda
Sydney
West Coast
Western Bulldogs

Those that are bolded i have a little more derision for than the others...

 

[Madas]

Glad this thread got bumped

Carlton

 

[Beerfish]

Glad this thread got bumped

Carlton

It's difficult to argue with this.

 

[NetworkNerd]

BigFooty will be renamed FlogFooty if Carlton win the flag

 

[Madas]

BigFooty will be renamed FlogFooty if Carlton win the flag

I’ll probably move to another country till they resume their rightful place as try hard pretenders

No way I could deal with the Carlton Flogs and the VAFL media

 

[YeoShuey]

Usually the most hated team is because other club supporters are jealous of them. Unsure I can say that about Essendon though.

 

[ElectricG]

Why do people hate Essendon and Carlton lol