Strategy Trade and List Management Thread Part 7 (opposition supporters - READ posting rules before posting)

[Del203211]

May is 33 what’s he gonna do replace Jones or Lobb for zero years?

Yeah not the answer sadly. Need someone in their mid 20s

 

[The Inbetweener]

The Rowell to Victoria stuff is very much linked to if Suns play finals

Dogs can get the capital to get both Butters and Rowell
But would require a lot of movement with future trading

Esp with Suns having some strong academy players over the next two drafts

Fascinated the see how we’d get the trade capital. Assuming it means trying to move Marra as we’d need multiple 1st for both Butters and Rowell.

 

[Golden_6]

If Dees play their cards right

They could get 9-12 picks over the next three drafts now that future trading has relaxed it's ruling

How? Most of their guys have no value.

Petracca is 2 first rounders at most and he’s nearly 30. Gawn & May are old and don’t hold that sort of currency. Oliver is a negative value and Salem is cooked.

The only way they get quality picks is trading away high end young talent like Pickett but all the sudden they’re looking at a North Melbourne scenario.

 

[Golden_6]

Fascinated the see how we’d get the trade capital. Assuming it means trying to move Marra as we’d need multiple 1st for both Butters and Rowell.

No chance we would get both.

Both guys will each cost at least our next two first rounders plus another quality pick that we would have to acquire.

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

Have we even been linked to him in the media?

Only that his still good friends with Cody

 

[VitalDread]

How? Most of their guys have no value.

Petracca is 2 first rounders at most and he’s nearly 30. Gawn & May are old and don’t hold that sort of currency. Oliver is a negative value and Salem is cooked.

The only way they get quality picks is trading away high end young talent like Pickett but all the sudden they’re looking at a North Melbourne scenario.

Oliver, Pickett and Trac would easily be around 9 picks

Pickett would command two first rounders, Oliver if he keeps up his stats is two rounders
Trac is a legit star and people would pay overs

Plus late end picks swapping and moving up

I could see North having another crack at Viney as well

 

[Bulldog1954]

Oliver, Pickett and Trac would easily be around 9 picks

Pickett would command two first rounders, Oliver if he keeps up his stats is two rounders
Trac is a legit star and people would pay overs

Plus late end picks swapping and moving up

I could see North having another crack at Viney as well

No way would Oliver be worth 2 first rounders when he is on a million a year until 2030, that's a terrible deal.

Viney has been rubbish this season and it's possible that the game may have passed him by, not sure him and Oliver in the same midfield works anymore. He has 3 years to go on his deal after this, he's almost negative value.

 

[cecil]

Pickett- 2 firsts
Oliver - 1 late first
Petracca - 1 decent first, or a late 1st and a second.

May, Salem et all are worth token late picks.

I can see Goodwin going and them trading all 3 big names.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Is May a flog? Or has flog tendencies? Genuinely curious

Yes very much so. Gun player though.

 

[manutd/dogs]

I don't think I could stomach Steven May playing for the Dogs.

 

[JohnnySteel]

I don't think I could stomach Steven May playing for the Dogs.

Too old. I wouldn’t go near Melbourne’s has beens.

 

[MaxiBont]

Pickett- 2 firsts
Oliver - 1 late first
Petracca - 1 decent first, or a late 1st and a second.

May, Salem et all are worth token late picks.

I can see Goodwin going and them trading all 3 big names.

Trac definitely still worth 2 firsts at least

 

[bobs head soup]

Start getting to work on this bloke. There’s no chance he’s staying at Melbourne.

To be honest, If we were 0-3 I'd expect that reaction from a senior player.

What really galls is seeing them smiling and chatting carefree with the opposition after a bad loss.

 

[DognBones]

I wouldn't pay high draft picks for any of the Melbourne players mentioned above. I think they're all on the downward curve. Overpriced and now over-rated. The only one I'd be interested in is Lever who would be handy for us for a few years as an intercepting half back but he's still contracted til 2028 so not likely going anywhere.

 

[cecil]

Trac definitely still worth 2 firsts at least

Nah he's 30 before the season starts next year.

 

[Lindsay_Gilbee]

Nah he's 30 before the season starts next year.

If Bont wanted out what do you think he’s worth? They’re the same level of player.

 

[Nath09]

If Bont wanted out what do you think he’s worth? They’re the same level of player.

Only if it’s quite a large and broad level.

 

[Lindsay_Gilbee]

Only if it’s quite a large and broad level.

Sure. Petracca is the only person over the last 5 year who has come near Bont’s level. The bloke is a super super super star. Easily worth two picks in the 8-16 range.

 

[VitalDread]

If Bont wanted out what do you think he’s worth? They’re the same level of player.

Well he's unrestricted
So only one first rounder this year

 

[Munnez]

Too old. I wouldn’t go near Melbourne’s has beens.

Yep if we are replacing Jones and Lobb we need to do it with younger options. Not sure who is available that fits that bill Aleer maybe?

 

[Golden_6]

If Bont wanted out what do you think he’s worth? They’re the same level of player.

I will say that Petracca hasn’t proven that he’s the same level of player he once was since his very serious injury last year.

 

[Anja_Nees]

Pickett- 2 firsts
Oliver - 1 late first
Petracca - 1 decent first, or a late 1st and a second.

May, Salem et all are worth token late picks.

I can see Goodwin going and them trading all 3 big names.

As bad as they’ve been, they risk falling into WC territory getting rid all all their prime movers, particularly with Gawn and Viney looking like they’re in major decline.

I reckon they’ll flog one and keep the rest.

 

[Iamspock]

Petracca’s Body language going back weeks now has been appalling and super visual. I remember a damning shot last week in the forward fifty, where he looked absolutely distraught and seemed to be one bad play/decision away from becoming a loose cannon.

He wants out of that Footy club so bad, he can’t be bothered to even hide it anymore. Makes me grateful to the Josh Dunkley’s of the league.

However, l do feel for Dees’s supporters. I remember the visual of Bont throwing his mouth guard on the turf so hard it sprung back into frame a few years ago. Not a good feeling.

You're better than me, the only feelings I have for Melbourne and their fans after their classless carry-on, is contempt.

 

[W W Biscuit]

To be honest, If we were 0-3 I'd expect that reaction from a senior player.

What really galls is seeing them smiling and chatting carefree with the opposition after a bad loss.

I don't mind seeing a player showing that they really, really care. There are worse things.

 

[Lindsay_Gilbee]

I will say that Petracca hasn’t proven that he’s the same level of player he once was since his very serious injury last year.

It’s been four games