List Mgmt. Trade and Free Agency Discussion 2018 - Edition V - TRADE SUMMARY IN OP

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

Rather have Hogan if it was me. He wanted to go though. Not much tgey could do.
I guess not.
May is overrated but might be OK when Lever gets back.
KK is stagnated but then so has everyone at GC.
 
Brisbane have done really well thus far. I hope they don't ruin it by giving Beams back to Collingwood after what they had to give up to get him.

Not just what they gave up to get him,also the fact they frontloaded his $$.

What's is that saying? You can take the boy from the Pies but you can't take the Pie from the boy.
 
they are already players in our best 22.
what if we get a couple of midfield injuries. that's depth. who comes in from the vfl to play midfield. miles could have easily but luckily didn't need him for mid cover. Lloyd did come in and played mainly when we wanted to rest someone form midfield. there is no straight swap, VFL mid to come in and play AFL mid.
possibly caddy and Edwards can move acorss, but to ask them to play 80% mid, when they usually play 40% mid (just round estimates) is a step up....

Mate, we had midfielder challenges this year in particular and Miles came in once. Like you said Lloyd didn’t play in the middle. It’s very unlikely that a VFL player walks into the seniors team midfield. Prime example Townsend came in dominating all year in the twos winning the Liston as a midfielder and comes in as a forward. Does well, kicks a bag and wins a flag but as a forward.

You work with your best 22 and have the depth play their roles. We may not have a strong VFL side next year but our depth will be solid.
 
Last edited:

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I guess not.
May is overrated but might be OK when Lever gets back.
KK is stagnated but then so has everyone at GC.

Melbourne has just added the final piece of the puzzle to their list, May for pick is steal on its own IMO
 
I guess not.
May is overrated but might be OK when Lever gets back.
KK is stagnated but then so has everyone at GC.
Actually think May is best in the same role Lever plays, only thing is Lever does it way better.
Don’t rate May as a stopper at all, who knows might do better in a team that’s not shitful like the Suns.
 
Presume Adelaide still desperate for pick 2 or 3.
Could offer 8 & 13 to Gold Coast for either.
GC could then almost get King twins for 6 & 8 ( if they are interested)

574585_d133b16df8e3ca10e385d2feece93f71.png
 
Melbourne has just added the final piece of the puzzle to their list, May for pick is steal on its own IMO
Tend to agree with this. May can seriously play but at that shit truck it's easy for it to all fall apart. He frees up Lever, rolls Frost and O.McDonald down one KPF...they'll be top 2 challengers now.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top