Analysis The Rebuilds of Geelong and Richmond and their Future Prospects

[STPer18]

Win-win Holmes won.

 

[Black Saab]

I'm nervous about the Bailey Smith recruitment and think going after Oliver is probably a mistake.

But getting to read so many utterly unhinged, batshit crazy rants like this one makes me think it's all worth it.

You have over 330 posts in this sh*t thread. Just think about that for a moment. Unbelievable.

 

[Wojcinski]

You have over 330 posts in this sh*t thread. Just think about that for a moment. Unbelievable.

Is it a shit thread because people think Geelong has better future prospects than Richmond?

 

[Fadge]

That's partly my point. Nearly every other team doesn't continue that great run. Why? Because it's almost impossible to do so. Geelong somehow manages it over and over.

No matter how good other teams can be when they get their moment in the sun, the sun fades and they get recycled back down the ladder. And it happens to pretty much EVERY other team other than the Cats.

Except Sydney and Collingwood have also finished top 4 as often as they haven't since the turn of the century.

What conspiracy theories do you have about them being able to regenerate on the run without the need to spend multiple decades at a time outside the top 8 and being non-competitive?

 

[MisterMarcus]

As I and many many others have said all season, the only 'old blokes' who'd be in our best this year would be Cameron, Stewart and Dangerfield.

Lo and behold that's exactly what happened, only 3 old dudes in the Top 10 of our B&F.

Everyone else is 26 or younger (Zuthrie, Miers, Close, Stengle, Holmes, Dempsey and Henry)

 

[PhatBoy]

That's partly my point. Nearly every other team doesn't continue that great run. Why? Because it's almost impossible to do so. Geelong somehow manages it over and over.

No matter how good other teams can be when they get their moment in the sun, the sun fades and they get recycled back down the ladder. And it happens to pretty much EVERY other team other than the Cats.

Bailey Smith AND Clayton Oliver choose Manchester City. Yeah right. In a competition leveled by the salary cap there must be a helluva lot of wheeling and dealing behind the scenes in other areas to keep Geelong in endless supply.

I'm sure if this was Sydney or West Coast some new sanctions would be invented to nullify the deals.

Because we try to. Every team does to a degree but many when they see the writing on the wall decide enough is enough and clean things out. Sydney are the same.

Why should we be sanctioned for it? Because we are going to possibly trade in a new player having not traded in any new player last year?

Hawthorn just finished a game behind us - by a couple of points - and are about to bring in Josh Battle who while not elite is a good strong footballer and Tom Barrass who I would say is bordering on elite. They’d just brought in Jack Ginnivan - a knob but a fairly talented flag player, Massimo Dambrosio, Mabior Chol and Jack Gunston this season.

I’m not saying any of the current versions of those players are as good as what we are trying to get but they’re all - Dambrosio is the best of them and made an AA squad. But what makes their acquisition of 6 players any more fair than our acquisition of 3? We didn’t pick anyone up for this year.

 

[Footy Smarts]

You have over 330 posts in this sh*t thread. Just think about that for a moment. Unbelievable.

I admit needling deluded Richmond fans is a guilty pleasure of mine. You've certainly delivered on that!

With almost 6,500 posts on this site it looks like you've got plenty of shit threads you like to post in too.

 

[Cursed Cat]

Taken out by an ancient Max Holmes and pensioner Zac Guthrie in second

Bit of a concern seeing the old guard still propping us up.

 

[PhatBoy]

Bit of a concern seeing the old guard still propping us up.

Time for a clean out

 

[CatToTheFuture]

Interesting that Meteoric Ruse is all about finals performances, until it's a discussion about a young Geelong player who had an influential final.

Then it's all about home and away performances (where Henry's 'stats' are relatively impressive for a young, mid sized forward anyway).

Oh my.

You see what we have to put with?

 

[STPer18]

Wow, those BnF results for a top 4, preliminary final team are pretty impressive. This one is going to be hard to twist by our Tiggie friends. Maybe the Geelong coaches just manipulated the votes to specifically troll you?

 

[PhatBoy]

Wow, those BnF results for a top 4, preliminary final team are pretty impressive. This one is going to be hard to twist by our Tiggie friends. Maybe the Geelong coaches just manipulated the votes to specifically troll you?

Given their reliance on a conspiracy theory to get through their day to day existence it wouldn’t surprise me if they went there

 

[MisterMarcus]

Wow, those BnF results for a top 4, preliminary final team are pretty impressive. This one is going to be hard to twist by our Tiggie friends. Maybe the Geelong coaches just manipulated the votes to specifically troll you?

Steve Hocking the puppet master behind the scenes yet again.

 

[joe444]

It's so funny coming back these threads after spending time on the Draft/Trade board.

There = Geelong have such a start-studded list on every line that they MUST be rorting the salary cap!!

Here = Geelong's good players are all old blokes who are out the door, and they have only mediocre B-graders coming through!!

It's got to the point of tedium, like that poster who claimed Geelong is like the "EPL madness"; no, Geelong just do the off-field stuff better than other clubs. It wasn't always the case...

Now, twenty years ago isn't exactly the stone age, so for our idiot friend who thinks Geelong are the evil empire:

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Cats B & F placings for young players fake news.

Holmes had an outstanding season, no arguments there, polled appreciably better than recent winners.

The only other 2 young players to finish top 10 were Oli Dempsey, who averaged 3 out of 10 available votes per game played, and Oli Henry, who averaged much the same. Those are nothing results beating nobody of any note who played sufficient games to be in the mix. They beat Blicavs and Jack Henry

38

Jack Henry

Age

26

Ht

192cm

Wt

96kg

Pos.

Def

Career

Season

Last 5

D

10.3

3star

K

7.3

3star

HB

2.9

3star

M

4.0

4star

T

2.2

4star

MG

142.6

2star

D

8.6

2star

K

6.7

3star

HB

1.9

1star

M

3.9

4star

T

2.1

3star

MG

142.6

3star

D

9.6

3star

K

7.0

3star

HB

2.6

3star

M

3.6

4star

T

2.0

4star

basically. Wow.

 

[PhatBoy]

Cats B & F placings for young players fake news.

Holmes had an outstanding season, no arguments there, polled appreciably better than recent winners.

The only other 2 young players to finish top 10 were Oli Dempsey, who averaged 3 out of 10 available votes per game played, and Oli Henry, who averaged much the same. Those are nothing results beating nobody of any note who played sufficient games to be in the mix. They beat Blicavs and Jack Henry basically. Wow.

So the 7 guys in the top 9 who are all 26 or under, 2 of whom turn 27 next July, the rest don’t even turn 26 at the earliest until next year, in a sport routinely churning out 32-33-34 year old good, often elite players - should we be concerned that these guys are past their prime?

I guess that’s the question on everyone’s lips, basically.

 

[PhatBoy]

Whoa-oh, the chip is getting bigger

 

[Footy Smarts]

Cats B & F placings for young players fake news.

Holmes had an outstanding season, no arguments there, polled appreciably better than recent winners.

The only other 2 young players to finish top 10 were Oli Dempsey, who averaged 3 out of 10 available votes per game played, and Oli Henry, who averaged much the same. Those are nothing results beating nobody of any note who played sufficient games to be in the mix. They beat Blicavs and Jack Henry basically. Wow.

You're losing your edge MR.

No dig at Holmes' kicking? No mention of the Holmestring issue (gotta say that's one of your best)?

No RaTiNgZ talk???

Geelong make a prelim with 7 of the top 10 in the B&F under 27. Richmond win the spoon with only 4 of the top 10 under 27 and 2 of those are about to leave.

I'd be flat too if we'd just won the spoon and our only good players were walking out on us.

 

[Footy Smarts]

How would you feel being Baker, Bolton, Graham and Rioli?

You're key parts of multiple premierships. You then sign on for unders to try and keep the club successful.

Your coach and CEO blow up the club with awful list management and recruiting decisions then piss off to much more lucrative jobs leaving a mess.

You're left playing at a rabble, running around with some absolute spuds. But keep your standards up and are among the team's best players

Then for daring to not waste the rest of your career at a basket case the dickhead President starts taking pot shots at you

 

[Sttew]

You're losing your edge MR.

No dig at Holmes' kicking? No mention of the Holmestring issue (gotta say that's one of your best)?

No RaTiNgZ talk???

Geelong make a prelim with 7 of the top 10 in the B&F under 27. Richmond win the spoon with only 4 of the top 10 under 27 and 2 of those are about to leave.

I'd be flat too if we'd just won the spoon and our only good players were walking out on us.

What a bitter and twisted poster is Medicority. He can find a negative in something that is 99.9999% positive and then write tomes about it.

The Geelong B&F proves beyond any reasonable doubt the club is on the right track in terms of turning over the team, and remaining highly competitive.

 

[Fadge]

You see what we ALL have to put with?

Edited for accuracy.

 

[PhatBoy]

You're losing your edge MR.

No dig at Holmes' kicking? No mention of the Holmestring issue (gotta say that's one of your best)?

No RaTiNgZ talk???

Geelong make a prelim with 7 of the top 10 in the B&F under 27. Richmond win the spoon with only 4 of the top 10 under 27 and 2 of those are about to leave.

I'd be flat too if we'd just won the spoon and our only good players were walking out on us.

He maintains a veneer of humour about most of it but a quick glance at stuff he posts to his fellow Tiger fans shows a high degree of genuine - and hilarious - bitterness beneath.

What a bitter and twisted poster is Medicority. He can find a negative in something that is 99.9999% positive and then write tomes about it.

The Geelong B&F proves beyond any reasonable doubt the club is on the right track in terms of turning over the team, and remaining highly competitive.

what’s incredibly amusing is that I wouldn’t cross the street to slag off their youth really if it wasn’t prompted by his never ending desire to find fault in ours. I don’t have any beef with what the Tigers are doing and they’ll probably do it well in time.
But yeah, the unyielding desire to find a flaw in having players be pretty good across all age brackets is somewhat bewildering.

It’s like criticising a cricket side because they rely too heavily on their batsmen, bowlers and fielders to get results

 

[Meteoric Rise]

I write about the subject.

Triggered Cats fans and Fadge write about me.

I am a celebrity.

 

[morsie]

It's going to be a money pit.At least we are not trying to get a PNG team up.

 

[Footy Smarts]

I write about the subject.

Triggered Cats fans and Fadge write about me.

I am a celebrity.

Hey Mr Celebrity.

Can you write some more about the Richmond kids?

Your stuff about the Geelong kids is a bit predictable. You've gone to the well too many times.

But you got any more hits like when Tom Brown was worth an $800k contract? That was top notch.