Speculation Harley Reid [OOC 2026]

Remove this Banner Ad

Philhawk said:
We took the long road to get here, but glad we did.
Click to expand...

exactly

just trust Rosa to rebuild and not do what Dodoro did and miss picks.

It's a risk, but sending three 1st round picks for a kid who's showing absolutely nothing is a worse risk IMO
 
HirdsTheWord said:
exactly

just trust Rosa to rebuild and not do what Dodoro did and miss picks.

It's a risk, but sending three 1st round picks for a kid who's showing absolutely nothing is a worse risk IMO
Click to expand...

It depends on the list profile of where the trading team is at.

For Hawthorn, it would be the cherry on top of the cake.

For Essendon, trading that much when you don’t have the list would be stupendously idiotic.
 
Philhawk said:
It depends on the list profile of where the trading team is at.

For Hawthorn, it would be the cherry on top of the cake.

For Essendon, trading that much when you don’t have the list would be stupendously idiotic.
Click to expand...

yep hard agree.

Though is argue that Reid is no cherry........at least not yet.

he is an out of season grape
 

Log in to remove this ad.

HirdsTheWord said:
exactly

just trust Rosa to rebuild and not do what Dodoro did and miss picks.

It's a risk, but sending three 1st round picks for a kid who's showing absolutely nothing is a worse risk IMO
Click to expand...
I'd be taking the picks to the draft if I were Rosa. Reid ain't fixing our problems on his own.
While he is currently in contract, WC hold the cards. They will demand overs and rightfully so.
An out of contract Reid next year, the situation maybe different, not sure WC would get anywhere near what they could this year. (Depending on Reid's form)
Big decision for WC as well, clearly won't stay there. Hawks would be a good option for him.
 
What’s he really worth though?

If the bombers get picks 5 and 9 this year would the Eagles turn away the equivalent of Langford and Lindsay?

Or if Richmond for some good forsaken reason gave up picks 1 and 4 would the Eagles turn away Lalor and Draper?

I’d say both clubs where they are at would be happy with their current hand for 2025.


If Harley turns it on it may change things but the eagles would want him to improve on his current output to maximise their return for him. At the moment he’s playing like a petulant, unfit yet prodigious talent. There’s a lot of risk there.
 
Rich01 said:
What’s he really worth though?

If the bombers get picks 5 and 9 this year would the Eagles turn away the equivalent of Langford and Lindsay?

Or if Richmond for some good forsaken reason gave up picks 1 and 4 would the Eagles turn away Lalor and Draper?

I’d say both clubs where they are at would be happy with their current hand for 2025.


If Harley turns it on it may change things but the eagles would want him to improve on his current output to maximise their return for him. At the moment he’s playing like a petulant, unfit yet prodigious talent. There’s a lot of risk there.
Click to expand...
No Chance in the world would i give up #1 + #4 for 2025 Harley Reid
Give me Sharp & Fred to go along with Smillie , Lalor & Hotton
 
Seb78 said:
I'd be taking the picks to the draft if I were Rosa. Reid ain't fixing our problems on his own.
While he is currently in contract, WC hold the cards. They will demand overs and rightfully so.
An out of contract Reid next year, the situation maybe different, not sure WC would get anywhere near what they could this year. (Depending on Reid's form)
Big decision for WC as well, clearly won't stay there. Hawks would be a good option for him.
Click to expand...

yep let hawks deal with them next year.
 
THE_GUN said:
No Chance in the world would i give up #1 + #4 for 2025 Harley Reid
Give me Sharp & Fred to go along with Smillie , Lalor & Hotton
Click to expand...

literally the only people who think Reid is worth a massive draft hand is WCE supporters

colour me shocked.

Everyone else seems to want to avoid this like a COVID outbreak.

Eagles should just up their offer and keep him if he's that valuable.
 
HirdsTheWord said:
literally the only people who think Reid is worth a massive draft hand is WCE supporters

colour me shocked.

Everyone else seems to want to avoid this like a COVID outbreak.

Eagles should just up their offer and keep him if he's that valuable.
Click to expand...
You are 100% correct and I for one as a long term Hawthorn member hope we have nothing to do with him.

He has all the hallmarks of a kid who pushed everyone around at junior level but now he can’t to it in the big time he has no coping mechanism. His fitness levels are not much better than mine and he uses up most of that energy fighting anyone who dares to tackle him. I can guarantee his attitude and body language would be wearing very thin on a few of his teammates that at least give maximum effort.

No way would I want the Hawks to shell out the draft capital or the money on a guy who is good for about 12 possessions a game that are canceled out by the half a dozen free kicks he gives away, because someone looked at him.
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

TazHawk15 said:
You are 100% correct and I for one as a long term Hawthorn member hope we have nothing to do with him.

He has all the hallmarks of a kid who pushed everyone around at junior level but now he can’t to it in the big time he has no coping mechanism. His fitness levels are not much better than mine and he uses up most of that energy fighting anyone who dares to tackle him. I can guarantee his attitude and body language would be wearing very thin on a few of his teammates that at least give maximum effort.

No way would I want the Hawks to shell out the draft capital or the money on a guy who is good for about 12 possessions a game that are canceled out by the half a dozen free kicks he gives away, because someone looked at him.
Click to expand...
Your skivvy coach would be the first one knocking on the door if Harley became available.
 
VicBased said:
Your skivvy coach would be the first one knocking on the door if Harley became available.
Click to expand...

GoEaglesGoSGIO said:
Harley has someone else’s wife behind his door ?
Click to expand...
Exhibit A and B.

As I said I hope my club has nothing to do with Harley and his 12 possessions minus the 6 free kicks.

I hope and prey he stays at the WCE.

It’s not my fault me wanting him to stay at the WCE triggers you both, but I fully understand why it does. 👍
 
Last edited:
TazHawk15 said:
Exhibit A and B.

As I said I hope my club has nothing to do with Harley and his 12 possessions minus the 6 free kicks.

I hope and prey he stays at the WCE.

It’s not my fault me wanting him to stay at the WCE triggers you both, but I fully understand why it does. 👍
Click to expand...
Hawks entertaining 1st 25. 26, 27

For Reid @nd 2.5 27
 
WilloTree said:
Hawks entertaining 1st 25. 26, 27

For Reid @nd 2.5 27
Click to expand...
I hope he stays at the WCE but if anyone can fix him it would be Sammy.

But I would not want my club to shell out anywhere near that or the money for his current output, he is just just not worth it.
 

Speculation Harley Reid [OOC 2026]


Write your reply...

Similar threads

Cleric
Speculation Darcy Cameron [OOC 2026]
2
Replies
41
Views
2K
VinnieB
VinnieB
B
Speculation Jamarra Ugle-Hagan [OOC 2026]
2 3 4 5
Replies
115
Views
8K
Since 2001
Since 2001
The Nostradamus
Speculation Taylor Adams [OOC 2026]
2
Replies
27
Views
3K
The Nostradamus
The Nostradamus
Sarcoidevo
Speculation Lewis Young [OOC 2026]
2
Replies
49
Views
3K
THE_GUN
THE_GUN
Lingsface
Speculation Will Brodie [OOC 2026]
Replies
4
Views
1K
GoEaglesGoSGIO
GoEaglesGoSGIO
S
Speculation Jaxon Binns [OOC 2026]
2
Replies
39
Views
3K
Atomboy
Atomboy
S
Speculation Elijah Tsatas [OOC 2026]
2 3 4 5
Replies
103
Views
8K
bzparkes
bzparkes
Back
Top