4th Test Border Gavaskar Trophy December 26-30 1000hrs @ the MCG

Who will win?


  • Total voters
    42
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Am I the only one who thinks the media are going over the top on Sam Konstas on what he has done today? Yes it was a solid knock, there was some good shots, but also there was some lucky shots as well. It was good, but not as good as the Media are talking about
Konstas scored 60 on debut of 63 balls, before today Khawaja had scored 63 runs from 6 innings and McSweeney 72 from 6 innings. First player to make Bumrah look second rate is impressive in it self.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Konstas scored 60 on debut of 63 balls, before today Khawaja had scored 63 runs from 6 innings and McSweeney 72 from 6 innings. First player to make Bumrah look second rate is impressive in it self.

Great post. The kid showed some nerve and spirit & said follow me. And they did. What else do you need?
 
This is supposed to be cricket. There is no excuse for players to make physical contact with each other unless it was accidental and in the play. Please don't make excuses for Kohli, he's been doing these things for his entire career.
Australians like Ponting have done a lot worse.
 
Unfortunately my google-fu skills have failed to turn up a definitive answer, but there doesn't seem to be much stopping his head being turned if Aus come calling. Would be a Bethell-like selection though.

You can play for an associate team and then to a full member with no qualification period.

But you can only go from a full member to any other team (full member or associate) if you've served the qualification period.

So Manenti playing for Italy doesn't make any difference to his chances of playing for Australia.

It's still zero.
 
Konstas scored 60 on debut of 63 balls, before today Khawaja had scored 63 runs from 6 innings and McSweeney 72 from 6 innings. First player to make Bumrah look second rate is impressive in it self.
Yeah it is crazy... He gets picked and all i saw all week was how the selectors are throwing him to the wolves, Bumrah is one of the best ever, Bumrah is unplayable and anyone would fail against him.

Konstas comes out and takes the game on and scores 60 to put is in the driving seat and some are not convinced...
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Am I the only one who thinks the media are going over the top on Sam Konstas on what he has done today? Yes it was a solid knock, there was some good shots, but also there was some lucky shots as well. It was good, but not as good as the Media are talking about
No one is claiming he is a finished product, what i will say is how anyone could see his wide array of shots he has and not be excited is beyond me. He has all the shots in the book and plenty of his own as well.

He will have some rough moments
He will fail at times

He is a kid and has a lot to refine about his game but damn is he talented and damn is he exciting.
 
Can someone explain to me why there is so much crying on this thread.
Batting to slow caused lots of tears, but 311 in a day is ok.
Tears again for over rates. 87 isn't perfect, but on a scorching hot day is acceptable.
Just seems sooking is so prevalent.
If people say they enjoy Test Cricket, I don't get why they complain so much.

Has complaining become cool?
Do people desperate for a like think a tear will bring them one?
 
Last edited:
Can someone explain to me why there is so much crying on this thread.
Batting to slow caused lots of tears, but 311 in a day is ok.
Tears again for over rates. 87 isn't perfect, but on a scorching hot day is acceptable.
Just seems sooking is so prevalent.
If people say they enjoy Test Cricket, I don't get why they complain so much.

Has complaining become cool?
Do people desperate for a like think a year will bring them one?
I follow AFL, NRL, cricket, NBA, F1, Tennis very very closely. I also follow a few other sports casually.

I have never met fans as miserable and whiny as test cricket fans. They just criticize everything and anything no matter how good things are going. Heck we whine when Australia dominate because it is boring but the second they lose they want to retire everyone.

Today was such a great advertisement for the sport!
 
Last edited:
Can someone explain to me why there is so much crying on this thread.
Batting to slow caused lots of tears, but 311 in a day is ok.
Tears again for over rates. 87 isn't perfect, but on a scorching hot day is acceptable.
Just seems sooking is so prevalent.
If people say they enjoy Test Cricket, I don't get why they complain so much.

Has complaining become cool?
Do people desperate for a like think a year will bring them one?
Ironically your post is a complaining one too
 
Am I the only one who thinks the media are going over the top on Sam Konstas on what he has done today? Yes it was a solid knock, there was some good shots, but also there was some lucky shots as well. It was good, but not as good as the Media are talking about
You’re not allowed to say that. Haven’t you read the press conference release?

Konstas has two first class tons as a teenager, isn’t that proof enough for you?
 
Am I the only one who thinks the media are going over the top on Sam Konstas on what he has done today? Yes it was a solid knock, there was some good shots, but also there was some lucky shots as well. It was good, but not as good as the Media are talking about

After a few low scores the sharks will circle and they'll bring in someone new.
Even today he got a few lucky boundaries from some off target bowling.
 
You’re not allowed to say that. Haven’t you read the press conference release?

Konstas has two first class tons as a teenager, isn’t that proof enough for you?
Why are you so offended about this kid? Is it just because he replaced a South Australian?
 
How old was Ponting? What Kohli did was not only intimate a teenager as a senior player but a debutant.
It's all good fun and adds to the atmosphere. Kohli has earnt the right to do that.
If Konstas wants to play IPL he should respect Kohli.
 
Unfortunately my google-fu skills have failed to turn up a definitive answer, but there doesn't seem to be much stopping his head being turned if Aus come calling. Would be a Bethell-like selection though.


after another redback, joe scuderi
 
Why are you so offended about this kid? Is it just because he replaced a South Australian?
No, it’s about the significant number of Shield players who have put up far better cases for replacing incumbents over the last few years, and have been ignored.
It’s about guys like Glen Maxwell who have been overlooked for test selection, because he can play the game precisely as Konstas played today and it was deemed not suitable.
It’s a pure media / ACB campaign since the start of the summer that even has Konstas’ name in contention.
Hits a ODI ton against India A and it’s shouted from every stage managed puff piece script, ignoring the 7 matches leading in where he averaged 25.

Good luck to the kid, very talented, great eye, but let’s not kid ourselves that it’s a logical selection even if it pays off.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

4th Test Border Gavaskar Trophy December 26-30 1000hrs @ the MCG

Back
Top