List Mgmt. 2023 List Management and Trading

[George CantStandYa]

Dowling showed a bit yesterday, kicking was quite good too.....I'm thiinking he's going to be another Hamish success story already.

Who do you consider Hamish’s failures?

 

[dogs105]

Who do you consider Hamish’s failures?

Gallucci for a start

 

[Mostyn]

Who do you consider Hamish’s failures?

McAsey, Gallucci, Poholke over Graham. Did he choose Nick Joyce?

 

[dogs105]

McAsey, Gallucci, Poholke over Graham. Did he choose Nick Joyce?

Nick Joyce at 46 isn't a huge issue, whoever drafted him

 

[George CantStandYa]

McAsey, Gallucci, Poholke over Graham. Did he choose Nick Joyce?

I think that was Rendell, over Neale, ouch.

I’d add Jones and McHenry. Not only we did we not trade up for Rozee, we chose Jones over Butters. Both are on the fringe of selection in their 4th year, not good enough

 

[cleanhands]

Who do you consider Hamish’s failures?

You’re persistent

 

[George CantStandYa]

You’re persistent

It’s a fair question, surely if you’re going to talk up “another success”, you’re open to discussing the failures

 

[cleanhands]

It’s a fair question, surely if you’re going to talk up “another success”, you’re open to discussing the failures

Are you expecting it?

 

[Danger in Texas]

None of them are centre square mids. That's what we need when talking about a midfielder. A taller bustling explosive mid.

We have a million half backs and half forwards, we need pure A grade talent

Who is a tall explosive mid that’s available on the trade market?

Before you say Hollands, he’s showed most on the wing so far

 

[George CantStandYa]

Are you expecting it?

Yes, just as others have given their opinion, it is after all a football forum where we discuss football

 

[cleanhands]

Yes, just as others have given their opinion, it is after all a football forum where we discuss football

Good luck

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Nick Joyce at 46 isn't a huge issue, whoever drafted him

Had a dual role, so not a complete waste...

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

You’re persistent

You have only just worked that out...

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Who is a tall explosive mid that’s available on the trade market?

Before you say Hollands, he’s showed most on the wing so far

You tell me.

I wouldn't be limiting Hollands to being a wingman!

 

[dogs105]

It’s a fair question, surely if you’re going to talk up “another success”, you’re open to discussing the failures

McAsey certainly didn't work out.

 

[cleanhands]

You have only just worked that out...

I’m slow

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

McAsey certainly didn't work out.

Don't think anyone would argue against you... including WW.

 

[Mostyn]

I think that was Rendell, over Neale, ouch.

I’d add Jones and McHenry. Not only we did we not trade up for Rozee, we chose Jones over Butters. Both are on the fringe of selection in their 4th year, not good enough

Yeah, I'm not as fussed by that. Hamish can't do the trade, and while I wish we had Butters, I still have some hope for Jones.

I guess we can include McHenry but the draft really fell off a cliff then, so it bothers me less that McAsey and Gallucci, when there were a LOT of better players that should have been selected.

 

[Mostyn]

Nick Joyce at 46 isn't a huge issue, whoever drafted him

That one annoyed me, because it was the equivalent of giving the work experience kid a job at the firm.

 

[George CantStandYa]

Yeah, I'm not as fussed by that. Hamish can't do the trade, and while I wish we had Butters, I still have some hope for Jones.

I guess we can include McHenry but the draft really fell off a cliff then, so it bothers me less that McAsey and Gallucci, when there were a LOT of better players that should have been selected.

If Hamish said to Reid “we have 3 firsts, use them to get Rozee as he’s the clear standout and the talent drops away” Reid would have done the deal.

Hope for Jones in his fourth year compared to Butters proven quality in his first year.

 

[pushintheback]

Gallucci for a start

Its a pity we didn't see Gallucci off half back. He's lightning quick and a good user of the ball, so maybe a missed opportunity for us :-(. But at the same time you've gotta take your opportunities where ever you get asked to play.

 

[cleanhands]

Its a pity we didn't see Gallucci off half back. He's lightning quick and a good user of the ball, so maybe a missed opportunity for us :-(. But at the same time you've gotta take your opportunities where ever you get asked to play.

It also helps to be committed to the cause, if outside influences are to be believed

 

[martyparty]

Its a pity we didn't see Gallucci off half back. He's lightning quick and a good user of the ball, so maybe a missed opportunity for us :-(. But at the same time you've gotta take your opportunities where ever you get asked to play.

Luckily for Gooch, he had cultivated a moustache that enabled him to move on to a successful career in the pr0n industry…

 

[Mostyn]

It also helps to be committed to the cause, if outside influences are to be believed

I think he's mostly left us regretting the decision to draft him and not the decision to delist him, sadly.

 

[1970crow]

I think he's mostly left us regretting the decision to draft him and not the decision to delist him, sadly.

I think the snapped achilles came at a very bad time for him. Ordinarily, earlier draft picks get an opportunity to turn it around and he had that removed. Still mightn't have done it, but a second chance at another club can be that wake up call.