Autopsy Swans v Blues - AFL Rd 10, 2024 - Friday May 17th 7:40pm - (S.C.G.)

[eaglespremiers]

Injuries and umpires, the only two things that can stop the Mighty Bluebaggers, or so I'm reliably told!

Sam McClure hasn't had the best year with his predictions.

 

[Swansong81]

I'm backing Carlton would win this game at the MCG. SCG is the biggest home advantage in the AFL.

Who is this flogger

 

[Mayes2Gray]

Who is this flogger

They say that about every ground tbh. I wouldn’t be too concerned. Carlton were always losing that

 

[Swansong81]

almost

Heeney destroys daicos in every aspect of the game. Speed, marking, strength, kicking. It's just age that gives daicos a hope

 

[FreoRicci]

Is Harry McKay quickly turning out to be most overrated footballer in the competition or is he merely overrated by his own supporter base?
Silvagni would probably make a better second forward target given he's a little more physical and go chip out in ruck as well.

Overrated
Umpires onto him with his flopping and theatrics.

 

[jwint43]

Heeney destroys daicos in every aspect of the game. Speed, marking, strength, kicking. It's just age that gives daicos a hope

Daicos is an incredibly hardworking and smart footballer, but Heeney has the natural athletic talent that very, very few players possess. It's a shame it took him 10 years to acutally get a chance in the midfield, his 23-26 years could have been something special. I'm sure he won't mind if he wins brownlow and the swans win a flag this year.

I almost tipped Carlton as I thought no Mccartin would be a huge disadvantage, but TDK went missing after quarter time. I like the theory of the two ruck set up with TDK as a 3rd tall but it gets exposed badly if Carlton lose the midfield battle. Missing Cerra badly.

 

[Don Won]

Heeney destroys daicos in every aspect of the game. Speed, marking, strength, kicking. It's just age that gives daicos a hope

Heeney has had a great couple of months, but we need to see this for a couple more years before we start comparing him to Daicos.

 

[VinnieB]

Jack Silvagni was blamed for everthing from war in the Ukraine to Global Warming at one stage.

I blame him for having a brother who is on the Collingwood VFL list.

 

[VinnieB]

Heeney destroys daicos in every aspect of the game. Speed, marking, strength, kicking. It's just age that gives daicos a hope

Settle petal.

 

[VinnieB]

Injuries and umpires, the only two things that can stop the Mighty Bluebaggers, or so I'm reliably told!

When you have injured players like Zac Williams coming back who shiit the bed when having to be accountable, we should hope for a speedy recovery for them all.

 

[sthmelb_dimmies]

I'm backing Carlton would win this game at the MCG. SCG is the biggest home advantage in the AFL.

Wow what an absolute belting. I’ve not seen one way traffic like that since the 2022 GF

 

[VinnieB]

Carlton need to stop moving Curnow to the backline in the middle of games

That was U14 coaching right there.

 

[sthmelb_dimmies]

That was U14 coaching right there.

Classic Crazy Vossy

 

[MisterB]

Had a bad game - wasn’t an Island by any means

Has he ever had a good game? Genuine question.

 

[kreuze_missile]

You all overreacting.

Richmond beat Sydney.

And we beat Richmond.

So we’re still Flaggers.

 

[Mr Meow]

You all overreacting.

Richmond beat Sydney.

And we beat Richmond.

So we’re still Flaggers.

Any team below Geelong at the end of this round isn't winning the flag. Time to look to 2025 and maybe see how Charlie goes in the Coleman until then.

 

[CCurnow3votes]

Has he ever had a good game? Genuine question.

If that’s a genuine question, it’s also a stupid one.

 

[Tall poppy Syndrome]

Now that Buddy has left the Swans can finally go back to winning flags.

Historically, when Buddy leaves a club that club goes on to win the next two flags.

 

[ToreadorMarch]

Carlton are just a rung below the best teams.

Who are the best teams?

 

[JackFlash]

It's now proven the Blues are way out of their depth, the Swans are clearly the best team in it this year.
Already the top 8 can forget about Carlton and Geelong and Melbourne are probably next best along with Collingwood. GWS have disappointed a little and the jury is still out on Essendon. Port are just hanging in there. Forget the rest.
I'll go for a Swans v Melbourne or Swans v Collingwood Grand Final at this stage.

 

[Osho]

It's now proven the Blues are way out of their depth, the Swans are clearly the best team in it this year.
Already the top 8 can forget about Carlton and Geelong and Melbourne are probably next best along with Collingwood. GWS have disappointed a little and the jury is still out on Essendon. Port are just hanging in there. Forget the rest.
I'll go for a Swans v Melbourne or Swans v Collingwood Grand Final at this stage.

Pies B2B a big show imo.

 

[beema limapep]

Any team below Geelong at the end of this round isn't winning the flag. Time to look to 2025 and maybe see how Charlie goes in the Coleman until then.

Yep. Im sure the 3 game 'dynasty' for Carlton fans felt like 3 premierships, but back to reality again. Same old Carlton. Yaaawwwn.

 

[Worm4]

It's now proven the Blues are way out of their depth, the Swans are clearly the best team in it this year.

It was a good kick in the teeth but could be a blessing . They will be back before too long competitive against the best sides.
Every team this year has had a crap game including Sydney.

 

[beema limapep]

If that’s a genuine question, it’s also a stupid one.

He's not rated by anyone other than a small majority of Carlton supporters. Bog average at best.

 

[CCurnow3votes]

He's not rated by anyone other than a small majority of Carlton supporters. Bog average at best.

Yes you should know about bog average.

Thanks so much for your opinion though.