Honestly Zvim, the way you carry on some times I get the opinion that you think the rookie list is a completely pointless exercise.
Where did I say or imply it is completely pointless? Most of the guys there have been in the system for a while now and if they don't have a senior position it is because they have some significant deficiencies so for me, a great year for a rookie is to get a lot of VFL time, get the consistency up and IF there is a serious injury to someone then bring one in to have a crack.
To expect rookies to have an impact with the senior team is just flat out delusional. If and when it happens it is just a nice bonus, like a Campbell or many other players that have come through the rookie system.