Search results for query: *

How is our gameplan so inflexible we prefer to sub out a 2nd gamer at half time than put him in an attacking role that compliments his play style.

GAME 3 ROUND 9 arrowman – Dawson (Fogarty, Keays, Rachele, Walker, Rankine) IMMUNITAH robboaustralia - Soligo (Keays, Fogarty, Rachele, Walker, Rankine) Stephen2 - Himmelberg (Keays, Fogarty, Rachele, Walker, Rankine) Scorpus - Cook (Rachele, Fogarty, Walker, Keays, Rankine) IMMUNITY Eddie...

He’d also be spending significantly more time in midfield than other smalls in the conversation (bar Bolton).

GAME 2 ROUND 9 arrowman - Collingwood (St Kilda) skam85 - Collingwood (St Kilda) Scorpus - Collingwood (St Kilda) Dirty Bird - Hawthorn (Adelaide) Dude316 - Geelong (Adelaide) OldCrowBloke - Suns (St Kilda) Eddie Murphy - Suns (St Kilda) SugarShane - Bulldogs (St Kilda)

Are we sure they aren’t Ports doctors in disguise?

I'm not a doctor but that seems a pretty extreme contrast to "weighing up season ending surgery"

And we can breathe a sigh of a relief

Surely he’d be coming here as a coach. But even then why would he move from Moggs Creek again? Bizarre, bizarre rumour.

I agree with everything said here except I’d be holding onto Gollant, particularly with 25’ being Walker’s last likely year, and we don’t know if he’s playing a full season. I’d also rather have Sholl in a rookie list spot than Hamill. Don’t mind cheaply targeting Caleb Daniel should we fail to...

Gollant deserves a chunk of games without one of Tex or Fog in the side before we make any call on his future.

Whether McHenry is dropped or not is the least of my concerns. Two things I want to see most next week: retain Curtin, retain Cook.

Have to admit Geelong’s insane i50 efficiency in round 2 made me question Hombsch. Very happy to say I’m wrong on that call.

JFK today if Port were the shooter.

Is it not obvious what I’m getting at… he was more scared of kicking than he was getting tackled

Why didn’t rozee kick the ball all night? Another port doctor masterclass

14th for i50 tackles last year and rated elite for defensive pressure (going off his bio). At 186cm he’s more mobile than fog. I see him much more in the McAdam mould, a genuine marking target that can apply ground level pressure.

Surely Hayward is a need if we see Rachele and Rankine as full time midfielders.

GAME 3 ROUND 8 arrowman – Fogarty (Keays, Rachele, Walker, Rankine) Eddie Murphy - Rankine (Cook, Rachele, Gollant, Fogarty)

GAME 1 ROUND 8 Crowholder - Saints (Melbourne, Hawks, Geelong, Sydney, Western Bulldogs, GWS, Port Adelaide, Gold Coast) skam85 - GAME 2 ROUND 8 BrissyCrow - Bulldogs MrMysteryGuest - Bulldogs Dirty Bird - Adelaide Danger Zone - Saints Crowholder - Saints OldCrowBloke- Saints Scorpus - St...

Surely this means either Sholl is omitted or Smith is playing SANFL. We’d be stacked for wingers/HBF otherwise

LFG

Borlase/Butts gets Marshall Worrell gets Georgiades Michalanney gets Rioli Hamill/Curtin gets Evans (who I’ll assume comes in for SPP?) Hinge gets Byrne-Jones? Might be Byrne-Jones marking Hinge more than the other way around.

I really don’t see why North would let LDU go this year. He’s a guaranteed band 1 which in all likelihood looks like a top 4 pick. I can’t see them getting better offers than that this year. They also need good mature players more than they need draft picks, they’ll want to do everything they...

Think many are underrating that for a solid five years he was a top 20 player in the comp. Think people are also forgetting his first half of 2023 was decent enough and he realistically only went half a season longer than he should (should have certainly retired at the end of 2023 though). I...

Wonder what his shape making is like?

Bad: a clinical 29 disposals and a goal against the worst team in the comp means Sholl is locked in for another month

Berg is currently the best option we have sure, and is actually decent depth. But he’s also 8 years into his career and we can put a line through him being anything more than depth. Gollant has the hardest break in our list being behind Walker, Fogarty and TT despite past reserves form...

Really felt our shape was out of sorts that quarter. Thank god Ned the shape keeper is coming in to bring us some much needed balance.