Opinion Recruiting and List Management Team: Hamish Ogilvie, Justin Reid & Co

[George Kramer]

There is no debate or conversation to be had, it’s unarguable that we draft best available. We know this by observed action, and we know it as it’s been confirmed from the very heart of drafting team. The highest levels

What I find peculiar is that our free agent / trade strategy still seems focused on who might available not who we need.

A just get in good players strategy

Because when you’re a leper you take what you can get. The offer we threw at Melbourne last year says it all

 

[Sanders]

Certainly a shared responsibility

Look at us actively trying to f*** up Curtin. Three games in and can't possibly be doing anything dumber or more destructive.

Silence you

 

[Sanders]

Hamish’s record since 2012

Sam Siggins
Rory Atkins
Ian Callinan
Nicholas Joyce
Kyle Hartigan
Jack Osborn
Tim Klaosen
Matt Crouch
Riley Knight
Rory Laird
Charlie Cameron
James Battersby
Jake Kelly
Alex Spina
Jake Lever
Harrison Wigg
Mitch McGovern
Harry Dear
Reilly O'Brien
Keenan Ramsey
Anthony Wilson
Wayne Milera
Tom Doedee
Paul Hunter
Jonathon Beech
Hugh Greenwood
Alex Keath
Jordan Gallucci
Myles Poholke
Elliott Himmelberg
Matthew Signorello
Ben Davis
Sam Shaw
Ben Jarman
Darcy Fogarty
Andrew McPherson
Patrick Wilson
Cameron Ellis-Yolmen
Lachlan Murphy
Jackson Edwards
Chayce Jones
Ned McHenry
Will Hamill
Lachlan Sholl
Kieran Strachan
Paul Hunter
Jordon Butts
Fischer McAsey
Harry Schoenberg
Josh Worrell
Ronin O'Connor
Lachlan Gollant
Ben Keays
Ben Crocker
Riley Thilthorpe
Luke Pedlar
Brayden Cook
Sam Berry
James Rowe
Jackson Hately
Patrick Parnell
Josh Rachele
Jake Soligo
Zac Taylor
Luke Nankervis
Ben Davis
Brett Turner
Max Michalanney
Billy Dowling
Hugh Bond
Daniel Curtin
Charlie Edwards
Oscar Ryan
Will Hamill
James Borlase


Ports recruitment manager in 2018

Connor Rozee
Zak Butters
Xavier Duursma
Riley Grundy
Boyd Woodcock
Tobin Cox
Cameron Hewett


Hahahaha wonder why they have a list stronger than ours


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Laird was under Rendell

 

[Sanders]

I think he does have an eye for some talent, he's picked enough players who turned out to be good that it's more than just luck.

Compared to what?

 

[George Kramer]

Here is his 12 years as the boss please name one superstar from all those picks in 12 years including so so many 1 st rounders

However Hamish hypothetically in 2016 cost us a flag we went for Galluci Polhkoke and Himmelberg in front of some SA under 18 captain who won player of the under 18 championship who then went on to stand out best midfielder in Sloane on GF day in 2017 and not only destroy Sloane but kick 3 Wowsa was that the flag moment


Sam Siggins
Rory Atkins
Ian Callinan
Nicholas Joyce
Kyle Hartigan
Jack Osborn
Tim Klaosen
Matt Crouch
Riley Knight
Rory Laird
Charlie Cameron
James Battersby
Jake Kelly
Alex Spina
Jake Lever
Harrison Wigg
Mitch McGovern
Harry Dear
Reilly O'Brien
Keenan Ramsey
Anthony Wilson
Wayne Milera
Tom Doedee
Paul Hunter
Jonathon Beech
Hugh Greenwood
Alex Keath
Jordan Gallucci
Myles Poholke
Elliott Himmelberg
Matthew Signorello
Ben Davis
Sam Shaw
Ben Jarman
Darcy Fogarty
Andrew McPherson
Patrick Wilson
Cameron Ellis-Yolmen
Lachlan Murphy
Jackson Edwards
Chayce Jones
Ned McHenry
Will Hamill
Lachlan Sholl
Kieran Strachan
Paul Hunter
Jordon Butts
Fischer McAsey
Harry Schoenberg
Josh Worrell
Ronin O'Connor
Lachlan Gollant
Ben Keays
Ben Crocker
Riley Thilthorpe
Luke Pedlar
Brayden Cook
Sam Berry
James Rowe
Jackson Hately
Patrick Parnell
Josh Rachele
Jake Soligo
Zac Taylor
Luke Nankervis
Ben Davis
Brett Turner
Max Michalanney
Billy Dowling
Hugh Bond
Daniel Curtin
Charlie Edwards
Oscar Ryan
Will Hamill
James Borlase





On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

119others you going to acknowledge the misses in this lot? If more worked out do you think we would have made the finals once in the last 7 years?

 

[marty36]

Laird was under Rendell

True rookie drafted by Rendell then drafted on to main list

Makes the list even more diabolical than it looks soo sad he has been there 12 years

Ogilvie is a hack but then those that have retained him are too blame aswell


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Sanders]

Quite a few simplistic, non balanced opinions here.

Crayon chewing nonsense

 

[Sanders]

For someone who likes holding others to account I am actually disappointed you ain’t man enough to answer the questions. And frankly if you aren’t man enough I can’t be stuffed arguing further with you here.

The absolute F ???

 

[Sanders]

Well I didn't look back to Twomey's power rankings in 2012 to find out who he would have suggested to pick. So I was talking 2014 onward

Of what I've seen it's 3 AA vs 3 AA for Ogilvie vs Twomey in total

Even if we say he was overruled on English it's not a stellar record compared to freely available rankings by a journalist

The recruiting manager is NEVER overruled and has NEVER been

 

[Sanders]

So you reckon he’s been AVERAGE now, glad you’re content with being AVERAGE

Why are you arguing with a ABAB level clapper?

 

[George Kramer]

Why are you arguing with a ABAB level clapper?

That’s true, occasionally I get sucked in. Can you please take over

 

[Sanders]

That’s true, occasionally I get sucked in. Can you please take over

just point at laugh.

Not only does this Pygmy not understand Bayesian probability, he doesn’t even understand why it matters

 

[BunjiMac]

I don't know how anyone can objectively look at the body of evidence and say we've recruited well.

 

[Sanders]

Our trading has been fine. Recent pickups include our captain, another one of our best players in Rankine, and Hinge and Keays who are consistent first team players and we picked up at little cost. Hinge in particular is a steal and one of our better players. Calling that trading record the worst in the league is absurd.

We drafted Keays

 

[George Kramer]

The absolute F ???

Oh wow, I skimmed over that, did he really throw out I’m not man enough?

The irony is I did actually answer his questions, he just couldn’t comprehend.

So from 119 previously he’s said I can’t be happy in life, today it’s I’m not man enough and he thinks I believe I’m elite because of my old username. Makes sense because now I think I’m 2 Seinfeld characters merged into one, you think you’re really Colonel Sanders too don’t you?

 

[jackster83]

Oh wow, I skimmed over that, did he really throw out I’m not man enough?

The irony is I did actually answer his questions, he just couldn’t comprehend.

So from 119 previously he’s said I can’t be happy in life, today it’s I’m not man enough and he thinks I believe I’m elite because of my old username. Makes sense because now I think I’m 2 Seinfeld characters merged into one, you think you’re really Colonel Sanders too don’t you?

I wonder how his little letters to the club are going.

 

[Sanders]

Oh wow, I skimmed over that, did he really throw out I’m not man enough?

The irony is I did actually answer his questions, he just couldn’t comprehend.

So from 119 previously he’s said I can’t be happy in life, today it’s I’m not man enough and he he thinks I believe I’m elite because of my old username. Makes sense because now I think I’m 2 Seinfeld characters merged into one, you think you’re really Colonel Sanders too don’t you?

what does “not man enough” even mean?

What a F-ed up thing to say

 

[George Kramer]

what does “not man enough” even mean?

What a F-ed up thing to say

I actually think it’s quite sexist, what a grub.

 

[Sanders]

If you want to criticise them about anything - the decision to rebuild is looking foolish, as even Bevo has pointed out how impossible rebuilds have become, with the draft decimated by the advantages given to Academies, free agent compos and father-sons.

An excellent point

 

[Sanders]

Pretty glad we turned down WCE’s trade offer of their future 1st

 

[Sanders]

I actually think it’s quite sexist, what a grub.

 

[George Kramer]

Yuk!!

 

[Sanders]

Yuk!!

You’ll never be as manly as that fine specimen

 

[1970crow]

So you reckon he’s been AVERAGE now, glad you’re content with being AVERAGE

Average gets you between 10 and 15 years at our club.

 

[1970crow]

what does “not man enough” even mean?

What a F-ed up thing to say

Sounds l8ke someth8ng a toxic white male would say.