Worst AFL ground?

[Jezzitizle]

I moved to Sydney before last season, and have been to 5 games at Giants home ground.

Personally I don’t mind it, it doesn’t have the roar of the huge stadiums, but I like that you aren’t miles away because of it’s size.

Not the best, but not the worst imo.

 

[Captain_Bender]

geelong playing on a ground with substandard dimensions is no different to St Kilda watering Moorabbin back in the 80s

 

[Boxhead_31]

Kardinia Park and it’s not even close.

Country ground
Mangled dimensions
No capacity
It’s Victoria’s Norwood Oval. And is a disgrace.

Props to the Catters though for continually grifting the Victorian tax payers to pay for their sham redevelopments and scoreboards etc.

It’s the only football oval on the list of choices, the rest are just cricket grounds

 

[Captain_Bender]

It’s the only football oval on the list of choices, the rest are just cricket grounds

That's where you are wrong cobba, footy is meant to be played on a wide ground , kardinia park is a handbagger oval

 

[FootyLad0]

That's where you are wrong cobba, footy is meant to be played on a wide ground , kardinia park is a handbagger oval

That’s where you’re wrong Cobba, footy in its earliest origins started on a rectangular patch of dirt so really no one is conforming to standards.

 

[GoldbergsGold]

geelong playing on a ground with substandard dimensions is no different to St Kilda watering Moorabbin back in the 80s

I wonder why they didn't fix the dimensions when they did the renovations.

 

[iameviljez]

I wonder why they didn't fix the dimensions when they did the renovations.

Google Maps it and you'll see the problem (street location).

 

[UnitedWarrior93]

Marvel, shithole.

Gabba not far behind.

 

[GoldbergsGold]

Google Maps it and you'll see the problem (street location).

There's a car park where they did the renovations, though, they could have moved the stands using up that parking area and designed it to make the boundary dimension more wider and symmetrical.

 

[Sttew]

geelong playing on a ground with substandard dimensions is no different to St Kilda watering Moorabbin back in the 80s

What a dumb post, but hey, who can be surprised? I'd love to hear how you see the two as being the same!

Is GMHBA "Substandard" because its narrower? The best brand of football is corridor football and playing on GMHBA promotes corridor football. Not that Richmond would know, only having played at the ground a few times in the past 20 or so years.

 

[Sttew]

There's a car park where they did the renovations, though, they could have moved the stands using up that parking area and designed it to make the boundary dimension more wider and symmetrical.

Only if they did the stands all at the same time, but the redevelopment was staggered over 15 or so years because of funding

 

[Cyclops]

Docklands. It seems to reap a harvest if serious knee injuries every year.

Kardinia Park is a silly shape, I guess they had to compromise with local and state politicians to get the money and footy lost.

Cannot last as a venue, as viable as the gridiron and baseball ground used for the failed os exhibition games, but it's keeping the Cats afloat so good on em while it lasts.

 

[Xtreme]

GMHBA by the length of the Flemington straight AND the amount of tennis fans after Tony Jones.

 

[Saints4ever]

Hate playing there because we lose every single time and the cats are so finely tuned at playing there ground.

Obviously they get to train on the ground and can develop the perfect game style to suit the dimensions but I really don’t get that hate for GHMBA stadium.

Yes it’s narrower who cares you just have to adapt to the conditions. With the new grand stands it’s really become a first class stadium.

Haters going to hate. I’ll enjoy watching all the games down at Geelong this year except for the saints game which will be a guaranteed Loss.

Doesn’t mean I hate the ground though.

Worst ground Ninja stadium

 

[JP Ollards]

Worst ground is marvel, built the wrong way, grass is horrible, how could you get a new stadium so wrong

 

[StillAtLarge]

Docklands easily. Players hate playing there, grass hates growing there, fans hate going there. The staff are miserable too, it really is a cluster**** of a stadium

 

[GoldbergsGold]

Worst ground is marvel, built the wrong way, grass is horrible, how could you get a new stadium so wrong

It was by design, it was a compromise to fit it on that land.

 

[iameviljez]

There's a car park where they did the renovations, though, they could have moved the stands using up that parking area and designed it to make the boundary dimension more wider and symmetrical.

The tough bit, though, is that you would need to shift everything (i.e. the goalposts, and therefore the two "end" stands) for that to happen. I get what you're saying, but pulling the centre of the ground away from Moorabool Street would be extremely difficult in AFL in a way that it would not be for a soccer ground.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

I moved to Sydney before last season, and have been to 5 games at Giants home ground.

Personally I don’t mind it, it doesn’t have the roar of the huge stadiums, but I like that you aren’t miles away because of it’s size.

Not the best, but not the worst imo.

One of my favourite footy going experiences. Don’t know how it would be with a capacity crowd, but with a reasonable attendance it was just fine. Did give vibes of an enhanced WAFL feel but that was part of the charm.

Noted no issue with the facilities either

 

[iameviljez]

Marvel, shithole.

And yet eleventy million light years ahead of the massive shithole it replaced

 

[Mofra]

Once you've watched a few full games at Williamstown in the dead of winter, with the wind ripping off the water on 3 sides of the oval, any AFL ground is tolerable.

 

[fake tyrone]

I honestly don't mind grounds having slightly different dimensions, sizes, and conditions. It's nothing like baseball or cricket where things can really be different to the point where player selection and strategy can become drastically altered. Even then, I love seeing how players and teams adapt to their environment so that they still have the best chance of winning.

As an aside, does anybody else find the seats on level 4 at the G almost unbearably uncomfortable? I love the G but I can't sit still when I'm up there on level 4; the seats seem tiny and there's next to no leg room.

 

[flamethrower]

Worst ground is marvel, built the wrong way, grass is horrible, how could you get a new stadium so wrong

If it was built east-west, the western end would be under water.

The biggest issue with Docklands is the roof - it should have been translucent like SoFi Stadium or US Bank Stadium in the States to let in natural light. Having an opaque roof makes it feel like a crypt.