Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

Banter threads are not to be taken too seriously. Have fun. Let others have fun.

Who will be better in 2025

  • Collingwood

    Votes: 64 52.9%

  • Carlton

    Votes: 57 47.1%
  • Total voters
    121

Remove this Banner Ad

Fadge said:
So you're telling me the fact Collingwood have objectively improved a list that won a premiership in 2023, compared to Carlton who didn't improve a list that is yet to even contend for a premiership let alone win one, 'means sfa towards 2025'?

Hmmmm.....
Click to expand...
No. What I'm telling you. Please keep up. Is that prior to 23/24 has sfa to do with 25.
Who's list has or hasn't improved is opinion only and everyone knows your opinion on Carltons list.
No point naming names or providing a list because you under rate our list anyway.

On SM-G980F using BigFooty.com mobile app
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Fadge said:
I do rate Jagga Smith.

But I don't expect him to single-handedly compensate for the combined contribution of the players you have lost in the off season, in year 1 of his career.

Still waiting for a Carlton supporter to give me a list of the in's and out's for 2025, and explain to me how the list is better year on year.
Click to expand...
The only player I will miss is Kennedy - one of my favourite 'blue collar' battlers.

Cuningham/Marchbank/Martin were never on the park

Owies....don tmake me larf cost us finals two years in a row for being a choker - good luck to him.
 
Fadge said:
Of course there's no point naming names, because we all know what the answer will be.
Click to expand...
You asked for "a list of our outs and ins" and that it would be "clear the Carlton list has gone backwards, at least for 2025".

Seeing as how "we all know what the answer will be" and seeing as how you asked the question and you're part of us "all", how about you, in all your wisdom, tell everyone this list of outs and ins, with your evaluation of the players involved.

As you love to put it.

Go.

On SM-G980F using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
WalshistheGOAT said:
Pies geriatrics are apparently excited about Perryspud in action. Lmao if I ever needed to hear one line that summed up how cooked a list is that was it.

Will be lucky to make the top 8.
Click to expand...
Our old gold geriatrics are like Rolls Royce's crossed with Hilux's. All class that never dies! Year after year they turn up to beat your sorry asses. Old reliables.

Watch and weep as our silver fox grey nomads put your mob to the sword again. Just like they did this year...Twice!
 
WalshistheGOAT said:
Pies geriatrics are apparently excited about Perryspud in action. Lmao if I ever needed to hear one line that summed up how cooked a list is that was it.

Will be lucky to make the top 8.
Click to expand...
We were also excited when we saw Billy Frampton receive his premiership medal.

One day you guys might realise a deep and balanced squad wins a premiership, and the top end players win the individual awards.

Then again, you might not...
 
Scritchyscroony said:
Our old gold geriatrics are like Rolls Royce's crossed with Hilux's. All class that never dies! Year after year they turn up to beat your sorry asses. Old reliables.

Watch and weep as our silver fox grey nomads put your mob to the sword again. Just like they did this year...Twice!
Click to expand...
old man GIF
 
Fadge said:
We were also excited when we saw Billy Frampton receive his premiership medal.

One day you guys might realise a deep and balanced squad wins a premiership, and the top end players win the individual awards.

Then again, you might not...
Click to expand...

+ Carlton folks need to realise that Premierships are won in a month of the year called “September”.

When Carlton supporters go outside and feel that the weather is hot, and they see the nights are long, and the calendar says it’s February - they need to realise that it’s not the time of the year that Premierships are being handed out.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Fadge said:
We were also excited when we saw Billy Frampton receive his premiership medal.

One day you guys might realise a deep and balanced squad wins a premiership, and the top end players win the individual awards.

Then again, you might not...
Click to expand...
This is the same guy who spent all year talking up Nicky Squibcos for his individual brilliance and how amazing it will be when he wins some individual awards????
 
I have come up with a dream Carlton matchup. I have taken all those players that have played in a Premiership for Carlton in the 21st century and made a best side out of them. I have previously listed this team. I have matched them up against all those Carlton players who have won a Preliminary Final for Carlton in the 21st Century but have failed to win a flag. The cream game. This brings together the best of the best. The line ups are as follows.

Premiership Team
B
HB
C
GF
F
R
R
Inter

Preliminary Final Winning Team

B
HB
C
HF
F
R
R
Inter

Wow these line ups are littered with Champions on every line.
 
South of the Yarra said:
I have come up with a dream Carlton matchup. I have taken all those players that have played in a Premiership for Carlton in the 21st century and made a best side out of them. I have previously listed this team. I have matched them up against all those Carlton players who have won a Preliminary Final for Carlton in the 21st Century but have failed to win a flag. The cream game. This brings together the best of the best. The line ups are as follows.

Premiership Team
B
HB
C
GF
F
R
R
Inter

Preliminary Final Winning Team

B
HB
C
HF
F
R
R
Inter

Wow these line ups are littered with Champions on every line.
Click to expand...
My abacus tells me the result of that game will be the same scoreline as Carlton had at the 50 minute mark of the 2024 Elimination Final.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

Back
Top