Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 2

[Fadge]

You got lucky you didn't play anyone of note while you had injuries, but i see you're still behind Carlton and Essendon though, i think that's about your limit, at best it's off to Sydney in your first final.

I guess time will tell, let's see how the next 9 weeks pan out...

But if that is the case, if any team is going to beat Sydney in Sydney it's Collingwood when they're humming, with the alternative being a Preliminary Final against either Carlton or Essendon at the 'G.

Pies are very well placed given all the challenges we've had so far this year...

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

Pies supporters are fine with how everything is going now.

Reigning premiers, in the top 4, starting to get some Cavalry back.

Hoping to contend for another premiership.

Good for you but we're still ahead of you now though.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

I guess time will tell, let's see how the next 9 weeks pan out...

But if that is the case, if any team is going to beat Sydney in Sydney it's Collingwood when they're humming, with the alternative being a Preliminary Final against either Carlton or Essendon at the 'G.

Pies are very well placed given all the challenges we've had so far this year...

We're going great and I'm ecstatic after a shocking start to the season

We're not going to finish higher on the ladder than Carlton but if we can hold 4th or even sneak into third it's lock and load baby, we know how to win finals

 

[Fadge]

Good for you but we're still ahead of you now.

Right you are, but you don't get handed the premiership flag for being 2nd on the ladder in June.

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

Right you are, but you don't get handed the premiership flag for being 2nd on the ladder in June.

No but the signs are encouraging nonetheless.

 

[Aphrodite]

It's a dream for most Essendon supporters I've been told.

7,238 days and counting!

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Right you are, but you don't get handed the premiership flag for being 2nd on the ladder in June.

So THAT'S why they're jittery, looking down instead of looking up

 

[Robertio]

I guess time will tell, let's see how the next 9 weeks pan out...

But if that is the case, if any team is going to beat Sydney in Sydney it's Collingwood when they're humming, with the alternative being a Preliminary Final against either Carlton or Essendon at the 'G.

Pies are very well placed given all the challenges we've had so far this year...

What challenges?

 

[Fadge]

We're going great and I'm ecstatic after a shocking start to the season

We're not going to finish higher on the ladder than Carlton but if we can hold 4th or even sneak into third it's lock and load baby, we know how to win finals

Indeed.

Particularly after we were told by all and sundry after 2021 that we were in for a minimum 5 years of Carlton type mediocrity in the bottom 4.

But since then we've gone 3rd, flag, and priming for another tilt at a flag.

Glorious.

 

[Aphrodite]

Lowe than St Kilda eh? The same St Kilda that beat your rabble in a grand final? In the here and now we are ahead of you as well buddy.

At least we were there, 1966 just another drought period rubbish season from the BluesView attachment 2033627

 

[Fadge]

What challenges?

I pointed them all out in a previous post.

Keep up.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Indeed.

Particularly after we were told by all and sundry after 2021 that we were in for a minimum 5 years of Carlton type mediocrity in the bottom 4.

But since then we've gone 3rd, flag, and priming for another tilt at a flag.

Glorious.

The struggling clubs need their "windows" but ours is permanent

 

[Fadge]

The struggling clubs need their "windows" but ours is permanent

127 year window for Collingwood, and still going strong!

 

[Robertio]

I pointed them all out in a previous post.

Keep up.

This is not a previous post what challenges has Collingwood faced this season?

 

[carlton_99]

winning a final is a pass mark for most Carlton supporters Ive been told

Surely that would be exceeding expectations for your lot?

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Don't see any Carlton players in that photo couldn't even make the finals

Saints beat Carlton by 53 points that year, drubbing

 

[Arr0w]

3 flags from 14 GFs in 6 odd decades. Still makes me laugh

That's closer to the Saints losing ratio

Boy oh boy, wowee

 

[Fadge]

This is not a previous post what challenges has Collingwood faced this season?

Why should I repeat myself because you can't keep up with the discussion?

 

[Yoda_]

Surely that would be exceeding expectations for your lot?

its nice but like 5 of a kind on the pokies, you take it but the real reason you're there is for the jackpot

 

[Fadge]

Corn Cobbers, we've tried to keep the discussion relevant to the thread title, but these Carlton posters keep digressing.

Between tying themselves in knots and struggling to cope with the weight of expectation, they really aren't covering themselves in glory...

 

[JustaBattler]

We're going great and I'm ecstatic after a shocking start to the season

We're not going to finish higher on the ladder than Carlton but if we can hold 4th or even sneak into third it's lock and load baby, we know how to win finals

You don't know that and neither does your abacus wielding mate - NO ONE knows what is going to happen 10 games till the end of H&A...
OR

explain how Colingwood isnt gong to finish higher than Carltonin H&A?

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Corn Cobbers, we've tried to keep the discussion relevant to the thread title, but these Carlton posters keep digressing.

Between tying themselves in knots and struggling to cope with the weight of expectation, they really aren't covering themselves in glory...

Emoji guy gets the prize today

 

[Arr0w]

Pies 80s peroxide mullet, bus driver, is still impersonating a Tiger's supporter because they won 3 flags in 4 years

He really is an A1 pillock

 

[Fadge]

Emoji guy gets the prize today

Careful, he might call you childish (whilst posting an emoji himself)...

 

[Arr0w]

I heard the Pies are planning another inseason holiday to Mexico