Trent Cotchin bump on Dylan Shiel

[DemonTim]

You spelt Cotchin wrong. Sloane if fit will be lining up next week

I was mocking your fans logic

Neither should get a week

Cotchin might get a fine and miss for that

 

[Bradkli]

He is gone. He can't not get a fine. Shiel being concussed is what will cost him. Would be 1 week in regular season, but will be a fine because it's a prelim. He already has 2 strikes. Any richmond supporter that tries to think he won't get a fine has no idea. If he doesn't get a fine, they might as well shut up shop the AFL.

 

[Badesumofu]

Was going for the ball. No case to answer. There's no automatic suspension for head-high contact.

 

[Crow till I die]

Oh. So now it's the player has to sit out?

Quit your whinging mate. If you want Cotchin gone, then you must agree with the Geelong fans calling for sloanes head.

Wtf Sloane has no case to answer..even the geelong supporters and commentators agreed on that. If Cochin gets off and somehow Sloane gets cited and rubbed out, there will be a riot and the crows would take it further

 

[mattsk88]

Oh. So now it's the player has to sit out?

Quit your whinging mate. If you want Cotchin gone, then you must agree with the Geelong fans calling for sloanes head.

If you hit someone in the head with enough force to cause concussion when you go for a bump then you are gone.

 

[Suma Magic]

It was two players going to pick up the ball. Two players with eyes for the ball.

It was a collision not a one-way bump.

If you take someone high while picking up the ball you don't get fined or suspended.

 

[DemonTim]

If you hit someone in the head with enough force to cause concussion when you go for a bump then you are gone.

But Geelong fans said danger was knocked out? Is that less force?

Neither should go. Quit being a sook.

 

[Goats]

If Richmond win this game, I can't wait to read all you miserable pricks moaning on Monday night when he gets off.

 

[Knox Harrington]

Next week he will he Trent Watchin

 

[BK Eaglesfan]

After reviewing the footage I don't think it's a bump. He just threw himself at the ball.

I’m with this. I think he threw himself at the ball, braced himself for contact and was actually lower down than Shiel but Shiel literally led with his head. Would hate to see anyone miss a GF on this incident.

 

[Pea Nut]

He is gone. He can't not get a fine. Shiel being concussed is what will cost him. Would be 1 week in regular season, but will be a fine because it's a prelim. He already has 2 strikes. Any richmond supporter that tries to think he won't get a fine has no idea. If he doesn't get a fine, they might as well shut up shop the AFL.

I want to see a Bradkli special if he gets off. Tag me in it !!

 

[Membling]

It was two players going to pick up the ball. Two players with eyes for the ball.

It was a collision not a one-way bump.

If you take someone high while picking up the ball you don't get fined or suspended.

Right arm curled for impact.

Wouldn't be surprised to see him get off due to finals. Shouldn't but probably will

 

[RUNVS]

Cotchin needs to be suspended as his actions here helped his team win the game. Had Shiels not been concussed GWS might have won.

 

[Suma Magic]

Right arm curled for impact.

Wouldn't be surprised to see him get off due to finals. Shouldn't but probably will

It was curled. He was going hard at the ball, eyes for the ball, was touching the ball when the two players collided. He just protected himself from a potential impact.

 

[Membling]

It was curled. He was going hard at the ball, eyes for the ball, was touching the ball when the two players collided. He just protected himself from a potential impact.

Curled arm, bracing for impact, hits player high. Regular season he gets pinged.

 

[UnitedWarrior93]

Went for the ball.

Incidental Contact. Play on.

Considering he already has got lucky this season with 2 coward punches, he has to go for this hit.

I can't see how he doesn't go for it, went the bump, got him in the head, and he went off concussed. GONE!

 

[random260]

 

[Suma Magic]

Curled arm, bracing for impact, hits player high. Regular season he gets pinged.

It was a collision not a one way hit.

Cotchin was touching the ball and only had eyes on the ball when shiel collided with Cotchin.

 

[Lensen]

Right arm curled for impact.

Wouldn't be surprised to see him get off due to finals. Shouldn't but probably will

braced. Not curled. you're allowed to protect yourself in a contest

 

[Winky]

It was two players going to pick up the ball. Two players with eyes for the ball.

It was a collision not a one-way bump.

If you take someone high while picking up the ball you don't get fined or suspended.

Not for me, Cotchin went for the man head first, while Shiel was upright just taking possession. Result was basically a head butt from Cotchin

 

[Korn]

Nah he will get off.
100% certain.

 

[DemonTim]

Cotchin needs to be suspended as his actions here helped his team win the game. Had Shiels not been concussed GWS might have won.

Pretty ****ed off cotchin. Can't believe he hit a random person as well as Shiel.

 

[jerry springer]

The headslam Nakervis did doesn't look too flash either

 

[JasRulz63]

Maybe he should've kept his hands to himself the other two times this season. Let's not forget that if he gets a fine and gets suspended, it's also because he couldn't help whacking Neale in the jaw or Lonie in the body.

 

[pjcrows]

No chance he misses.