List Mgmt. Trade & F/A - 2018/2019 - Part 3

[Chrispiesssss]

Jeff Garlett on the rookie list wouldn’t be the worst option.

Josh Walker could be useful as KPD depth.


Callum ah Chee would be a token pick. He’s averaging 4.5 clearances per game.

We need to move either Howe, Murphy or Schaz to the forward line. We have too many of these half-back flankers.

I also think we need to go all out on Jeremy Cameron or Ben Brown. I’m sick of having these “mediocre” forwards. However, I understand that we probably won’t be able to fit De Goey, Moore, Grundy, Stephenson and another potential superstar in our salary cap. Only way that would work is if the rest of the team is B-grade or below.

Would we be happy if:
Grundy - 1. 2 mil
De GOEY - 1. 2mil
Moore - 800
Stephenson - 600
Cameron/Brown - 1. 2 mil

Essentially half our salary cap to 5 superstars.

Would we be okay with this scenario?
It’s similar to the Richmond model.

Lynch, Martin, Prestia, Rance and Cotchin probably take up a large chunk of their salary cap.

 

[Albert Parker]

You clearly haven’t watched Atu play if you think I he can’t stick a tackle...

I was referring to Broomhead, who was referenced later in the discussion that I was responding too (note my comment about shoulder susceptibility).
I'm sure Atu can tackle given his Union background. Not nearly at the level to be playing seniors yet though.

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

Jeff Garlett on the rookie list wouldn’t be the worst option.

Josh Walker could be useful as KPD depth.


Callum ah Chee would be a token pick. He’s averaging 4.5 clearances per game.

We need to move either Howe, Murphy or Schaz to the forward line. We have too many of these half-back flankers.

I also think we need to go all out on Jeremy Cameron or Ben Brown. I’m sick of having these “mediocre” forwards. However, I understand that we probably won’t be able to fit De Goey, Moore, Grundy, Stephenson and another potential superstar in our salary cap. Only way that would work is if the rest of the team is B-grade or below.

Would we be happy if:
Grundy - 1. 2 mil
De GOEY - 1. 2mil
Moore - 800
Stephenson - 600
Cameron/Brown - 1. 2 mil

Essentially half our salary cap to 5 superstars.

Would we be okay with this scenario?
It’s similar to the Richmond model.

Lynch, Martin, Prestia, Rance and Cotchin probably take up a large chunk of their salary cap.

What's with the Ah Chee mention, he's going to Brisbane and this has been known for ages.

 

[Chrispiesssss]

What's with the Ah Chee mention, he's going to Brisbane and this has been known for ages.

Callum Ah Chee

“He’s been tempted by the Brisbane Lions I understand it,” Edmund told SEN Breakfast.

“There’s a link there with Dom Ambrogio who is the list manager, he was the recruiter who actually drafted him to the Suns in the first place.”


Don’t think he’s requested a trade to Brisbane. Just a trade in general.

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

Heard the Cats are pretty confident they'll get Jeremy Cameron

Absolutely no chance of leaving GWS, as he will sign a long term contract with the Giants.

 

[BringouttheGimp]

Thoughts on WHE Thomas and the Crock for Jason Castagna?

 

[loki04]

If it releases Degoey into the middle why not? I don’t care how the goals are kicked, he’s someone that can add fire power.

Because he doesn't adress KPF or small crumbing deficiencies and adds more of the same.

However I get it if we lose Elliott, Degoey pegged for full time midfield, WHE moved back to wing.

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

or the Could Not.

Kelly is the Exception of the Rule

Or they could.

 

[Bramax]

Pies only needed a small crumbing forward for 5 years.

Exhibit A

 

[DaVe86]

I'm happy to see talk about a small crumbing forward.

As bad as we need a KPF, we have another major hole for a crumber. We have used JT, Varcoe and Cal Brown in this role, but all were very average this year and barely hit the score-board. Cal Brown and JT are more midfielders who are playing pressure forward roles, and Varcoe is slowing up.

I would love to be in the race for Papley, but if the reported figures of 700K are true then that's ridiculous for a crumber. You can get them pretty cheap in the draft.

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

Maybe we could develop Quaynor into a crumbing forward?

 

[ThePhantom777]

I'm happy to see talk about a small crumbing forward.

As bad as we need a KPF, we have another major hole for a crumber. We have used JT, Varcoe and Cal Brown in this role, but all were very average this year and barely hit the score-board. Cal Brown and JT are more midfielders who are playing pressure forward roles, and Varcoe is slowing up.

Could Daicos play this role?

 

[Soups]

While I think we should pick up a crumbing forward, I think we can still utilise the players we have. I have been saying it for years, we don’t get to the right spots when the ball comes in. We have the tallest player in the league and hardly anyone gets front and center of him. A few little tweaks, and guys like Thomas and Stevo can improve us in that area.

 

[LuckyLee]

While I think we should pick up a crumbing forward, I think we can still utilise the players we have. I have been saying it for years, we don’t get to the right spots when the ball comes in. We have the tallest player in the league and hardly anyone gets front and center of him. A few little tweaks, and guys like Thomas and Stevo can improve us in that area.

The last good crumbing forward we had was Andrew Krakouer. He was terrific for the time that he was with us. We could certainly use some more indigenous talent on our list. We must have close to the league's lowest representation on that front.

 

[nahnah]

The last good crumbing forward we had was Andrew Krakouer. He was terrific for the time that he was with us. We could certainly use some more indigenous talent on our list. We must have close to the league's lowest representation on that front.

With Wells and Varcoe retiring we have 0, bulldogs have 0 too

 

[wicksy]

The last good crumbing forward we had was Andrew Krakouer. He was terrific for the time that he was with us. We could certainly use some more indigenous talent on our list. We must have close to the league's lowest representation on that front.

Wellingham is the only indigenous Collingwood player to have won a premiership.
Pretty disgusting in my opinion.

 

[manicpie]

Could Daicos play this role?

NO

 

[CFC2010]

Wellingham is the only indigenous Collingwood player to have won a premiership.
Pretty disgusting in my opinion.

Its not our fault Davis was shit in Grand Finals.

 

[left at home]

Maybe we could develop Quaynor into a crumbing forward?

Thought attu is being developed for that role

 

[Seedsfan]

Wellingham is the only indigenous Collingwood player to have won a premiership.
Pretty disgusting in my opinion.

Davis is a premiership player.

 

[left at home]

Davis is a premiership player.

Mite have been give a medal but never played in one, so no he is not

 

[Seedsfan]

Mite have been give a medal but never played in one, so no he is not

Yet is officially recognised as one. Either way the point of Wellingham being the only aboriginal premiership player at the Pies. Well we have aboriginals play in all our GF sides this century we just lost them. Of course when 11 of our 15 flags happen before 1936 there isn’t a great number of aboriginal premiership players

 

[left at home]

Yet is officially recognised as one. Either way the point of Wellingham being the only aboriginal premiership player at the Pies. Well we have aboriginals play in all our GF sides this century we just lost them. Of course when 11 of our 15 flags happen before 1936 there isn’t a great number of aboriginal premiership players

While l agree we have not had enough aboriginals playing for us which is another story altogether, fact remains it was only MM that got him the medal, not playing on the day

 

[Seedsfan]

While l agree we have not had enough aboriginals playing for us which is another story altogether, fact remains it was only MM that got him the medal, not playing on the day

AFL rules do state though if you play in the draw then your team wins you’re a premiership player. May not be the way anyone wants to get a medal but **** I would still take that over Buckley’s Norm Smith

 

[adrian25]

Wellingham is the only indigenous Collingwood player to have won a premiership.
Pretty disgusting in my opinion.

Who cares what nationality the players are. Just win grand finals.