Roast St Kilda in no mans land

[ScrappyDo]

I'll like to formally apologize for calling St Kilda a treadmill team.

Also thanks to for the second rounder.

You're very welcome. Thanks for paying us a 2nd and 4 rounder to get it.
And thank you for the last 7,502 days. Each one has been an absolute treasure. ❤

 

[Atomboy]

You're very welcome. Thanks for paying us a 2nd and 4 rounder to get it.
And thank you for the last 7,502 days. Each one has been an absolute treasure. ❤

How many years is 7,500 days ?

 

[StCicatriz]

What the hell even is this post?

Oh look at hawks fan defending the hawks fan. Very brave.

 

[Delisted]

Oh look at hawks fan defending the hawks fan. Very brave.

I'm curious too though. Why you talking about homeless people in a St kilda thread?

Oh..

 

[ScrappyDo]

How many years is 7,500 days ?

I believe it's a very, very long time.....

 

[BIGHAWK23]

Oh look at hawks fan defending the hawks fan. Very brave.

Defending?

Pull your head in

Noone needs defending from St Kilda fans

Your team doesn't even defend

 

[Nvent]

One question to Saints fans.
Thoughts on starting a season with 7 first 22 players missing and another 3 off no pre season.
Must be a concern.

 

[Pistol Night]

One question to Saints fans.
Thoughts on starting a season with 7 first 22 players missing and another 3 off no pre season.
Must be a concern.

You pretty well answered it for them

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

It was all going so well and then you lost to Richmond in the first game of the season. After leading by 7 goals.

The only way it could get any worse was if you sold out of the next two drafts for a bloke who won’t play for the next year. Oh…..

One day you’ll shed your Bluenesia and realise that you are the St Kilda of the 21st century (eg. a bit of a joke).

Well at least you have the self awareness to realise that your club is a joke! I suppose you've been a joke since 1966 and we've been a joke since 2002.

It's a better to be a joke club that once achieved something of relevance though.

 

[Nvent]

Well at least you have the self awareness to realise that your club is a joke! I suppose you've been a joke since 1966 and we've been a joke since 2002.

It's a better to be a joke club that once achieved something of relevance though.

Nothing worse in sport than cheating

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

Nothing worse in sport than cheating

Come back to me mate when your team is good enough to finally play finals footy.

 

[Nvent]

Come back to me mate when your team is good enough to finally play finals footy.

Come back to me when the stigma of cheating has cleared.

 

[jumperfan]

This is truly some sad and a pathetic sequence of posting for merely reading an opinion you don't agree with.
Go outside and touch grass ffs.

There’s a difference between posting a well-reasoned opinion and coming in here spewing conspiracies and poor attempts at trolling. Interesting that you choose to ignore those posts from one side of the fence.

 

[jannissary]

st kilda banter gets a bit worse when you remember their last premiership was before australia had colour tv.

 

[Pistol Night]

st kilda banter gets a bit worse when you remember their last premiership was before australia had colour tv.

Or man walked on the moon

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Oh look at hawks fan defending the hawks fan. Very brave.

I’m not defending the Hawks fan, he’s capable of handling himself.

Your post was really weird, as is this narrative that no one should criticize St Kilda.

 

[jumperfan]

I’m not defending the Hawks fan, he’s capable of handling himself.

Your post was really weird, as is this narrative that no one should criticize St Kilda.

No one is saying that mate. There is a legitimate discussion to be had on the topic. Issue is when posters come in with bad faith arguments to derail the thread on purpose, which in turn invites the defensive comments from St Kilda fans.

 

[Pistol Night]

No one is saying that mate. There is a legitimate discussion to be had on the topic. Issue is when posters come in with bad faith arguments to derail the thread on purpose, which in turn invites the defensive comments from St Kilda fans.

Great encapsulation of Bigfooty on the whole.

 

[jumperfan]

Great encapsulation of Bigfooty on the whole.

Pretty much the whole internet these days tbh.

 

[Delisted]

Your opinion is that they are in bad faith, but sadly many of them are true.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

No one is saying that mate. There is a legitimate discussion to be had on the topic. Issue is when posters come in with bad faith arguments to derail the thread on purpose, which in turn invites the defensive comments from St Kilda fans.

Ok, so what did you think about Josh Gabelich’s article yesterday, or more importantly Lyon’s comments about being a great place and ticking the boxes of being a destination club?

 

[Rabish Binney]

Or man walked on the moon

And Australia only converted to decimal currency 6 months earlier.......

 

[MisterMarcus]

I get the feeling people still think of St Kilda as a middle-aged team treading water. But in fact the Saints are the 5th youngest and 4th least experienced team in 2025. The 'old blokes' in the team are only 30-31 maximum. A fair chunk of the rebuild has already been undertaken, really.

They're at the stage where they still need to build their depth and experience, and if they have some key players missing then it risks getting ugly.

 

[Art Vandelay_]

There’s a difference between posting a well-reasoned opinion and coming in here spewing conspiracies and poor attempts at trolling. Interesting that you choose to ignore those posts from one side of the fence.

You're accusing someone with no real history of trolling because you don't like what was said.

And why would someone following Hawthorn bother to troll St.Kilda. So many things in your existence do that for yourselves. Weirdest fanbase with the largest chip on the shoulder.

 

[mad-saint-guy]

One question to Saints fans.
Thoughts on starting a season with 7 first 22 players missing and another 3 off no pre season.
Must be a concern.

Massive concern, compounded by the fact that this has been three case for all three seasons during the Lyon/Misson 2.0 era. Lots of saints fans like to say this is just bad luck but somehow we lead the league for stress fractures while also being the weakest, least explosive squad in the comp. At least early in 2023 we could run teams off their feet in the second half but that's out the window now as well