Review Round 14, 2024 vs GWS

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Sorry just woke up...

Geez it must have been hard to kick with all that rain....

Geez it must have been hard to kick with that howling wind.....

What?

Seriously?

Unwatchable Slip.

But hey we will announce something shiny Monday and we have no debt.... Stop complaining and support your team you ungrateful bastard.
Just woke up? Were you in our midfield this afternoon?
 
This won't be popular but it's time for a serious discussion about Rozee and Butters. On current form - as in, two months worth of form - neither are starting midfielders. In no particular order, Wines, Drew, Horne-Francis and Mead are all significantly better players and we look far more difficult to beat at stoppage when it's a combination of that quartet instead of Rozee and Butters.

Arguably we would be better served as a team if we played them both as forwards where their physical and mental softness will be less costly and their clever little tricks might actually result in goals rather than turnovers and easy clearances to the opposition.

The fact that they are captain and vice captain is nothing short of hilarious.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

This won't be popular but it's time for a serious discussion about Rozee and Butters. On current form - as in, two months worth of form - neither are starting midfielders. In no particular order, Wines, Drew, Horne-Francis and Mead are all significantly better players and we look far more difficult to beat at stoppage when it's a combination of that quartet instead of Rozee and Butters.

Arguably we would be better served as a team if we played them both as forwards where their physical and mental softness will be less costly and their clever little tricks might actually result in goals rather than turnovers and easy clearances to the opposition.

The fact that they are captain and vice captain is nothing short of hilarious.

Or after half a season as captain and vice captain you could you know, back them in.

It’s not like they’ve been there 12 years.

What’s the excuse for McEntees abhorrent game today?
 
This won't be popular but it's time for a serious discussion about Rozee and Butters. On current form - as in, two months worth of form - neither are starting midfielders. In no particular order, Wines, Drew, Horne-Francis and Mead are all significantly better players and we look far more difficult to beat at stoppage when it's a combination of that quartet instead of Rozee and Butters.

Arguably we would be better served as a team if we played them both as forwards where their physical and mental softness will be less costly and their clever little tricks might actually result in goals rather than turnovers and easy clearances to the opposition.

The fact that they are captain and vice captain is nothing short of hilarious.
Disagree on Butters but Rozee for sure needs to spend the majority up forward for mine. Too soft on the ball to be a full time midfielder. Would much rather see Drew in the CBAs.
 
This won't be popular but it's time for a serious discussion about Rozee and Butters. On current form - as in, two months worth of form - neither are starting midfielders. In no particular order, Wines, Drew, Horne-Francis and Mead are all significantly better players and we look far more difficult to beat at stoppage when it's a combination of that quartet instead of Rozee and Butters.

Arguably we would be better served as a team if we played them both as forwards where their physical and mental softness will be less costly and their clever little tricks might actually result in goals rather than turnovers and easy clearances to the opposition.

The fact that they are captain and vice captain is nothing short of hilarious.
IMO Butters and Rozze are suffering from Ken's ineptitude. Ken's giving no structure, gameplan, or tactics & it's causing Rozee & Butters to go out on a limb and figure things out themselves.
 
A broken footy club, from the top to the bottom, every level.

Koch is primarily responsible but this is his vision. He doesn't want tough or aggressive. Nor does he want win at any cost mentality. What he wants is a virtue signaling family club where everybody hugs everybody else and nobody is to blame for anything as that may lead to people not feeling good about themselves.

This is ALL David Koch.

From the moment he walked in to the joint his ego told him "nah **** 150+ yrs of tradition" I'm building this in to my vision, I'm here for change and stability.

Congrats, Dave. Fantastic job.
It’s not just him.
 
Or after half a season as captain and vice captain you could you know, back them in.

It’s not like they’ve been there 12 years.

What’s the excuse for McEntees abhorrent game today?

For all of McEntee's limitations he at least puts his body on the line and exerts maximum effort at every contest, which is probably why he gets a game every week. Rozee and Butters are Nick Kyrgios style footballers - all of the talent in the world but no hunger for the contest or the hard work required to be great. Get them to watch the way Callan Ward goes about it to see just how far they are off the pace in terms of toughness and unconditional effort.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Review Round 14, 2024 vs GWS

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top