Rate my team Part III

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Defenders: Goddard, Enright, Duffield, Hodge, J Russell, Kennely, Hunt (Markovic, Silvagni)

Mids: Ablett, S Thomson, Armitage, Masten, Trengove, Martin (Barlow, Schuey)

Rucks: Sandilands, Tippet (Warnock, J Roughead)

Forwards: Riewoldt, Gia, LeCras, Dangerfield, Gray, Medhurst, Ziebell (Davis, Podsiadlly)


Only one I am not sure about is Jordan Russell

Looks like a very solid team, as a carlton supporter i would probably not go russel a similar priced pick that could work out well for you would be birchall or Ellis apart from thats no real worries at all

can someone do mine now


Backs: hodge shaw mackie gilbee harbrow malcheski ladson (waters, maguire)

Mids: Bartell Mitchell (c) ball robinson martin shuey ( banner Barlow)

Rucks: tippet hille (warncok skipper)

Forwards: Reiwvoldt (vc) harvey gia brennan buddy ziebell hall (rockliff gumbleton)
 
Cheers mate, I would prefer Hunt over Ladson but is a 50-50 either way. i think you may be a bit top heavy in your forward line. I would take out Franklin and put in a Murphy type sort of player.

I take that is Mitch Robinson in the middle? You are probably better off getting a Scully/Trengove sort of player and then upgrading Luke Ball to a Jobe Watson sort of player.

With Russell I am sort of hoping this is going to be his breakout year, Run and carry sort of guy who you guys will look to carry the ball out of defence
 
Thoughts?

Backs:
Hodge
Enright
Harbrow
Dempsey
H. O'Brien
T.Kennelly
H.Shaw
(J.Hunt)
(A.Smith)

Midfielders:
Cooney
Dal Santo
Mitchell
Masten
J.Watson
D.Martin
(Barlow)
(Shuey)

Rucks:
Hille
Sandilands
(Warnock)
(Browne)

Forwards:
Porplyzia
LeCras
Hall
Dangerfield
Ziebell
Franklin
T.Varcoe
(Gumbleton)
(Rockliff)
 

Log in to remove this ad.

BACKS:
Corey Enright $394,300 :thumbsu:
Luke Hodge $366,800 :thumbsu:
Heath Shaw $365,400 :thumbsu:
Clancee Pearce $246,000 - could be a decent choice if he gets upgraded, pretty risky though when you've got B Sheppard also.
Nick Malceski $242,800 :thumbsu:
Josh Hunt $164,100 :thumbsu:
Bradley Sheppard $133,500 - hasn't played much in the pre-season. not sure if he'll play enough for you to select him on the ground.
----
Matt Maguire $101,700
Phil Davis $94,500

MIDS:
Jimmy Bartel $480,200 :thumbsu:
Bryce Gibbs $470,000 :thumbsu:
Matthew Boyd $456,400 :thumbsu:
Sam Mitchell $449,200 :thumbsu: - considering how much your defence falls away after the third keeper i'd think about dropping one of your keeper mids to a mid-pricer and use the cash to bolster your back-line.
Dustin Martin $149,500 :thumbsu:
Mitchell Banner $94,500 :thumbsu:
----
Michael Barlow $105,800
Luke Shuey $94,500

RUCKS:
Mitch Clark $414,800 :thumbsu:
Nick Naitanui $232,400 :thumbsu:
----
Robert Warnock $101,800
Jordan Roughead $94,500 - i like one of the Hawthorn rucks in this possie. With Taylor going down Skipper or Grimley will most likely play a lot.

FORWARDS:
Nick Riewoldt $468,100 :thumbsu:
Ryan O'Keeffe $425,400 :thumbsu:
Daniel Giansiracusa $378,500 - potentially has value at his price, getting old though and succumbed to injuries last year.
Lance Franklin $354,900 :thumbsu:
Eddie Betts $274,300 - not for me. only averages around 60 for the last four years. B Hall or a Ziebell have more upside.
Hayden Ballantyne $238,400 :thumbsu:
Patrick Dangerfield $232,000 - nothing wrong with this choice, but not sure if you want three sub-300k forwards though.
----
Tom Rockliff $101,100
Cameron Hitchcock $97,800


I've still got $138,700 left in the bank, thoughts?

my thoughts in red.
 
In the backline I wouldn't advise having O'brian and I would have maguire on the bench.
In the midfild I would be starting with two rookies.
Rucks i am not very keen on hille- coming of injury i don't seem him scoring well.
Fowards you haven''t spent enough, i dont like proplyzia and varcoe.
 
BACKS:
Corey Enright $394,300
Luke Hodge $366,800
Heath Shaw $365,400
Clancee Pearce $246,000
Nick Malceski $242,800
Josh Hunt $164,100
Bradley Sheppard $133,500
----
Matt Maguire $101,700
Phil Davis $94,500

MIDS:
Jimmy Bartel $480,200
Bryce Gibbs $470,000
Matthew Boyd $456,400
Sam Mitchell $449,200
Dustin Martin $149,500
Mitchell Banner $94,500
----
Michael Barlow $105,800
Luke Shuey $94,500

RUCKS:
Mitch Clark $414,800
Nick Naitanui $232,400
----
Robert Warnock $101,800
Jordan Roughead $94,500

FORWARDS:
Nick Riewoldt $468,100
Ryan O'Keeffe $425,400
Daniel Giansiracusa $378,500
Lance Franklin $354,900
Eddie Betts $274,300
Hayden Ballantyne $238,400
Patrick Dangerfield $232,000
----
Tom Rockliff $101,100
Cameron Hitchcock $97,800



I've still got $138,700 left in the bank, thoughts?


Not sure if Pearce will get elevated after last night. Very ordinary.
 
Backs: Enright, Hodge, Shaw, Harbrow, Dempsey, Malceski, Hunt (Farmer, Maguire)

Mids: Bartel, Boyd, Lewis, Mackay, Martin, Barlow (Shuey, Banner)

Rucks: Clark, Tippett (Roughead, Prato)

Forwards: Riewoldt, Pavlich, Giansiracusa, Franklin, Gray, Dangerfield, Campbell (Rockliff, Hitchcock)

What you think? Any major concerns?

Bank: $12,300
 
Any suggestions? Got 4,400 left.

Backs
Gram
Doughty
Hodge
Mitch Brown
Kennelly
Ladson
Waters
--------
Sheppard
Maguire

Midfield
J.Selwood
S.Black
Higgins
D.Beams
Masten
Martin
----------
Trengrove
Shuey

Rucks
Kruezer
Naitanui
---------
Trengrove
Charman

Forwards

J.Brown
Pavlich
Gia
Franklin
Porplyzia
LeCras
Ziebell
---------
Gumbleton
Dennis-Lane

I was thinking about maybe downgrading Sheppard to another first year player who'll play to free up some money and upgrade, Ladson or Waters.
 
Any weaknesses in my team guys?

Backs - Enright, Fisher, Hodge, H. Shaw, Malcheski, Kennelly, Hunt (Maguire, Davis)
Mids - Bartel (c), Boyd, Watson, Masten, Martin, Barlow (Banner, Shuey)
Rucks - Sandi, Tippett (Warnock, Roughhead)
Forwards - Roo, Pav, Gia, Buddy, Grey, Zeibell, Dangerfield (Rockliff, Hitchcock)

600 bucks left lolz!!

Not so happy bout Fisher tbh....
Also need to know guys Malcheski or Ladson + 65k which = watson to selwood/mitchall and Fisher to Duffield?
Pav still the way to go?

Thx for help guys!
 
Backs: Enright, Hodge, Shaw, Harbrow, Dempsey, Malceski, Hunt (Farmer, Maguire)

Mids: Bartel, Boyd, Lewis, Mackay, Martin, Barlow (Shuey, Banner)

Rucks: Clark, Tippett (Roughead, Prato)

Forwards: Riewoldt, Pavlich, Giansiracusa, Franklin, Gray, Dangerfield, Campbell (Rockliff, Hitchcock)

What you think? Any major concerns?

Bank: $12,300

One of the better sides I have seen on here mate, kudos.

Defence: The Lack of Goddard is made up by having 5-6 potential keepers.

Mids: A pretty good structure. Bartel and Boyd are locks in my side. I'd keep an eye on Lewis; He is a steal at that price however there is an injury concern over him at the moment. Mackay was one of the mid-pricers I identified in the off-season. He appears to be fit, but that hasn't translated into good DT form so far. Is this a concern for you? I know you probably can't look into it much (Factors such as Weather and Team Performance) but I would hope to see a bit of a leap in the remaining NAB challenge action. Wouldn't mind your take on it actually, with your Adelaide connection? Sensible move in starting 2 rookies, although I think leaving Trengove out may come back to bite you.

Rucks: Nice little combo. Having seen it too much and it has the potential to net you ~ 180-200 points a week.

Forwards: Can't fault that forward line mate.
 
Any ideas on my team guys, made a few changes since my last post:

$10,200 Left.

Backs:
B. Goddard
C. Enright
L. Hodge
B. Lake
J. Hawksley
M. Broadbent
R. Ladson

B. Sheppard
P. Davis


Mids:

D. Swan
J. Bartel
A. Cooney
P. Dangerfield
J. Trengove
D. Martin

A. Morabito
L. Shuey


Rucks:
M. Clark
M. Kreuzer

W. Skipper
J. Trengove


Forwards:

N. Riewold
A. Didak
L. Franklin
R. Murphy
R. Gray
J. Polkinghorne
T. Lynch

C. Hitchcock
T. Dennis-Lane


Thoughts?
 
dt_online.jpg




Whadda y'all think?
Still got 64 k left.
 
One of the better sides I have seen on here mate, kudos.

Defence: The Lack of Goddard is made up by having 5-6 potential keepers.

Mids: A pretty good structure. Bartel and Boyd are locks in my side. I'd keep an eye on Lewis; He is a steal at that price however there is an injury concern over him at the moment. Mackay was one of the mid-pricers I identified in the off-season. He appears to be fit, but that hasn't translated into good DT form so far. Is this a concern for you? I know you probably can't look into it much (Factors such as Weather and Team Performance) but I would hope to see a bit of a leap in the remaining NAB challenge action. Wouldn't mind your take on it actually, with your Adelaide connection? Sensible move in starting 2 rookies, although I think leaving Trengove out may come back to bite you.

Rucks: Nice little combo. Having seen it too much and it has the potential to net you ~ 180-200 points a week.

Forwards: Can't fault that forward line mate.

Thanks for the insight mate. I wasn't aware of the injury concerns over Lewis. He is definitely a steal at that price but I'll have to take a look into how he is travelling. How will the injury to Sewell effect him do you think?

Mackay is one that I am relatively keen on. It has been hard to gauge how he will go in the season proper due to the wet conditions and getting belted by the Power but Mackay got plenty of it and was one of the standouts yesterday against Melbourne. It was also raining here yesterday but it will be interesting to see how his performance translates into DT scores when the Freako email comes out.

Your right, I don't feel safe not including Trengove in my mids. Last year I opted to not take Rich and it left me a fairway behind the competition as it became incredibly hard to make sufficient cash out of the cash cows i did take from the start (Anthony, Beams, Robinson etc).
I'm really hoping Silvagni can get elevated taking Grovers spot in the side. That way I can downgrade Farmer and pick up Trengove for Banner/ Shuey.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

dt_online.jpg




Whadda y'all think?
Still got 64 k left.
I think you have to make a decision between either Seaby or Hille, can't have both in the same squad. I would also take out Connors and bring in Trengove/Scully. I would then upgrade Malceski from the money you got from Seaby to a better player.

Solid team though
 
Hi Guys,

I have just updated my team and would appreciate some positive or negative feedback about my team below.

BACKS

Goddard Brendan
Enright Corey
Hodge Luke
Shaw Heath
Ladson Rick
Hunt Josh
Waters Beau

Maguire Matt
Webberley Jeromey

CENTRES

Bartel Jimmy
Stanton Brent
Selwood Joel
Mitchell Sam
Martin Dustin
Banner Mitch

Jetta Lewis
Shuey Luke


RUCKS
Aaron Sandilands or Mitch Clark
Hille David

Warnock Robbie
Skipper Wayde

FORWARDS
Chapman Paul
Riewoldt Nick
Johnson Steve
Giansiracusa Daniel
Betts Eddie
Dangerfield Patrick
Rockliff Tom

Podsiadley james
Hitchcock Cameron
 
Hi Guys,

I have just updated my team and would appreciate some positive or negative feedback about my team below.

BACKS

Goddard Brendan
Enright Corey
Hodge Luke
Shaw Heath
Ladson Rick
Hunt Josh
Waters Beau

Maguire Matt
Webberley Jeromey

CENTRES

Bartel Jimmy
Stanton Brent
Selwood Joel
Mitchell Sam
Martin Dustin
Banner Mitch

Jetta Lewis
Shuey Luke


RUCKS
Aaron Sandilands or Mitch Clark
Hille David

Warnock Robbie
Skipper Wayde

FORWARDS
Chapman Paul
Riewoldt Nick
Johnson Steve
Giansiracusa Daniel
Betts Eddie
Dangerfield Patrick
Rockliff Tom

Podsiadley james
Hitchcock Cameron

Not a bad team at all.
First Collingwood supporter's team I have seen without Ball in it!!!

My comments, and these are simply comments as like me most DTer's have researched enough to know what's what by now!

Hille, Chappy and Johnson are all iffy with injuries. Add that to Ladson, Hunt and Waters and you could look famous or get hit with injuries badly.
I think I only made 4 trades that weren't injury related last year so I am putting a premium on keepers that will play 18+ games.

Mez
 
Not a bad team at all.
First Collingwood supporter's team I have seen without Ball in it!!!

My comments, and these are simply comments as like me most DTer's have researched enough to know what's what by now!

Hille, Chappy and Johnson are all iffy with injuries. Add that to Ladson, Hunt and Waters and you could look famous or get hit with injuries badly.
I think I only made 4 trades that weren't injury related last year so I am putting a premium on keepers that will play 18+ games.

Mez

Thanks for the feedback mate!

Yeah thats deffinatley the one thing im worried about with this team is the risk of injuries.

If the risk pays off though i would think it will be worth it. Just got to pray i have some luck....or try and find a few players around the same value that will be reliable
 
Any suggestions? Got 4,400 left.

Backs
Gram
Doughty
Hodge
Mitch Brown
Kennelly
Ladson
Waters
--------
Sheppard
Maguire

Midfield
J.Selwood
S.Black
Higgins
D.Beams
Masten
Martin
----------
Trengrove
Shuey

Rucks
Kruezer
Naitanui
---------
Trengrove
Charman

Forwards
J.Brown
Pavlich
Gia
Franklin
Porplyzia
LeCras
Ziebell
---------
Gumbleton
Dennis-Lane

I was thinking about maybe downgrading Sheppard to another first year player who'll play to free up some money and upgrade, Ladson or Waters.

Seems like I've been forgotten. Any ideas?
 
am i crazy starting 3 rooks in the middle?

Backs
goddard, hodge, enright, duffield, shaw, hunt, waters (maquire, webberly)

Mids
Bartel, mitchell, ball, trengove, barlow, martin (shuey, banner)

Rucks
Sandilands, Mitch Clarke (roughead, warnock)

Forwards
Roo, rok, pav, buddy, gia, dangerfield, hitchcock (pods, rockliff)

Thoughts?

reds highlight keepers.
 
am i crazy starting 3 mids in the middle?

Backs
goddard, hodge, enright, duffield, shaw, hunt, waters (maquire, webberly)

Mids
Bartel, mitchell, ball, trengove, barlow, martin (shuey, banner)

Rucks
Sandilands, Mitch Clarke (roughead, warnock)

Forwards
Roo, rok, pav, buddy, gia, dangerfield, hitchcock (pods, rockliff)

Thoughts?

reds highlight keepers.

I would think youd be better starting 6 ;)
 
I think you have to make a decision between either Seaby or Hille, can't have both in the same squad. I would also take out Connors and bring in Trengove/Scully. I would then upgrade Malceski from the money you got from Seaby to a better player.

Solid team though


thanks for the feedback.

I have seaby and hille as I believe they will both improve and make me some $$, so round 6ish ill be looking at having a Petrie or similar along side jolly.

Also, is their something about Connors you know that others don't? Because it seems like everyone is picking him.
I must admit though, I've never heard of any of these children, except for Silvagni, was impressed with his game last night.

I'm relying heavily on this board for my choice of children.
 
To be honest I haven't seen enough of Connors to comment but if you already have Martin in your team I wouldn't have two midfielders from the same side that is going to get pumped quite a few times this year
 
hey guys would appreciate some feedback

Backs: Goddard, hodge, Shaw, Harbrow, Malceski, Ladson, Waters (Davis, Silvagni)

Mids: Swan, Mitchell, J,selwood, Watson, ball, Martin (Shuey, banner)

Rucks: Tippet, Hille (R,Warnock, Roughead)

Forwards: Reiwoldt, Pavlich, Giansiracusa, Franklin, gray, Dangerfield, hitchcock (Dennis-Lane, podsiadly)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top