Player X vs Y

[Jiska]

Pick 2 of Ellis, Polec, Michie.

 

[JPod_31]

Libba vs Cotchin?
Cotchin could get back to his best but burnt me last year, and Libba could improve on last year, but don't know what to expect as he could be tagged. Both potential guns.

I would pick Libba because Griffen would be the one who will be tagged and Libba will win plenty of the ball. Cotchin will be tagged nearly every game.

 

[Chappycats]

Pick 2 of Ellis, Polec, Michie.

I'd go with Ellis and Polec although I have all 3.

Cotchin & Caddy + $100k( gives me more flexibility with upgrades for underperforming rookies)

Vs

Murphy & Roughnuts + extra trade(as in these 2 would be set and forget but Caddy would probably be upgraded after the bye)

Any and all suggestions welcomed, cheers.

 

[JPod_31]

Downgrade Grimes-Suckling or Shaw and Upgrade Aish-Macrae?

 

[Jiska]

I'd go with Ellis and Polec although I have all 3.

I've got Ellis, Polec, Tyson, Crouch, Robertson

Cotchin & Caddy + $100k( gives me more flexibility with upgrades for underperforming rookies)
Vs
Murphy & Roughnuts + extra trade(as in these 2 would be set and forget but Caddy would probably be upgraded after the bye)

Don't like Caddy as a SC option, but then again I don't like Furphy much either.

Forced to choose, I'd go the Furph and Roughuts.

 

[scaryness]

Watson (M3) and Hogan (F5) + 6k left
vs
Tyson (M6) and Martin (F2)/Franklin (F2)/Chapman (F3) and 50k+ left

 

[Dominion]

Watson (M3) and Hogan (F5) + 6k left
vs
Tyson (M6) and Martin (F2)/Franklin (F2)/Chapman (F3) and 50k+ left

Tyson and Martin IMO, though you should find room for Buddy as well.

I've got 2: Higgins vs Hogan

and one I'm sure has been gone over before, but the thread is too long to go through the whole thing... Goldstein vs Minson.

 

[cdcanman]

Pick 2 of Ellis, Polec, Michie.

Ellis and Polec ahead of Michie.
Ellis has some proven form when healthy. Polec was a highly talented youngster, high draft pick, who had injury interruptions and was unsettled at Brisbane. Untapped potential.
Michie is less proven. Not a high draft pick. Played a total of 1 senior game at Freo. He had some injury concerns too, but he also put together some solid blocks of continuous footy at WAFL level. Why didn't he get a crack in the seniors? Perhaps he is similar to Levi Greenwood at NM, very good footballer at the lower level, not quite up to it at AFL standard.
He'll get his chance at Melbourne though, may prove me to be an imbecile.

 

[richolovesgoal]

Tyson and Martin IMO, though you should find room for Buddy as well.

I've got 2: Higgins vs Hogan

and one I'm sure has been gone over before, but the thread is too long to go through the whole thing... Goldstein vs Minson.

I'd go Goldy just cos he's playing for a better team and it'll be tough for Minson to back up and All Australian year.

Jacobs and Mitchell or Ryder and Enright?

 

[scaryness]

Last question I will ask (i promise )
I have two team variations need to know which is best

Hurn (D2), Shuey (M5), Tyson (M6), Martin (F2), Franklin (F3), 31k
vs
Simpson (D2), Watson (M3), D Thomas (M6), T Mitchell (F2), Caddy (F5), 6k

As I was typing it out I think its obvious but need thoughts anyway

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Last question I will ask (i promise )
I have two team variations need to know which is best

Hurn (D2), Shuey (M5), Tyson (M6), Martin (F2), Franklin (F3), 31k
vs
Simpson (D2), Watson (M3), D Thomas (M6), T Mitchell (F2), Caddy (F5), 6k

As I was typing it out I think its obvious but need thoughts anyway

Possible to do Simpson, Watson, Tyson, Martin and Caddy?

 

[DEECEE]

Polec or Aish?

Not a money factor, can afford both. BE is v similar. Wondering who will give better output.

 

[Test Tickle]

Polec or Aish?

Not a money factor, can afford both. BE is v similar. Wondering who will give better output.

Polec because he has had a better pre season and i'm not confident Aish will be named at this stage.

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Polec or Aish?

Not a money factor, can afford both. BE is v similar. Wondering who will give better output.

Aish doesn't fill me with confidence. Polec on the other hand...

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Pick one out of mummy,Lobbe and Jacobs?

 

[Clutch]

Jacobs for me, mummy to injury prone and Lobbe is fist but Jacobs safer I think. And Renouf or redden could affect Lobbe.
Laidler, michie, c beams v Daisy, Georgiou, m crouch.

 

[Jiska]

Pick one out of mummy,Lobbe and Jacobs?

Mummy.. Lobbe..

In that order.. Not quite sure who that third player is?? Was he the guy that was named Ruck in the All-Spud Team??

 

[Test Tickle]

Mummy.. Lobbe..

In that order.. Not quite sure who that third player is?? Was he the guy that was named Ruck in the All-Spud Team??

thats him, he was Captain.

 

[Jiska]

thats him, he was Captain.

Nooooooooooooo he was not..

Broughspud was Captain, Duffspud was Vice.. Judd_Magic was Chairman of selectors - he can confirm..

 

[Judd_Magic]

Nooooooooooooo he was not..

Broughspud was Captain, Duffspud was Vice.. Judd_Magic was Chairman of selectors - he can confirm..

Hah!

Yes I can confirm this as Chairman of selectors.

Duffield was definitely vc of the All Australian Spud Team.

He did a great job spudding it up all year and leading by example to the other spuds like Broughton, Jacobs, etc.

 

[KardiniaPark]

Polec because he has had a better pre season and i'm not confident Aish will be named at this stage.

Aish will be named and play every week.

 

[cdcanman]

Polec or Aish?

Not a money factor, can afford both. BE is v similar. Wondering who will give better output.

Impossible to tell having seen so little of both.
Polec is the safe pick given he has spent longer in the system and has shown better form in preseason FWIW.
Aish has played senior footy and is very highly thought of by recruiters and so-called draft experts. Might surprise a few...

 

[Test Tickle]

Aish will be named and play every week.

i do hope so
So i can lock him in now?

 

[timtamWB]

Libba vs Cotchin?
Cotchin could get back to his best but burnt me last year, and Libba could improve on last year, but don't know what to expect as he could be tagged. Both potential guns.

Libba won't get tagged, his game doesn't suit it plus you would tag Griffen ahead of him. I'd go Libba.

 

[Amazing Bombers]

Laidler and D Martin + 47k or Suckling + Gunston.