Most overrated player in the AFL currently?

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Tim English
Mitchell Lewis
Isaak Rankine
Elliott Yeo
Zac Butters
Darcy Parish
Matt Rowell
George Wardlaw
Max King
Tom McCartin

Wowsers. You got some good players in there. Are you saying they're just overrated or you don't rate them at all?

I would say english, Lewis, Rankine, butters, Rowell are atleast above average players and will have/have had long careers. The rest I can see an argument for.
 
All the attributes
All the tools

What's does even mean?
He seems pretty vanilla.

Powerful like Petracca, with strong hips and the ability to break tackles effortlessly. A bull at the contest, he has the potential to be one of the best contested midfielders in the game. While not a naturally gifted endurance athlete, his elite acceleration enables him to explode out of stoppages.

Like any young player, he needs a consistent run at it to grow into his body and reach his full potential—something he obviously hasn’t had the opportunity to do yet.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Wowsers. You got some good players in there. Are you saying they're just overrated or you don't rate them at all?

I would say english, Lewis, Rankine, butters, Rowell are atleast above average players and will have/have had long careers. The rest I can see an argument for.
Just over rated/over paid.

I like Butters but commentators carry on like he's Hayden Bunton Sr.
I've seen plenty of games where he's a a bit shit.
 
Did not come in here expecting Wardlaw slander.
Genuine goer, issues have been around injuries.
Anyone who reckons he just can't go hasn't been paying attention. Hope he gets a sustained crack at it
 
Cerra's output is great when he is out on the park.
Seems harsh to call blokes overrated due to injury stuff
He averages a touch under 20 disposals, 1/3 of a goal, and 300m gained. He offers little positional flexibility. And then you come here to overrated thread and describe his output as 'great'. You're kind of making my point for me.
 
He averages a touch under 20 disposals, 1/3 of a goal, and 300m gained. He offers little positional flexibility. And then you come here to overrated thread and describe his output as 'great'. You're kind of making my point for me.
So your saying not let the door him on the way out ..🤣.

What players did freo get for him ?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Most overrated player in the AFL currently?


Write your reply...

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top