Prediction Harry Sheezel - Can he be the GOAT?

[Arr0w]

Plenty of time for Pistol Night

 

[Elixuh]

Best 1-3yr player in the game at present. My view is he will be the GOAT

 

[nahnah]

This Sheezel kid has a good head on his shoulders.

When asked on SEN this morning which player, past or present, did he model himself on, his answer - Scott Pendlebury.

At the GF parade he got a lot of support from the pies fans in the crowd in my area… unlike Curnow

 

[Fadge]

At the GF parade he got a lot of support from the pies fans in the crowd in my area… unlike Curnow

Surprising that...NOT!

 

[Meteoric Rise]

I think it’s pretty crazy that the player with the greatest finals records ever and greatest singular season ever and also is 8th all time total career Brownlow votes isn’t allowed to get a mention.

I also think people don’t understand the difference between greatest (which implies success and achievements) and best. As you mentioned GAS I’ll use him. Is he one of the best players of all time, yep even top 4 by me. However is he one of the greatest when you look at his achievements? I’d honestly struggle to put him in the top 10.

No Flag from 4 GFs, not a legend, 1 B&F, only 3 Coleman’s, No Brownlow (which matters because Lockett has one as a fwd)

Being in the TOC albeit the bench is super impressive and prevents him from dropping below top 15 imo.

I’m not having a go that’s just what it is. I think I’m actually being pretty fair with this but I’m expecting a laughing emoji from Fadge and Cats supporters on here anyway.

Having 6 more successful footballers in his own family pretty much rules GAS out I would have thought.

 

[Cleansweep17]

Having 6 more successful footballers in his own family pretty much rules GAS out I would have thought.

Haha but for real.

Between the two Abletts 2-6 GF record is a poor return. It’s my firm belief that you need a positive W/L record in GFs to be the GOAT.

Think about it, could you really say so and so is the GOAT but he gets beaten most of the time (or even every time) in the most important game of the year. Sounds stupid.

 

[BRider]

He also had a better debut season then Daicos. He is so young still as well. He has gone to another level this season, not hard to see why as the kid is as professional as they come along with his unreal skill set.

 

[Sector 7G]

He also had a better debut season then Daicos. He is so young still as well. He has gone to another level this season, not hard to see why as the kid is as professional as they come along with his unreal skill set.

Was a bit of a nothing game on the weekend. Game high disposals without much impact (only 3 SI) and a couple nice moments and a couple of blunders that cost goals. A good example of how racking up stats in the back half is over rated.

 

[Arr0w]

He also had a better debut season then Daicos. He is so young still as well. He has gone to another level this season, not hard to see why as the kid is as professional as they come along with his unreal skill set.

Much better debut season compared to Nicki, and a year younger

Will improve output as your side gets stronger

 

[Arr0w]

Tough day at the office, but still racked them up and used it well

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Tough day at the office, but still racked them up and used it well

The hardest schools produce the toughest graduates.

 

[ferrisb]

You do realise that sheezal is a midfield and larkey is a key fwd right?

You do realise his name is spelt Sheezel and while he is a great prospect he is not 'a midfield', right?

 

[ferrisb]

He also watches every single AFL game, ie. is a nuttier footy fan than many of the posters here.

BigFooty: hold my beer...

 

[Osho]

Scheezel!

Geshundheit!

 

[HairyO]

The hardest schools produce the toughest graduates.

HBF is a pretty easy school. Particularly in a team seeing 60 or 80 I50 every match.

But he is well ahead of Daicos at the same stage.

 

[Fadge]

But he is well ahead of Daicos at the same stage.

Except Daicos was the Brownlow Medal favourite by this round in his second season.

I notice you can still get $170 about Sheezel - you guys had better snap those odds up quickly.... surely those odds won't last long!

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Except Daicos was the Brownlow Medal favourite by this round in his second season.

I notice you can still get $170 about Sheezel - you guys had better snap those odds up quickly.... surely those odds won't last long!

Daicos was the age of Methuselah compared to Sheezel in his second year.

 

[Arr0w]

Except Daicos was the Brownlow Medal favourite by this round in his second season.

I notice you can still get $170 about Sheezel - you guys had better snap those odds up quickly.... surely those odds won't last long!

Sheezel still has him covered by age, essentially this is Sheezel's first season compared to Nicki

 

[HairyO]

Except Daicos was the Brownlow Medal favourite by this round in his second season.

I notice you can still get $170 about Sheezel - you guys had better snap those odds up quickly.... surely those odds won't last long!

Yeah, imagine that. A team near the top of the ladder getting more votes than a team at the bottom of the ladder. I wonder if it was the first time that ever happened.

And a player in that team being the focus of the media every-single-week, vs a player getting almost zero focus because literally noone cares about that team.

What are the odds ?!?!

The simple, uncomfortable truth is, Daicos at the Roos would be nowhere as good. Sheezel at the Pies would have won the Brownlow.

 

[Fadge]

The simple, uncomfortable truth is, Daicos at the Roos would be nowhere as good. Sheezel at the Pies would have won the Brownlow.

'Truth'.

Even if Sheezel was injured for the last 4 games of the home and away season?

 

[HairyO]

'Truth'.

Even if Sheezel was injured for the last 4 games of the home and away season?

The way you lot carry on, and the way the media fawned over Daicos - easily.

 

[ChairmanZia]

You do realise his name is spelt Sheezel and while he is a great prospect he is not 'a midfield', right?

Great players are not always midfielders

 

[windyhill]

He seems to have inherited the ziebull role, a lot of cheap ball down back. The kick out from fullback where they play on really pad the stats out.

 

[Orange crush]

HBF is a pretty easy school. Particularly in a team seeing 60 or 80 I50 every match.

But he is well ahead of Daicos at the same stage.

This why Toby’s first year was better than both Naicos and Sheezel …. Playing on-ball for a team of kids and racking them up

 

[HairyO]

This why Toby’s first year was better than both Naicos and Sheezel …. Playing on-ball for a team of kids and racking them up

His first year was incredible given how regularly they got flogged. O'Meara's first 2 years for similar reasons.