EDFL Div 2 discussion 2025

[ROOTA#6]

.

.

.

unbelievable

 

[get it done]

For what it’s worth NS player number 29 kicked a Hadfield player in the head last week, it was just visible on camera and EDFL did nothing about it.

What Qtr and time in the game was that incident

 

[Turbos mail]

I’m glad that is clarified. No 10 from the seniors wasn’t wearing those white skins.

Just heard Apparently senior game 17 reports out of the game from both clubs. Police called as well by 1/2 time to come to ground. Wow wee if true EDFL have to act.
Anyone hear this??

 

[mores]

Just heard Apparently senior game 17 reports out of the game from both clubs. Police called as well by 1/2 time to come to ground. Wow wee if true EDFL have to act.
Anyone hear this??

You hear alot of things.

 

[RustyGatez]

What Qtr and time in the game was that incident

Q2 - 20:40

 

[Donald D]

Q2 - 20:40

Vision of the Haddy v NS game has been taken down. Is this good policy or EDFL ducking for cover once again?

 

[umpires call]

Good to see Westy get there season going after a reality check rd 1. Came to play instead of just going through the motions like week before. Big Maynie makes a massive difference getting his hand to the ball in the guts. The run and hardness at ball was back no doubt CD and Ash during the week have woken them up. Yes I know it was ES but it was a very good display the team work in 3rd and 4th quarters was excellent. The fwd line is very dangerous, 2 of them kicked big goals Church and young Hugo the rest chipped in but how they function together as a 6 is great. Evens just knows where to be also pushes up ground and his kicking is fantastic. O,Grady consistently leads provides a option, Stingle very unselfish happy to block or pass to player in better spot like evens also hits targets consistently. Ash would be very happy with his fwds. Mids awesome backs awesome too many to talk about hopefully they bring this game to Glenroy on Anzac day. Also a little dust up in 3rd quarter with a ES supporter or trainer not sure but he came onto ground throwing punches at players have noticed the 3rd quarter vision taken down

 

[Turbos mail]

Good to see Westy get there season going after a reality check rd 1. Came to play instead of just going through the motions like week before. Big Maynie makes a massive difference getting his hand to the ball in the guts. The run and hardness at ball was back no doubt CD and Ash during the week have woken them up. Yes I know it was ES but it was a very good display the team work in 3rd and 4th quarters was excellent. The fwd line is very dangerous, 2 of them kicked big goals Church and young Hugo the rest chipped in but how they function together as a 6 is great. Evens just knows where to be also pushes up ground and his kicking is fantastic. O,Grady consistently leads provides an option, Stingle very unselfish happy to block or pass to player in better spot like evens also hits targets consistently. Ash would be very happy with his fwds. Mids awesome backs awesome too many to talk about hopefully they bring this game to Glenroy on Anzac day. Also a little dust up in 3rd quarter with a ES supporter or trainer not sure but he came onto ground throwing punches at players have noticed the 3rd quarter vision taken down

Why do the league take down the vision or not show tribunal results??

 

[Turbos mail]

You hear alot of things.

Yes I do.

Why as a community sport do WE ALL tolerate this? Why do clubs continue to NOT stamp out this behaviour??
The only way is to remove this clubs in ALL grades to make a stance to show it’s no longer tolerated..

 

[grubba94]

Yes I do.

Why as a community sport do WE ALL tolerate this? Why do clubs continue to NOT stamp out this behaviour??
The only way is to remove this clubs in ALL grades to make a stance to show it’s no longer tolerated..

If the government/police/parents can’t control the youth, do we expect a league and volunteers to control them?

 

[RustyGatez]

Vision of the Haddy v NS game has been taken down. Is this good policy or EDFL ducking for cover once again?

Yeah because they know there was probably half a dozen reportable offences that they didn’t stamp out. This is only Round 2, wait until the wheels really start falling off at NS this year. Doors could be closing quicker than we think.

 

[local footy fan]

most decent people and clubs don't accept this thuggish type of behaviour , it seems to flourish at NS the edfl need to take a strong stance with this NOW and not sweep it under the carpet . Would any club want to take any players from NS into their club ? who would want hot heads and fire crackers ready to go off at the slightest provocation to create head aches and problems

 

[Vlodrive]

most decent people and clubs don't accept this thuggish type of behaviour , it seems to flourish at NS the edfl need to take a strong stance with this NOW and not sweep it under the carpet . Would any club want to take any players from NS into their club ? who would want hot heads and fire crackers ready to go off at the slightest provocation to create head aches and problems

Sadly behaviour like this tarnishes the comp. Div 2 starting to get a name for it self. Just add it to the list of reasons why it can
be hard to recruit into this division. Who could be arsed playing here when knuckle heads are running around fighting people over literal bullshit. I know this doesn’t happen all the time but it’s starting to become more frequent and something needs to be done.

 

[Turbos mail]

Sadly behaviour like this tarnishes the comp. Div 2 starting to get a name for it self. Just add it to the list of reasons why it can
be hard to recruit into this division. Who could be arsed playing here when knuckle heads are running around fighting people over literal bullshit. I know this doesn’t happen all the time but it’s starting to become more frequent and something needs to be done.

Common denominator and nothing gets done which in fact encourages that type of behaviour.

 

[Donald D]

How about this ChatGPT diatribe coming out of HQ. This is a snippet from an EDFL statement as written in the Leader Local. I almost spat my false teeth out. Anyone visiting Charles Mutton don’t feel welcome and safe!
“The EDFL continues to detest anti-social behaviour and will always work to stamp it out of the game we love to ensure all feel welcome and safe in participating in and around matches.”

 

[Joey Montoro]

most decent people and clubs don't accept this thuggish type of behaviour , it seems to flourish at NS the edfl need to take a strong stance with this NOW and not sweep it under the carpet . Would any club want to take any players from NS into their club ? who would want hot heads and fire crackers ready to go off at the slightest provocation to create head aches and problems

It’s unfair to tarnish all their players with the actions of a selfish undisciplined handful who cause trouble. frankly the club needs to do something about it for the sake of the whole club, not for just for the open age teams, but for the juniors and girls teams.

 

[RustyGatez]

It’s unfair to tarnish all their players with the actions of a selfish undisciplined handful who cause trouble. frankly the club needs to do something about it for the sake of the whole club, not for just for the open age teams, but for the juniors and girls teams

That’s is true but sadly those that choose to keep playing there are asking to be tarnished like that when these incidents are so frequent. Continuing to play at a club like that says that you’re accepting of this type of rubbish. Debt collectors are out for the hierarchy at NS anyway, lots of unpaid bills and finances in tatters. Tamer has checked out, the rest will walk and watch it all come to an end. At least Marwan and Army Abdulwahed saw the writing on the wall and jumped ship whilst they could.

 

[Turbos mail]

It’s unfair to tarnish all their players with the actions of a selfish undisciplined handful who cause trouble. frankly the club needs to do something about it for the sake of the whole club, not for just for the open age teams, but for the juniors and girls teams.

I appreciate your passion and love for your club. However where is the leadership and those running the club to rid it off these people. Apologies and sorry don’t cut it. It continues to happen over & over.
what if the league throw a suspension at no10 from the seniors as the guy had a playing top on with this number. Yes it wasn’t the senior player but it would really create a sense of angst towards this person. Horrible look and almost the type of behaviour that could potentially shut up a club.
For those good volunteers trying hard at NS you might think why continue, why bother! I’m sure there are some really good people giving up valuable time but you can’t control stupidity of what might be a majority rather than a minority.

 

[ZingerAbed]

I appreciate your passion and love for your club. However where is the leadership and those running the club to rid it off these people. Apologies and sorry don’t cut it. It continues to happen over & over.
what if the league throw a suspension at no10 from the seniors as the guy had a playing top on with this number. Yes it wasn’t the senior player but it would really create a sense of angst towards this person. Horrible look and almost the type of behaviour that could potentially shut up a club.
For those good volunteers trying hard at NS you might think why continue, why bother! I’m sure there are some really good people giving up valuable time but you can’t control stupidity of what might be a majority rather than a minority.

So let’s punish #10 because he wears the same number as a bloke who plays reserves at his club who gets to keep playing after punching on with someone in the crowd?

Have to either punish the whole club or the individual that committed the act but you can’t choose another individual to take the fall on behalf of the whole club.

 

[Turbos mail]

So let’s punish #10 because he wears the same number as a bloke who plays reserves at his club who gets to keep playing after punching on with someone in the crowd?

Have to either punish the whole club or the individual that committed the act but you can’t choose another individual to take the fall on behalf of the whole club.

Well It was in jest mate but wouldn’t that cause some real issues internally.

Did that player think of the implications to the current senior no10? That’s my point they don’t think and it continues to happen.

No umpire wants to go out there. No clubs want to go out there as its just not welcoming.. That kind of crap went out of footy years ago.
The mentality between winning & losing. It’s a sport and when talking juniors it’s about educating, developing your young players and play in the right spirit winning or losing is irrelevant and more so at that bottom divisions. However some coaches are purely in it for winning and have trouble accepting losing.

 

[Turbos mail]

Good to see Westy get there season going after a reality check rd 1. Came to play instead of just going through the motions like week before. Big Maynie makes a massive difference getting his hand to the ball in the guts. The run and hardness at ball was back no doubt CD and Ash during the week have woken them up. Yes I know it was ES but it was a very good display the team work in 3rd and 4th quarters was excellent. The fwd line is very dangerous, 2 of them kicked big goals Church and young Hugo the rest chipped in but how they function together as a 6 is great. Evens just knows where to be also pushes up ground and his kicking is fantastic. O,Grady consistently leads provides a option, Stingle very unselfish happy to block or pass to player in better spot like evens also hits targets consistently. Ash would be very happy with his fwds. Mids awesome backs awesome too many to talk about hopefully they bring this game to Glenroy on Anzac day. Also a little dust up in 3rd quarter with a ES supporter or trainer not sure but he came onto ground throwing punches at players have noticed the 3rd quarter vision taken down

Looks to be an east Sunbury trainer as he loses his first aid bag. Horrible look as they shouldn’t even be close to that action.

EDFL copping it as it’s all over social media the 2 incidents.

 

[Gazza1221]

Looks to be an east Sunbury trainer as he loses his first aid bag. Horrible look as they shouldn’t even be close to that action.

EDFL copping it as it’s all over social media the 2 incidents.

do you have the vision of this one Turbo?

 

[Vlodrive]

Statement from the league.

 

[Donald D]

Statement from the league.

Will be on 7 news tonight

 

[get it done]

Vision of the Haddy v NS game has been taken down. Is this good policy or EDFL ducking for cover once again?

Vision is still up, the NS player didn't play rd2, maybe he got reported and a forced holiday....?