Traded Dylan Shiel [traded with future 2nd to Essendon for #9 and future 1st round pick]

[Northernsoul74]

Carlton would happily offer our 1st next year (a likely pick in the 1-5 range) plus a late 1st this year for Shiel and Setterfield.

Why would GWS wait until next year to use a high draft pick? They will want this years so they can get try and replace him in this draft. Rightly so.

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

Tony 2 Phones has spoken:

Dosen't this bloke get a lot of things wrong? I remember last year when he had "exclusive footage" of Stringer meeting Geelong players at a cafe with the video being so bad that you couldn't see anything lols

 

[Malifice]

Why would GWS wait until next year to use a high draft pick? They will want this years so they can get try and replace him in this draft. Rightly so.

Because this way they'll have 2 x 1sts this year, and 2 x 1sts next year (a likely top 5 pick in a year they win the flag, maybe even pick 1, that comes into play before Academy selections).

They get to keep loading up while in the window, either trading those picks out for experience, or getting in more good kids, or both.

 

[Malifice]

Dosen't this bloke get a lot of things wrong? I remember last year when he had "exclusive footage" of Stringer meeting Geelong players at a cafe with the video being so bad that you couldn't see anything lols

He nailed Buddy to Sydney when everyone else was saying GWS.

Has contacts in Sydney.

 

[Beer n Skittles]

I guess GWS would prefer to deal with Carlton, who just have more currency to trade.

If it's Shiel & Setterfield pick 1 is going to be involved

 

[Roughies Boys]

Tony 2 Phones has spoken:

Means you ain't getting either... when has this guy ever got anything right...

 

[HawksILove]

 

[TiAn_]

In your imagination. The reality is most free agents dont move.

Some do. Better to trade him now before leaves next year. Unless you think the AFL will look after you on the compo, which is always a chance.

Conversely apart from a word in Bontempelli's ear maybe when he holidays with our guys, and possibly Daniel, we wouldn't covet any of yours.

Yeah, Sam Reid is much better than Jack Macrae lol... This thread isn't about Bulldog players though, it's about Dylan Shiel. Stay on topic.

 

[DapperJong]

Haven't watched much Giants games so i cant answer.

This is the answer to a lot of questions.

 

[TerryWallet]

Means you ain't getting either... when has this guy ever got anything right...

I guess sarcasm and a bunch of overwrought fans on a trade thread in August is not a good mix.

 

[mario bortallotto]

Davis, Hopper, Sheil, Cogs, Kelly, Greene, Lobb, Cameron, Paton, Whitfield, Shaw, Ward, Scully and Taranto.
Remember I said average of $600k but I can't see any of those being much under $500k, with a few over $700k

reasonable call

 

[Isaac Cumming No 1]

Some do. Better to trade him now before leaves next year. Unless you think the AFL will look after you on the compo, which is always a chance.



Yeah, Sam Reid is much better than Jack Macrae lol... This thread isn't about Bulldog players though, it's about Dylan Shiel. Stay on topic.

You start by claiming this thread is unanimous bar one person, obviously not even close to being true. Why lie about something like that?

You then attempt to instruct me on what I can post.

You ignore the obvious fact this thread isn't about "gws players" but is about Dylan Shiel.

So all in all a bit better than your usual posting quality I'd say.

 

[Shadow89]

Should be Shiel and Setterfield for pick 1, with picks 7, 12 and a third or fourth rounder for pick 1 to Adelaide. Can't see Hawthorn getting him with their draft position.GWS would be crazy to negotiate with Hawthorn over Carlton

 

[Malifice]

I guess GWS would prefer to deal with Carlton, who just have more currency to trade.

If it's Shiel & Setterfield pick 1 is going to be involved

Pick 1 is involved in us drafting Walsh.

GWS can have our 1st next year (again, a likely top 5 pick, and maybe even 1 again) plus a late 1st this year.

At this stage probably Sydneys 1st rounder (we'd look to trade out 2 x 2nds for their 1st so they have more points for Blakey).

 

[Roughies Boys]

Should be Shiel and Setterfield for pick 1, with picks 7, 12 and a third or fourth rounder for pick 1 to Adelaide. Can't see Hawthorn getting him with their draft position.GWS would be crazy to negotiate with Hawthorn over Carlton

GWS don't decide this....

 

[Malifice]

GWS don't decide this....

Seeing as both players are contracted, yes they do.

 

[Shadow89]

GWS don't decide this....

Who does? Hawthorn? Shiel can nominate Hawthorn if he likes, but GWS can just hold him to his contract and sort it out next year. Shaw, Deledio, Griffen and other potential retirees will loosen up the cap, so trading Shiel this year while they're still in the premiership window has to be of benefit to them. They're not just going to give him away to a club who offers them less just because he wants to go there.

 

[Isaac Cumming No 1]

Seeing as both players are contracted, yes they do.

Finally someone gets it

 

[Beer n Skittles]

Pick 1 is involved in us drafting Walsh.

GWS can have our 1st next year (again, a likely top 5 pick, and maybe even 1 again) plus a late 1st this year.

At this stage probably Sydneys 1st rounder (we'd look to trade out 2 x 2nds for their 1st so they have more points for Blakey).

Why would GWS even agree to trade Shiel at all? They'd hang on to him for another year rather than take the old bigfooty multi-pick package.

The only thing that even tempts them to the trade table is pick 1.

 

[Malifice]

Why would GWS even agree to trade Shiel at all? They'd hang on to him for another year rather than take the old bigfooty multi-pick package.

Salary cap squeeze is the strong mail.

And we are basically offering them Pick 1. Or at least a top 5 pick. Along with the Suns, Carlton would be close to Spoon favorites next year. Can anyone honestly see us crawling out of the bottom 5 next year?

Plus we're throwing in an extra 1st round pick in this years draft.

 

[TiAn_]

You start by claiming this thread is unanimous bar one person, obviously not even close to being true. Why lie about something like that?

You then attempt to instruct me on what I can post.

You ignore the obvious fact this thread isn't about "gws players" but is about Dylan Shiel.

So all in all a bit better than your usual posting quality I'd say.

This is all very off topic Mr. No 1.

I suggest you keep the discussion to Dylan Shiel's impending move.

 

[Beerfish]

Can anyone honestly see us crawling out of the bottom 5 next year?

If the dogs can win a flag anything is possible.

 

[Isaac Cumming No 1]

This is all very off topic Mr. No 1.

I suggest you keep the discussion to Dylan Shiel's impending move.

I wish you had.

 

[TazHawk15]

Carlton would happily offer our 1st next year (a likely pick in the 1-5 range) plus a late 1st this year for Shiel and Setterfield.

That’s all well and good but why would he want to go to a basket case?

 

[Beerfish]

That’s all well and good but why would he want to go to a basket case?

Same reason Judd did?