Review Cats drop Bombers by 45 at MCG

Remove this Banner Ad

Tonight's win was the stabiliser that Geelong's Bi-Polar 2024 season so desperately needed.

With perrenial All-Australian Tom Stewart plainly struggling under recent, relentless pressure, the Match Committee finally, belatedly pulled the trigger and moved him into the middle of the ground, an area in which we have struggled mightily in recent weeks.

Stewart was slow to adapt to the new discipline, but to his credit he stuck to his task and gradually worked his way into the game.

Our other main onfield leader given the absence of Tom Hawkins is of course the captain Patrick Dangerfield, and he was superb. It's funny, at his peak I marked him super-hard; my expectations of him were sky-high.
Now that he has entered his footballing autumn years I value his contributions more than ever before.

Ollie Dempsey's verve has been a real gift in a trying year; he was excellent again tonight, full of ideas. The advantage of being super-fit is that you can actually compete at an intense level and still think when you need to.

The defensive stoppage breakdown that saw us unable to contest the throw-in and then predictably concede a piss-easy goal was a lowlight of this post Selwood-era team.
Sam De Koning looked lost and outmanned at times in the ruck, but, much like last week he actually seemed to be getting the hang of things as the game wore on. Made some blues but also chipped in here and there.


It's been a tough year for Jack Henry.
He's seemingly lowered his colours every other week, if not every week.
He battled on gamely tonight though. He actually always does, it's never a question of application.
Fought it out really strongly tonight though, and gradually asserted himself.

Lawson Humphries was fine on debut, moves well - he'll get fitter and move even better.
Love the dual-sided aspect to his game.

Zac Guthrie's year has been pretty epic. I honestly think the quality of the footy he's produced this season is the equal of anything his brother has produced. Really strong again this evening.

Shannon Neale kind of faded as the night wore on, but he was prominent early; as usual it was a bit of a mixed bag; dropped some marks, but did some good things too (and clunked a contested grab in the F50 to boot).
He needs to make it his priority to never get out-marked in a F50 aerial contest. Missed a simple set-shot tonight but generally the mechanics of his kicking looks really good. Happy with that effort.

I'm a bit of a Knevitt advocate; I don't think he's ever played a disappointing senior game among his dozen to date. Gotta start getting more games into him, surely.
 
The Rising Star is a race in two

Windsor isn't even in the discussion and paying double figures - Darcy Wilson is seen to be the third option behind Wardlaw & Dempsey
Fair enough. Just basing it on my own vision, and that is patchy.
Dempsey is special, as is Wardlaw.
Not even sure how the voting works.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Duncan was cramping and they didnt want him to ping a calf again. But otherwise i agree.

Im not a fan of this ruck issue and we wont keep getting away with it. Must bring in conway next week.

Neale needs to go back to the vfl and work on his intensity.

But id keep humphries and knevitt in.

Better selection just need to drop one or two more vets next week (they will be but will probably be 'managed').
It’s likely Conway won’t even play VFL tomorrow due to injury
Was mentioned on pre game on Krock
 
60 inside 50s for 60 points...

So they essentially scored 1 behind per entry - that's a shocking conversion rate

Not wanting to be a Debbie Downer but it’s also slightly concerning that we are conceding that many inside 50’s each week. A better team would have been more productive scoring than they were.
 
Tonight's win was the stabiliser that Geelong's Bi-Polar 2024 season so desperately needed.

With perrenial All-Australian Tom Stewart plainly struggling under recent, relentless pressure, the Match Committee finally, belatedly pulled the trigger and moved him into the middle of the ground, an area in which we have struggled mightily in recent weeks.

Stewart was slow to adapt to the new discipline, but to his credit he stuck to his task and gradually worked his way into the game.

Our other main onfield leader given the absence of Tom Hawkins is of course the captain Patrick Dangerfield, and he was superb. It's funny, at his peak I marked him super-hard; my expectations of him were sky-high.
Now that he has entered his footballing autumn years I value his contributions more than ever before.

Ollie Dempsey's verve has been a real gift in a trying year; he was excellent again tonight, full of ideas. The advantage of being super-fit is that you can actually compete at an intense level and still think when you need to.

The defensive stoppage breakdown that saw us unable to contest the throw-in and then predictably concede a piss-easy goal was a lowlight of this post Selwood-era team.
Sam De Koning looked lost and outmanned at times in the ruck, but, much like last week he actually seemed to be getting the hang of things as the game wore on. Made some blues but also chipped in here and there.


It's been a tough year for Jack Henry.
He's seemingly lowered his colours every other week, if not every week.
He battled on gamely tonight though. He actually always does, it's never a question of application.
Fought it out really strongly tonight though, and gradually asserted himself.

Lawson Humphries was fine on debut, moves well - he'll get fitter and move even better.
Love the dual-sided aspect to his game.

Zac Guthrie's year has been pretty epic. I honestly think the quality of the footy he's produced this season is the equal of anything his brother has produced. Really strong again this evening.

Shannon Neale kind of faded as the night wore on, but he was prominent early; as usual it was a bit of a mixed bag; dropped some marks, but did some good things too (and clunked a contested grab in the F50 to boot).
He needs to make it his priority to never get out-marked in a F50 aerial contest. Missed a simple set-shot tonight but generally the mechanics of his kicking looks really good. Happy with that effort.

I'm a bit of a Knevitt advocate; I don't think he's ever played a disappointing senior game among his dozen to date. Gotta start getting more games into him, surely.
Brilliant summary of the game.
 
Not wanting to be a Debbie Downer but it’s also slightly concerning that we are conceding that many inside 50’s each week. A better team would have been more productive scoring than they were.
Hi Debbie.
 
Fair enough. Just basing it on my own vision, and that is patchy.
Dempsey is special, as is Wardlaw.
Not even sure how the voting works.

There's 11 judges, and come seasons end they award votes as per
5.
4.
3.
2.
1.

The max number of votes a player can receive is 55 - it's essentially based on hoe judges view each player's season
 
Knevitt is an AFL player. Been a bizarre non selection.

And a little crazy we left Humphries in the VFL and played Mullin.

SDK into the ruck has been a fantastic move. Delighted he is back on track in his career now.

Not many big men have his skill set.

We still have a load of issues, but they can be debated another day.

Great win.
 
Not wanting to be a Debbie Downer but it’s also slightly concerning that we are conceding that many inside 50’s each week. A better team would have been more productive scoring than they were.
and too often in football when it does, and a team concedes 120+. A disproportionate level of blame gets laid at the feet of defenders, who by being in D50 most of the time are not responsible for the weight of entries, or the pressure that may or may not be placed on them.

Think we rank lowly for scores conceded from possession. We simply give up too many turnovers this year.
Maybe Holmes back to halfback to accumulate the ball and use his run and long kicking will help us.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

2. Zach Tuohy- Probably our best in the 1st half when we were under siege. That was his best game in ages.

5. Jeremy Cameron- He's still not 100%, but much better staying in F50 because he's still a very potent threat around goals.

8. Jake Kolodjashnij- Can't Kick Kolo was back with a vengeance. It's not a night he'd want to remember.

9. Max Holmes- So important for us now that he's added the ability to win the inside ball to go with his run and carry on the outside.

10. Mitch Knevitt- I was pleasantly surprised. He might have spent the majority of the game guarding the dead wing, but did a few nice things. A couple of clever tap-ons and that goal at the end was a pearler.

12. Jack Bowes- Got a heap of the footy and was classy with most of his touches. Nice goal too.

13. Jhye Clark- Let's be honest. He's like the best Grade 3 kid playing against Grade 6ers. Barrels in hard and has a lot of skills, but is just not big enough yet not to get pushed around.

16. Sam de Koning- Lost the ruck contest, but also lost the timidness he's had since breaking his entire face. I'll take it.

17. Lawson Humphries- Very impressive debut. He looked like he belonged. I hope he gets a lot more opportunities this year.

18. Tyson Stengle- Combines the goalsneaking flair of Ronnie Burns with the laser guided set shots of Mark Williams. So important, and I'm really hoping the Kayo bobble heads were right about him staying.

22. Mitch Duncan- Another veteran who told Father Time to bugger off tonight. Was his best game all year.

23. Gary Rohan- Crucially important that he step up with Hawkins out. Which he did. I had him in my votes.

28. Oliver Dempsey- BOG by a much larger distance than he gave Jye Menzie. Could be our next Steve Johnson.

30. Tom Atkins- Worked hard all night, pretty unobtrusive game, and I have nothing to complain about really.

32. Gryan Miers- He looks like he's working his way out of a form slump. Not there yet, but he got a bit done and got back to setting up goals.

33. Shannon Neale- I thought he was OK. Not good, not bad, just OK. He drifted in and out of the game a bit but did a few nice things. Better at ground level than I expected.

35. Patrick Dangerfield- This guy's third efforts make some players' first efforts look tepid.

38. Jack Henry- Started off bad in a worrying height mismatch against Two Meter Peter, but gradually got on top in that battle. When Geelong started winning in the middle and Essendon's kicks inside 50 started turning into high long bombs I expected Wright to become more of a worry rather than less. Kudos to Jack.

39. Zach Guthrie- Has he taken over as Geelong's D50 general?

42. Mark O'Connor- Six touches, all of them ending up in Geelong hands, is a fine return from being subbed on 10m into the final quarter.

44. Tom Stewart- I didn't mind him playing midfield. His strength and speed helped a lot since we're still a bit shaky there.

45. Brad Close- He's not getting a heap of the ball but is making things happen when he does.

46. Mark Blicavs- I thought he had a really good second half, particularly the 3rd quarter, and was huge in turning the game our way.
 
Tonight's win was the stabiliser that Geelong's Bi-Polar 2024 season so desperately needed.

With perrenial All-Australian Tom Stewart plainly struggling under recent, relentless pressure, the Match Committee finally, belatedly pulled the trigger and moved him into the middle of the ground, an area in which we have struggled mightily in recent weeks.

Stewart was slow to adapt to the new discipline, but to his credit he stuck to his task and gradually worked his way into the game.

Our other main onfield leader given the absence of Tom Hawkins is of course the captain Patrick Dangerfield, and he was superb. It's funny, at his peak I marked him super-hard; my expectations of him were sky-high.
Now that he has entered his footballing autumn years I value his contributions more than ever before.

Ollie Dempsey's verve has been a real gift in a trying year; he was excellent again tonight, full of ideas. The advantage of being super-fit is that you can actually compete at an intense level and still think when you need to.

The defensive stoppage breakdown that saw us unable to contest the throw-in and then predictably concede a piss-easy goal was a lowlight of this post Selwood-era team.
Sam De Koning looked lost and outmanned at times in the ruck, but, much like last week he actually seemed to be getting the hang of things as the game wore on. Made some blues but also chipped in here and there.


It's been a tough year for Jack Henry.
He's seemingly lowered his colours every other week, if not every week.
He battled on gamely tonight though. He actually always does, it's never a question of application.
Fought it out really strongly tonight though, and gradually asserted himself.

Lawson Humphries was fine on debut, moves well - he'll get fitter and move even better.
Love the dual-sided aspect to his game.

Zac Guthrie's year has been pretty epic. I honestly think the quality of the footy he's produced this season is the equal of anything his brother has produced. Really strong again this evening.

Shannon Neale kind of faded as the night wore on, but he was prominent early; as usual it was a bit of a mixed bag; dropped some marks, but did some good things too (and clunked a contested grab in the F50 to boot).
He needs to make it his priority to never get out-marked in a F50 aerial contest. Missed a simple set-shot tonight but generally the mechanics of his kicking looks really good. Happy with that effort.

I'm a bit of a Knevitt advocate; I don't think he's ever played a disappointing senior game among his dozen to date. Gotta start getting more games into him, surely.

Spot on, as usual.
I wanted to be fair, but probably expected just a bit more from Knevitt.
Moved okay and classy goal, but could tell he wasn't quite used to the system.
Will improve given the chance though.
 
The number one priority for the rest of the season is managing both Danger and Chuckie like they did with Danger and Joel in '22. We aren't doing anything of any note this season without both of them fit, fresh and in form.

There's quite a few on here that don't like Rohan because he doesn't get too much of the ball but he's the one forward we have that jumps/crashes into packs with intent and causes spillages for our brilliant smalls. I love him as a player.
 
Does anyone actually listen to his vitriol?

He's such a W:anchor:
He is just another scumbag Richmond supporter, who like the rest of them, when their team is shit they hop off and Barack for whoever is playing Geelong.

Meet him once and let's just say the elevator doesn't quite make it to the top floor.
 
and too often in football when it does, and a team concedes 120+. A disproportionate level of blame gets laid at the feet of defenders, who by being in D50 most of the time are not responsible for the weight of entries, or the pressure that may or may not be placed on them.

Think we rank lowly for scores conceded from possession. We simply give up too many turnovers this year.
Maybe Holmes back to halfback to accumulate the ball and use his run and long kicking will help us.

Tonight was a great result but I tend to feel it said more about the Bombers (absolute pretenders) than it did about us. Our midfield concerns are still there albeit they performed much better tonight than they have recently.

Holmes running off half back works but we do miss him running away from the contest in the middle if he plays in defence. Where’s he best suited for the team? I’m not sure.

We did defend well tonight. Though their entries were extremely poor which made our job much easier.
 
Not wanting to be a Debbie Downer but it’s also slightly concerning that we are conceding that many inside 50’s each week. A better team would have been more productive scoring than they were.
I thought the conditions contributed to this as both teams were able to gain quick multiple entries by having a player back across 50-60m from goal to intercept hack kicks out of packs etc.

Be interested to know what the second half looked like.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Review Cats drop Bombers by 45 at MCG

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top