List Mgmt. 2025 List Management 📃

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Normally agree but is going back to our VFL side beneficial for any player?

Our VFL side is a disaster as well. How many of our players have gone back and done well or improved?

At worst his leadership back there will help Ben & Lucas develop.

 

[Bamboo Harvester]

How many of this Southport team would play in our AFL team

Jacob Dawson is the unluckiest not to be on an AFL list imo. Was totally mismanaged by GCS when they tried to turn him into a defender - but has since become the premier midfielder at state league level.

Still only 25yo - would have him in a heartbeat...he's now become an inside/outside midfielder which is invaluable in any side.

 

[DangerousD]

If Harry were to leave, what would he get on the open market?

If a club like the Hawks or Lions miss out on Allan, how much would they pay for Harry as they are in the premiership window now and the next few years?

 

[Monty1978]

If Harry were to leave, what would he get on the open market?

If a club like the Hawks or Lions miss out on Allan, how much would they pay for Harry as they are in the premiership window now and the next few years?

1 first rounder I reckon , maybe swap of picks later on , that’s today value ..his value has dropped … can’t see anyone giving us more. If I was Harry I would leave Melb and pay interstate

 

[DangerousD]

1 first rounder I reckon , maybe swap of picks later on , that’s today value ..his value has dropped … can’t see anyone giving us more. If I was Harry I would leave Melb and pay interstate

For a side in the window, i think they will pay considerably more, other teams aren’t scared to go all in and go for a flag.

For reference, last year Harry kicked 49 goals and had his highest output stats wise, other than his health issues this year, his market value should be very high.

 

[Monty1978]

For a side in the window, i think they will pay considerably more, other teams aren’t scared to go all in and go for a flag.

For reference, last year Harry kicked 49 goals and had his highest output stats wise, other than his health issues this year, his market value should be very high.

I’m thinking worse case scenario and how I project his year will go … ask me 6 months ago after those 49 goals 2 first rounders but if he decides he wants out and we agree and his year is cooked like now , 1 first rounder is what I predict
Good clubs over pay for real guns , Harry is abit of a liability

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Nathan Wardius kicked 7 so far against the Saints half way through the 4th qtr in the VFL.

Marking small forward

 

[Michael Jezz]

Far too early to be writing off Doc but would rather he find touch and form in the VFL

That mentality has lead to 25 years of pain

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Nathan Wardius kicked 7 so far against the Saints half way through the 4th qtr in the VFL.

Marking small forward

8 now

 

[Blue_Fusion]

If Harry were to leave, what would he get on the open market?

If a club like the Hawks or Lions miss out on Allan, how much would they pay for Harry as they are in the premiership window now and the next few years?

I'd say given he's contracted, 2 first round picks or a top 10 pick + a 2nd rounder.

 

[Michael Jezz]

I'd say given he's contracted, 2 first round picks or a top 10 pick + a 2nd rounder.

Harry's minimum value given picks blow out is a top 5 and a pick 10 to 15, which ends up being pick 8 and pick 17 to 20.

 

[ESKIE]

Trade him for a player / s

 

[Korn]

Jacob Dawson is the unluckiest not to be on an AFL list imo.

He was good last night. Not saying he's definitely at AFL level great, but he is very capable of slotting into our AFL team and replace some of our duds easily.

 

[LFTWNG11]

The best thing about Hawks having our two picks is that this club has absolutely no choice but to fight tooth and nail not to bottom out this year.

And when they do finish bottom 4, there is no silver lining to market on. No pick.1 to fawn over. No draft hall for AFL radio to praise.

Don’t get me wrong, I don’t think the club will change its approach or get any better at recruiting. It’s just they won’t get that sugar hit and they will be forced to actually think outside of the box.

 

[JJBagger]

The best thing about Hawks having our two picks is that this club has absolutely no choice but to fight tooth and nail not to bottom out this year.

And when they do finish bottom 4, there is no silver lining to market on. No pick.1 to fawn over. No draft hall for AFL radio to praise.

Don’t get me wrong, I don’t think the club will change its approach or get any better at recruiting. It’s just they won’t get that sugar hit and they will be forced to actually think outside of the box.

Jagga is essentially our pick for this year. Which we may have ended up paying unders for when looking back at it

 

[Red_man2008]

Dawson to take newmans LTI spot at mid season. Hopefully we’re still low enough on the ladder to have that option available to us.

 

[Soapy V]

Jagga is essentially our pick for this year. Which we may have ended up paying unders for when looking back at it

Two top 5 picks and a second rounder?

He better be the next Kouta and more

 

[JJBagger]

Two top 5 picks and a second rounder?

He better be the next Kouta and more

One first rounder. We used the other first and second rounder to upgrade the first we already had

 

[Soapy V]

One first rounder. We used the other first and second rounder to upgrade the first we already had

So part of the deal for him then

 

[TENACIOUS]

Agree in writing with Hawthorn. Harry for our Rd1&2 picks back. Tank the rest of the year, if TDK leaves we get picks 1,2&19 for Harry and TDK.

Then total cleanout of the football and recruiting department for delivering us a spoon

 

[dylan_mike1]

Next year we get a top 5 draft pick in Cody Walker and a top three draft pick in Jagga Smith. Now is not the time to panic and trade away our stars. A full year into the Campo boys, Moir, Jagga and Walker as our depth? We will make the hard calls after we win a flag next year.

Ah, I forgot about Cody. Around what number will he be picked?

On SM-S928B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[bradfisher14]

Ah, I forgot about Cody. Around what number will he be picked?

On SM-S928B using BigFooty.com mobile app

1

 

[liverpoolblue]

Ok lads as I was recently appointed Carlton's new list manager taking over nick austin I've compiled the following list of targets for the off season

OUTS
Delist (contract ending)
Haynes
McGovern
Docherty
Evans
Fantasia

Trade
McKay (mentally weak)
Acres (can't kick, no upside)
Williams (as above, on too much $)
Lewis young

INS
Target 3-4 of the following players: (all out of contract end of season 2025 and can get them for next to nothing)

Rosas jr GC small forward
Wicks Sydney small forward
Matt Rowell (I wish, maybe if Walsh leaves)
Calsher dear hawks tall forward
Logan morris lions tall forward
Shaun Mannagh cats small forward
Tom atkins mid Cats (experienced head)
Cam Guthrie cats
Ollie Dempsey cats
Starcevich lions (experienced head)
Callum ah Chee lions (I wish)
Nick Bryan bombers (ruck depth?)
Sam Draper bombers (if tdk leaves...)
Leek aleer gws
Xavier o'hallaron gws
Jase Burgoyne power
Dougal Howard saints

Out of contract 2026: (give them something before their contract runs down or they get nothing year after)

Daniel curtin crows
Jordan Butts crows
Zac bailey lions
Jake rogers GC
Darcy jones small fwd gws
Jack Buckley GWS
Willie Rioli power
Zac butters power
Harley Reid wce
Liam Ryan wce
Khamis wb
McNeil wb

Gettable / potentially unhappy players:
Petracca
Harley Reid (contract ends of 2026)
Liam Ryan (ends 2026)
Willie Rioli (ends 2026)
Butters (ends 2026)
Ryan Maric

Contracts end 2026/ pipedreams:
zac bailey
Jack Buckley
Darcy jones

Thoughts on who we could get?

• I think aleer from Gws to partner weiters and silvagni in defence
• Petracca potentially in a deal for harry
• wicks and/or Rosas jr
• atkins or starcevich for experienced heads
• rest of the picks, hit the draft for quick/ good ball users with heart

 

[Aphrodite]

Trade
McKay (mentally weak)
Acres (can't kick, no upside)
Williams (as above, on too much $)
Lewis young

For a so called ‘newbie’ & 1st post, poor form

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Ok lads as I was recently appointed Carlton's new list manager taking over nick austin I've compiled the following list of targets for the off season

OUTS
Delist (contract ending)
Haynes
McGovern
Docherty
Evans
Fantasia

Trade
McKay (mentally weak)
Acres (can't kick, no upside)
Williams (as above, on too much $)
Lewis young

INS
Target 3-4 of the following players: (all out of contract end of season 2025 and can get them for next to nothing)

Rosas jr GC small forward
Wicks Sydney small forward
Matt Rowell (I wish, maybe if Walsh leaves)
Calsher dear hawks tall forward
Logan morris lions tall forward
Shaun Mannagh cats small forward
Tom atkins mid Cats (experienced head)
Cam Guthrie cats
Ollie Dempsey cats
Starcevich lions (experienced head)
Callum ah Chee lions (I wish)
Nick Bryan bombers (ruck depth?)
Sam Draper bombers (if tdk leaves...)
Leek aleer gws
Xavier o'hallaron gws
Jase Burgoyne power
Dougal Howard saints

Out of contract 2026: (give them something before their contract runs down or they get nothing year after)

Daniel curtin crows
Jordan Butts crows
Zac bailey lions
Jake rogers GC
Darcy jones small fwd gws
Jack Buckley GWS
Willie Rioli power
Zac butters power
Harley Reid wce
Liam Ryan wce
Khamis wb
McNeil wb

Gettable / potentially unhappy players:
Petracca
Harley Reid (contract ends of 2026)
Liam Ryan (ends 2026)
Willie Rioli (ends 2026)
Butters (ends 2026)
Ryan Maric

Contracts end 2026/ pipedreams:
zac bailey
Jack Buckley
Darcy jones

Thoughts on who we could get?

• I think aleer from Gws to partner weiters and silvagni in defence
• Petracca potentially in a deal for harry
• wicks and/or Rosas jr
• atkins or starcevich for experienced heads
• rest of the picks, hit the draft for quick/ good ball users with heart

What the hell would we want Tom Atkins for? George Hewett is just a better version lol