While I have always been an advocate for the draft, it should never be a blanket approach
Players picked beyond to top 5 picks only average about 100 odd game career and you can find talent at every level
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
List Mgmt. 2024 List Management Part 2 š
- Thread starter Aphrodite
- Start date
- Tagged users None
While I have always been an advocate for the draft, it should never be a blanket approach
Players picked beyond to top 5 picks only average about 100 odd game career and you can find talent at every level
bradfisher14
Not actually Brad Fisher
Certainly not advocating for a blanket approach either. I would be willing to spend two firsts in a trade for a player more appropriate for our needs.
CrippaTheGoat9
Senior List
- Aug 28, 2024
- 161
- 723
- AFL Club
- Carlton
I actually hope we can get pick 12 off the suns and take pick 11 and 12 in the draft
Lucky we aren't spending 2 1st rounders if Houston nominates us
bradfisher14
Not actually Brad Fisher
Ok, what are we spending if he does?
A future 1st as the main currency
- Oct 4, 2015
- 12,848
- 23,708
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Exactly, if we were looking at a trade for Butters or Petracca, then two 1st round picks would make more sense...
One first rounder won't seal the deal for Houston... Port will want more and given he's contracted they have no reason not to... we will at the very least need to throw another pick upgrade in for them... whether that's our F2 for a 3rd rounder or something similar... it's still too much to pay for a hb.
I made this point years ago when we traded pick 8 for Saad... I didn't want us to do it back then, we did it and yes, while Saad has been a good pickup... he's 31 next year and we don't even have a single top 4 finish to show for it... clock is ticking away... he might retire or be very close to in a couple years...
Look at Port's midfield compared to ours... Houston's elite kicking works with them... with our one paced midfield that relies on Cripps... that floods the wing and doesn't move to create options... Houston will have a hard time having the same impact in navy blue... he's just the wrong player for us to target at this stage imo...
bradfisher14
Not actually Brad Fisher
I would be astonished if they accept that. If that ends up being the framework of the final deal Iāll be okay with it.
- Apr 16, 2008
- 10,443
- 29,290
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Houston would be great but heās a bit too old for my liking.
I donāt mind if we use a F1 for a player but preferably if they are around 20-24.
We have the senior players, letās hit the draft hard with 2/3 1st this year, a couple of young guys from other clubs that need a change and the Campos is what Iām hoping for
I donāt mind if we use a F1 for a player but preferably if they are around 20-24.
We have the senior players, letās hit the draft hard with 2/3 1st this year, a couple of young guys from other clubs that need a change and the Campos is what Iām hoping for
- Apr 20, 2006
- 9,544
- 12,873
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Weāve had about 15 first round picks in this rebuild. Using 1 on Saad who is one of our best players is irrelevant.
Weāve used about 10 first rounders on midfielders, and havenāt got a top 4 finish to show for it. Doesnāt mean you donāt need them too.
Jimmae
Brownlow Medallist
Who could possibly do that...
So we need our academy systems to shit diamonds and compliment them with top 30 picks? Ok, I'm down
- Oct 4, 2015
- 12,848
- 23,708
- AFL Club
- Carlton
It isn't... we should have brought him over without having to pay pick 8.
No draft pick is a guarantee...
That doesn't mean you throw your first round picks out for hbf's...
Chasing quality mature aged players like Saad and Houston should not be done at the expense of at the very least, trying to improve the midfield...
- Apr 20, 2006
- 9,544
- 12,873
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Zorko will probably win Brisbanes B&F, they are bloody important.
Edit. Not aimed at you but people were talking up Sydneyās small/mid forwards on here over the last few days. Are they now their problem?
In saying this imo small forwards are our biggest weakness and Iāve been annoying people for years about it.
Last edited:
- Oct 4, 2015
- 12,848
- 23,708
- AFL Club
- Carlton
A mid 30's player winning a B&F is outside of the norm. Basing my point on the fact that usually once players hit early to mid 30's, they decline.
Small forwards are one weakness... but our biggest is our midfield and I've been saying so for a while now...
- Aug 16, 2009
- 7,691
- 11,332
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- North Ballarat
Isn't it just the two? Dow & SPS? We've otherwise gone the recycle bin route.
Meanwhile we've allocated more resources to rebounding defenders than any other position.
Reckon things could get very very spicy.
Sydney will pissed at that & we know they have no problem make monstrous offer for a gun key forward.
Realistically (& Iām not saying we will/should etc) just purely asking a hypothetical questionā¦
what would we want from them, if they said āwe want Hā ?
FYI - they have picks (17 & 19)
And GF isnāt a valid answer
Sydney will pissed at that & we know they have no problem make monstrous offer for a gun key forward.
Realistically (& Iām not saying we will/should etc) just purely asking a hypothetical questionā¦
what would we want from them, if they said āwe want Hā ?
FYI - they have picks (17 & 19)
And GF isnāt a valid answer
bradfisher14
Not actually Brad Fisher
17, 19, Papley and Campbell as a starting point.Reckon things could get very very spicy.
Sydney will pissed at that & we know they have no problem make monstrous offer for a gun key forward.
Realistically (& Iām not saying we will/should etc) just purely asking a hypothetical questionā¦
what would we want from them, if they said āwe want Hā ?
FYI - they have picks (17 & 19)
And GF isnāt a valid answer
Still wouldn't do it though.
- Aug 16, 2009
- 7,691
- 11,332
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- North Ballarat
H is in our top 3 most important players to our side, structurally, we aren't trading him.
There is always a price
2, 3, 1st rounders? Cats certainly coughed up for Cameron
But doubt the Swans will consider going hard at a KPF, when their issue is their midfield in big games
2, 3, 1st rounders? Cats certainly coughed up for Cameron
But doubt the Swans will consider going hard at a KPF, when their issue is their midfield in big games
We can throw in Kennedy for Warner, Paps, 17 & 19
I don't agree. You take Cripps out of our midfield and we can still find a way to win.
You take Weiters out and we are going to struggle big time. We need to settle our back 6.
- Apr 20, 2006
- 9,544
- 12,873
- AFL Club
- Carlton
If we are talking decent resources then Walsh, SPS, Dow, Philp, Stoker, Fisher, Cuningham traded for Kennedy, Cerra and Setterfield. Only draft assets off the top of my head would be Cowan and Saad. Williams obviously cap space but apparently he was a midfielder but obviously a hbf.
I understand the reasons why, especially with some of the busts SOS had, but think Austin has been a little too conservative with the type of players Austin has recruited, trade and draft
Moir has some real xfactor, I'd like to see a little more of these types, especially later in the draft
Moir has some real xfactor, I'd like to see a little more of these types, especially later in the draft
Can someone explain to me how the Campo twins are the answer to a lot of questions & a fix to problems.
Admittedly I havenāt watched them a lot but neither is a touted as top 20 talent.
Admittedly I havenāt watched them a lot but neither is a touted as top 20 talent.
- Aug 16, 2009
- 7,691
- 11,332
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- North Ballarat
I skipped over Walsh of all people. Lol
I was thinking: Doc, Williams, Saad, Kemp, Boyd, Cowan & McGovern - we have more AFL calibre options back there than available positions, so we're now repurposing players elsewhere.
It might be a sign that perhaps the list is unbalanced but apparently not, because we're now apparently eyeing off Houston for a healthy chunk of $ and something resembling a first & a second round pick.
Edit: misread the previous post, thought you meant top 10 picks.
