I'm not as convinced on Kemp up forward but happy to see what he has to offer over the pre season. Ollie I love as a player but need to see a bit more before I have him as genuine best 23. I think atm he's a 25-28 player if we're at genuine full health (which is unlikely obviously)
...Harry Charleson
Billy Wilson - Harry O'Farrell - Jack Silvagni
Jaxon Binns - Cooper Lord - Lucas Camporeale
Lachie Fogarty - Harry Lemmey - Orazio Fantasia
Corey Durdin - Hudson O'Keefe - Ashton Moir
MarcPittonet - Ben Camporeale - Alex Cincotta
Matt Cottrell - Rob Monahan - Matt Duffy -...
Very extensive run down. It's the definition of 'success' that is the issue in our case. ROB is best 22, 1st ruck, plays vast majority of games but given his lack of basic skills, he doesn't successfully contribute to the team. I'd like to see us break the mould and prioritise a player in that...
...could hold down that spot. They then hold that spot through to their 30s (unless a gun ruck comes through, as happened to 28 year old MarcPittonet at Carlton). But only if they go past the ruck ahead of them (or one can hold down a key forward post, like Jackson). Otherwise, they will need...
The really weird thing about the 2014 draft weas that there were 7 players picked by other teams that ended up playing at Carlton.
They were,
Jarrod Pickett (4)
Caleb Marchbank (6)
Hugh Goddard (21)
Mitch McGovern (43)
MarcPittonet (50)
Oscar McDonald (53)
Josh DeLuca (68)
MSD/Rookie gets eaten up by Lord.
Out: 6 x Senior, 2 x Rookie, 1 x Cat-B
In: 7 x Senior, 1 x Rookie (Lord), 1 x Cat-B (Duffy) plus Boyd must be upgraded. So you need to find a way to move 2 senior players to the rookie list.
Yes.
I'm sure those of us who simply watched many games of footy throughout the season would provide more accurate 'rankings'.
I'll start with my top 10:
1. Heeney
2. Cripps
3. Daicos
4. Bontempelli
5. Hogan
6. Warner
7. Serong
8. Neale
9. Butters
10. Gawn
Would it? These are the top 10 rated players by average rating in 2024...
That doesn't look like a lucky dip to me.
In the match you gave Mitchell "clear BOG" he had 35 disposals gaining 340m, but went at 65% efficiency. 22 of his disposals were uncontested. He had 1 goal assist, no...
...have no trust for the player ratings (as the PF example you shared demonstrates well).
This year, for example, the player ratings have MarcPittonet in the top 25 players in the AFL! Meanwhile, it has Lachie Whitfield (who was rightfully AA) at 180th! It has Nick Bryan (Ess) rated ahead of...
...have possibly been as poor. Has gone from one of my favorite players on the list to someone who I have little empathy towards.
MarcPittonet: Before the preliminary final last year I wasn't as critical as many on Pitto. Unfortunately, that game demonstrated to me who he truly was (see the...
(note: Hopefully this formats correctly)
I received a one day (justified, emotions were running high from lots of people) ban from BigFooty for posting my - honest - feelings about three players. Perhaps it was in the wrong forum (game day thread) and could have been better posted here but I've...
...Lachlan Cowan
Patrick Cripps
Tom De Koning
Sam Docherty
Corey Durdin
Orazio Fantasia
Elijah Hollands
Oliver Hollands
Brodie Kemp
Matthew Kennedy
Mitch McGovern
Harry McKay
Jesse Motlop
MarcPittonet
Adam Saad
Sam Walsh
Jacob Weitering
Zac Williams
Lewis Young
...a flag right now with any combination featuring some of Adam Cerra, Zac Williams, Matt Kennedy, Lachie Fogarty, Mitch McGovern, Blake Acres, Orazio Fantasia, Sam Docherty, Elijah Hollands, Jack Martin, Caleb Marchbank, George Hewett, Nic Newman, MarcPittonet, Lewis Young or Adam Saad in the...
That reads as a wishful thinking article rather then anything credible being leaked.
No different to our boards rumours really. Only difference is Carlton can afford to offer more if Petracca is happy to go there.
...defensive flaws which hindered it in 2024.
When De Koning is back, and Jack Silvagni returns from his ACL, and Moir pushes up, plus MarcPittonet in the ruck, Carlton have more marking options forward than they need to partner dual Coleman Medalist Curnow.
McKay signed a bumper seven-year...
...- Brodie Kemp
C: Lucas Camporeale - Cooper Lord - Jaxon Binns
HF: Jesse Datolli - Harry Lemmey - Jack Silvagni
FF: Corey Durdin - Hudson O'Keefe - Orazio Fantasia
R: MarcPittonet - Ben Camporeale - Hewett/Kennedy
I/C: Matt Cottrell - Rob Monahan - Jamaine Jones - Alex Mirkov - Matt Duffy
We've still got a ways to go before we're competitive again and have flynn ,JWilliams and a few others around so getting someone who's not quite ready yet wouldn't be the end of the world
On SM-S921B using BigFooty.com mobile app
Yes any of those would be nice, Reeves the one I dont really want as hes a bit skinny so can be pushed off the ball and does less around the ground than Bailey does.
If we are offering massive overpay then who knows what we could shake loose.
The trade value is the problem, all those guys...
...someone whose ready to go tomorrow, not wait another 2 years while we get destroyed in the centre
Liam Reidy, Ned Reeves, Nick Bryan, MarcPittonet, Ned Moyle
Drastically overpay one of these. I know Ned Moyle signed on but 5 years 4 mill and see what happens at this point. Nick Bryan id...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.