AFootballParent
Rookie
Tasmania
South Sydney
Newcastle
Auckland
Tassie Devils
Auckland Tūkaha
Canberra Redbacks
Darwin Deadly
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Tasmania
South Sydney
Newcastle
Auckland
Link?Stadium redevelopments are back on the agenda in Auckland
Just saw an NZ herald article about it the other day. Don’t have a linkLink?
Link?
Even if Auckland is going to have an AFL standard ground to play at, I'm not sure the AFL could actually pressure anyone into playing games there. It seems like the secondary markets are largely between the clubs and the respective governments that pay them to play there, but I could be wrong.
True, I'd rather play there than Darwin or Cairns, it just seems like the Victorian clubs are moving more towards wanting to play in their own state, although Cunnington Cartel showed me that the Saints were interested in playing in Auckland.Population of 1.8m in Auckland. Wider market if more than 5m in NZ. A lot of potential members and sponsors.
If being paid the same per game, Auckland would be a more attractive prospect than selling games to NQ or the NT.
Part of the problem with these ventures is that it's usually similar teams every year. Fans will travel for a one off - if you recall the first Wellington game it got a decent crowd and lots of people flew over for it. 2nd year the tourists dried up as it was another St Kilda game. You need to change the teams every year.Population of 1.8m in Auckland. Wider market if more than 5m in NZ. A lot of potential members and sponsors.
If being paid the same per game, Auckland would be a more attractive prospect than selling games to NQ or the NT.
Part of the problem with these ventures is that it's usually similar teams every year. Fans will travel for a one off - if you recall the first Wellington game it got a decent crowd and lots of people flew over for it. 2nd year the tourists dried up as it was another St Kilda game. You need to change the teams every year.
Population of 1.8m in Auckland. Wider market if more than 5m in NZ. A lot of potential members and sponsors.
If being paid the same per game, Auckland would be a more attractive prospect than selling games to NQ or the NT.
Yeah, but it's also got the timezone/travel time issues of Perth, but without the supporters to make it worthwhile.
Having one bunch of teams travel every week and another bunch of teams essentially not travel at all is just unfair and logistically impossible for a bunch of reasons. It's best to even out the travel as much as possible.Here's another way they could do the conference system.
At 21 teams, two conferences.
Victoria Conference: 10 teams
Australian Conference: 11 teams (new teams are Tasmania, Canberra, WA3)
Vic conference play each other once = 9 games
Oz conference play each other once = 10 games
Vic conference play Oz conference once = 11 games = 20 games
Oz conference play Vic conference once = 10 games = 20 games
Vic conference have three double ups = 23 games
Oz conference have three double ups = 23 games
Vic conference have a top 5 finals series, Oz conference have a top 5 finals series, the preliminary finalists of each series swap over to ensure that it's a possibility that an all Vic or all interstate GF can still happen.
At 22 teams:
Victoria Conference: 10 teams
Australian Conference: 12 teams (Brisbane 2 added)
Vic conference play each other once = 9 games
Oz conference play each other once = 11 games
Vic conference play Oz conference once = 12 games = 21 games
Oz conference play Vic conference once = 10 games = 21 games
Vic conference have two double ups = 23 games
Oz conference have two double ups = 23 games
Vic conference have a top 5 finals series, Oz conference have a top 6 finals series, the preliminary finalists of each series swap over to ensure that it's a possibility that an all Vic or all interstate GF can still happen.
At 23 teams:
Victoria Conference: 10 teams
Australian Conference: 13 teams
Vic conference play each other once = 9 games
Oz conference play each other once = 12 games
Vic conference play Oz conference once = 13 games = 22 games
Oz conference play Vic conference once = 10 games = 22 games
Vic conference have one double up = 23 games
Oz conference have one double up = 23 games
Vic conference have a top 5 finals series, Oz conference have a top 6 finals series, the preliminary finalists of each series swap over to ensure that it's a possibility that an all Vic or all interstate GF can still happen.
At 24 teams:
Victoria Conference: 10 teams
Australian Conference: 14 teams
Vic conference play each other once = 9 games
Oz conference play each other once = 13 games
Vic conference play Oz conference once = 14 games = 23 games
Oz conference play Vic conference once = 10 games = 23 games
No double ups
Vic conference have a top 5 finals series, Oz conference have a top 6 finals series, the preliminary finalists of each series swap over to ensure that it's a possibility that an all Vic or all interstate GF can still happen.
At 25 teams:
Victoria Conference: 10 teams
Australian Conference: 15 teams
Vic conference play each other once = 9 games
Oz conference play each other once = 14 games
Vic conference play Oz conference once excluding one team = 14 games = 23 games
Oz conference play Vic conference once excluding one team = 9 games = 23 games
No double ups
Vic conference have a top 5 finals series, Oz conference have a top 6 or top 8 finals series, the preliminary finalists of each series swap over to ensure that it's a possibility that an all Vic or all interstate GF can still happen.
At 26 teams:
Victoria Conference: 10 teams
Australian Conference: 16 teams
Vic conference play each other once = 9 games
Oz conference play each other once = 15 games
Vic conference play Oz conference once excluding one team = 15 games = 24 games
Oz conference play Vic conference once excluding one team = 9 games = 24 games
No double ups
Vic conference have a top 5 finals series, Oz conference have a top 8 finals series, the preliminary finalists of each series swap over to ensure that it's a possibility that an all Vic or all interstate GF can still happen.
At 27 teams:
Victoria Conference: 10 teams
Australian Conference: 17 teams
Vic conference play each other once = 9 games
Oz conference play each other once = 16 games
Vic conference play Oz conference once excluding two teams = 15 games = 24 games
Oz conference play Vic conference once excluding two teams = 8 games = 24 games
No double ups
Vic conference have a top 5 finals series, Oz conference have a top 8 finals series, the preliminary finalists of each series swap over to ensure that it's a possibility that an all Vic or all interstate GF can still happen.
At 28 teams:
Victoria Conference: 10 teams
Australian Conference: 18 teams
Vic conference play each other once = 9 games
Oz conference play each other once = 17 games
Vic conference play Oz conference once excluding three teams = 15 games = 24 games
Oz conference play Vic conference once excluding three teams = 7 games = 24 games
No double ups
Vic conference have a top 5 finals series, Oz conference have a top 8 finals series, the preliminary finalists of each series swap over to ensure that it's a possibility that an all Vic or all interstate GF can still happen.
Cunnington Cartel what do you think? I'm sure there's a glaring flaw in this somewhere, but the point is, there is a way, but at some point, if the AFL did keep expanding and expanding, then not everyone could play each other once a year, but at least the Vic's could and it wouldn't be a long wait for teams who don't play each other to play again.
Sorry I should have clarified that Victorian teams would still travel exactly the same way they do now, it's just that these "conferences" would just be splitting the league up into two ladders so more teams stay alive during the season in their race for the finals.Having one bunch of teams travel every week and another bunch of teams essentially not travel at all is just unfair and logistically impossible for a bunch of reasons. It's best to even out the travel as much as possible.
Having one bunch of teams travel every week and another bunch of teams essentially not travel at all is just unfair and logistically impossible for a bunch of reasons. It's best to even out the travel as much as possible.
Good effort. I like how it facilitates an expanded number of clubs as time goes on, without needing to rejig the conferences during each expansion phase. During the early phases, the Vic double ups should be rotated each season; however, it would be good for the Aus double ups to be fixed so it maintains more derbies and slightly reduces the travel burden for non-Vic clubs (e.g. at 21 and 22 teams West Coast should always have double ups against Freo and WA3).Here's another way they could do the conference system. Edit: To clarify, it's a different kind of "conference" where it's more just splitting the league up into two different ladders, but Vic sides would still travel every 2-5 weeks or whenever it is they do now.
At 21 teams, two conferences.
Victoria Conference: 10 teams
Australian Conference: 11 teams (new teams are Tasmania, Canberra, WA3)
Vic conference play each other once = 9 games
Oz conference play each other once = 10 games
Vic conference play Oz conference once = 11 games = 20 games
Oz conference play Vic conference once = 10 games = 20 games
Vic conference have three double ups = 23 games
Oz conference have three double ups = 23 games
Vic conference have a top 5 finals series, Oz conference have a top 5 finals series, the preliminary finalists of each series swap over to ensure that it's a possibility that an all Vic or all interstate GF can still happen.
At 22 teams:
Victoria Conference: 10 teams
Australian Conference: 12 teams (Brisbane 2 added)
Vic conference play each other once = 9 games
Oz conference play each other once = 11 games
Vic conference play Oz conference once = 12 games = 21 games
Oz conference play Vic conference once = 10 games = 21 games
Vic conference have two double ups = 23 games
Oz conference have two double ups = 23 games
Vic conference have a top 5 finals series, Oz conference have a top 6 finals series, the preliminary finalists of each series swap over to ensure that it's a possibility that an all Vic or all interstate GF can still happen.
At 23 teams:
Victoria Conference: 10 teams
Australian Conference: 13 teams
Vic conference play each other once = 9 games
Oz conference play each other once = 12 games
Vic conference play Oz conference once = 13 games = 22 games
Oz conference play Vic conference once = 10 games = 22 games
Vic conference have one double up = 23 games
Oz conference have one double up = 23 games
Vic conference have a top 5 finals series, Oz conference have a top 6 finals series, the preliminary finalists of each series swap over to ensure that it's a possibility that an all Vic or all interstate GF can still happen.
At 24 teams:
Victoria Conference: 10 teams
Australian Conference: 14 teams
Vic conference play each other once = 9 games
Oz conference play each other once = 13 games
Vic conference play Oz conference once = 14 games = 23 games
Oz conference play Vic conference once = 10 games = 23 games
No double ups
Vic conference have a top 5 finals series, Oz conference have a top 6 finals series, the preliminary finalists of each series swap over to ensure that it's a possibility that an all Vic or all interstate GF can still happen.
At 25 teams:
Victoria Conference: 10 teams
Australian Conference: 15 teams
Vic conference play each other once = 9 games
Oz conference play each other once = 14 games
Vic conference play Oz conference once excluding one team = 14 games = 23 games
Oz conference play Vic conference once excluding one team = 9 games = 23 games
No double ups
Vic conference have a top 5 finals series, Oz conference have a top 6 or top 8 finals series, the preliminary finalists of each series swap over to ensure that it's a possibility that an all Vic or all interstate GF can still happen.
At 26 teams:
Victoria Conference: 10 teams
Australian Conference: 16 teams
Vic conference play each other once = 9 games
Oz conference play each other once = 15 games
Vic conference play Oz conference once excluding one team = 15 games = 24 games
Oz conference play Vic conference once excluding one team = 9 games = 24 games
No double ups
Vic conference have a top 5 finals series, Oz conference have a top 8 finals series, the preliminary finalists of each series swap over to ensure that it's a possibility that an all Vic or all interstate GF can still happen.
At 27 teams:
Victoria Conference: 10 teams
Australian Conference: 17 teams
Vic conference play each other once = 9 games
Oz conference play each other once = 16 games
Vic conference play Oz conference once excluding two teams = 15 games = 24 games
Oz conference play Vic conference once excluding two teams = 8 games = 24 games
No double ups
Vic conference have a top 5 finals series, Oz conference have a top 8 finals series, the preliminary finalists of each series swap over to ensure that it's a possibility that an all Vic or all interstate GF can still happen.
At 28 teams:
Victoria Conference: 10 teams
Australian Conference: 18 teams
Vic conference play each other once = 9 games
Oz conference play each other once = 17 games
Vic conference play Oz conference once excluding three teams = 15 games = 24 games
Oz conference play Vic conference once excluding three teams = 7 games = 24 games
No double ups
Vic conference have a top 5 finals series, Oz conference have a top 8 finals series, the preliminary finalists of each series swap over to ensure that it's a possibility that an all Vic or all interstate GF can still happen.
Cunnington Cartel what do you think? I'm sure there's a glaring flaw in this somewhere, but the point is, there is a way, but at some point, if the AFL did keep expanding and expanding, then not everyone could play each other once a year, but at least the Vic's could and it wouldn't be a long wait for teams who don't play each other to play again.
Haha I replied to this but deleted them as I found the finals series to be exactly the biggest problem. But I agree that double ups should be preserved for WA teams etc.Good effort. I like how it facilitates an expanded number of clubs as time goes on, without needing to rejig the conferences during each expansion phase. During the early phases, the Vic double ups should be rotated each season; however, it would be good for the Aus double ups to be fixed so it maintains more derbies and slightly reduces the travel burden for non-Vic clubs (e.g. at 21 and 22 teams West Coast should always have double ups against Freo and WA3).
I’m not sure if the finals series is workable. With a final 5 system, the club that wins the second semi gets automatic qualification to the grand final. Therefore, there’d be two grand finalists after the second semi (one from each conference) and then two additional prelims to generate two more grand finalists (4 in total). Would there then be an extra week of finals between the prelim and GF? Then questions would be asked if the best teams are having too many weeks off during the finals.
During the later rounds of expansion, when there’s a top 5 and top 8 finals series running side-by-side, there ends up being a similar issue with three grand finalists after the prelim.
My thinking might be off here, but if I haven’t stuffed up, can you think of another solution to this?
Potentially, you could scrap the prelim cross overs, having an extra week of finals and holding conference GF’s the week prior to a ‘Super Bowl’ GF? But I really don’t like how that would guarantee Vic v Non-Vic opposition every year.
This link shows the various pathways previously-used finals systems.
AFL finals series - Wikipedia
en.m.wikipedia.org