Rumour Tales from the Henley Beach Cafe: CROWS 2021 RUMOURS

[ams4crows]

So you're telling me people are upset about losing B.Crouch and Atkins and gaining potentially Pick 2 and Menegola

When are people going to understand you can't play all of the kids at once? Look at Carlton FFS!

 

[jenny61_99]

AFC continue to bolster the strength of other clubs. Why don't Geelong F.R.O. and develop their own players
Pathetic by the Crows to not be able to get this deal one. Joke of a club

It's a done deal is it? FMD.

 

[Kane Johnson]

if we lose Crouch for Pick 2 AND Menegola it is a great result.

 

[Danger in Texas]

To ensure we get pick 2

Oh I think I get it now. So we'd get Menegola and pick 2, they'd get Brad?

That's actually a pretty damn good deal for us, although I'd still want to make sure Schoenberg/Jones get good midfield minutes

 

[cammo6556]

Oh I think I get it now. So we'd get Menegola and pick 2, they'd get Brad?

That's actually a pretty damn good deal for us, although I'd still want to make sure Schoenberg/Jones get good midfield minutes

Yep. That's the one

 

[Johnny Rutten]

if we lose Crouch for Pick 2 AND Menegola it is a great result.

What pick do we give up for Menegola in this scenario?

 

[FR0GGY]

Wow.

Let's just see it happen before we throw ourselves off bridges.

Where’s the fun in that?

 

[Kane Johnson]

tbh I'm not following how we get both... We only get pick 2 if Brad goes as a FA so... we trade Geelong an Audi Club membership for Menegola and its a done deal.

 

[StickerMan]

It's a done deal is it? FMD.

One of the better melts we've had in a while!!

 

[Betts are off]

I feel like we need a new thread. Where we get to post which new posters we believe were old posters.

To get it started.
Brett Cummings: Mick500
PrideofSA: EliteCrow?

 

[jenny61_99]

I feel like we need a new thread. Where we get to post which new posters we believe were old posters.

To get it started.
Brett Cummings: Mick500
PrideofSA: EliteCrow?

I had my differences with EliteCrow but I don't think he was ever as unhinged as that? Or maybe absence makes the heart grow fonder??

 

[cammo6556]

What pick do we give up for Menegola in this scenario?

second rounder

 

[Peter Doherty]

second rounder

This is where I have a problem.

We should be offering a 3rd. If Geelong think they can do better elsewhere, then go get that pick. They move him on, clear the space they need, we get pick 2.

 

[cammo6556]

This is where I have a problem.

We should be offering a 3rd. If Geelong think they can do better elsewhere, then go get that pick. They move him on clear, clear the space they need, we get pick 2.

Who knows? but either 20 or 31 are mooted for this.

 

[Mutineer]

I feel like we need a new thread. Where we get to post which new posters we believe were old posters.

To get it started.
Brett Cummings: Mick500
PrideofSA: EliteCrow?

No way.

 

[Peter Doherty]

I feel like we need a new thread. Where we get to post which new posters we believe were old posters.

To get it started.
Brett Cummings: Mick500
PrideofSA: EliteCrow?

Who is crow2crow?

 

[WeeBlake]

If we're looking at any of the Geelong players in the AA squad in a rebuild list management should be sacked

Has to be someone pulling Cammo's leg

Disagree. The deal Carno is suggesting is outrageously good for us (and hugely lopsided only because the Cats arent giving up pick 2 themselves). If it is keep Crouch vs replace with an equally good and only slightly older player in Menegola, Who seems a solid character, I can’t see The problem.

 

[crow2crow]

second rounder

if it’s pick 2 for brad and it’s 21 for menegola I will take back every bad word i have ever said about dangerfield
Win win for both teams

 

[cammo6556]

if it’s pick 2 for brad and it’s 21 for menegola I will take back every bad word i have ever said about dangerfield
Win win for both teams

the sticking point may well be convincing him to come.

 

[Mutineer]

Disagree. The deal Carno is suggesting is outrageously good for us (and hugely lopsided only because the Cats arent giving up pick 2 themselves). If it is keep Crouch vs replace with an equally good and only slightly older player in Menegola, Who seems a solid character, I can’t see The problem.

Equally good?, we're talking midfielders who's prime job is to win clearances....Menegola ain't no clearance machine and Brad Crouch is our best in that regard.

 

[Betts are off]

No way.

Yeah, that guys pretty extreme, but EC did also spend a decent chunk of his time way off the richter.

I was just getting a slight EC vibe

 

[Betts are off]

Who is crow2crow?

Good question, came in like a freight train. Could easily be a return poster

 

[crow2crow]

Good question, came in like a freight train. Could easily be a return poster

not a return poster. just have time on my hands at the moment will be gone again soon

 

[Betts are off]

not a return poster. just have time on my hands at the moment will be gone again soon

All good mate, Just so you know it wasn’t meant as an insult. More the merrier.

 

[Danger in Texas]

Menegola for Bulldogs 2nd is the max I'd give, considering his age

Brad and 30-ish for 2 and Menegola seems pretty much win-win, as long as it doesn't stunt the development of Schoenberg and Jones