Unofficial Preview Changes and Pre-match Discussion - Rd 13 vs Melbourne, 3.20pm Mon 13/06, MCG

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
If mihocek misses he just isn’t replaceable…

Assuming he plays, cox might take a mark or two down there… ditto a resting Cameron

So why not experiment and go smaller in the forward line?

Play McReery

Give Sidebottom a full game there

Maybe young Henry will thrive down at full forward

Going tall and kicking it in long inside 50 is less likely to work with Petty, Lever and Gawn floating down there anyhow
 

Log in to remove this ad.

We saw the next in line last week (Mcinnes) who showed he's not quite up to it yet. So it's easy to say let's drop WHE but it's not as easy to find a replacement for him. Baring in mind WHE was running in to some decent form before being fairly quiet the past 2 weeks. With Checkers looking like missing, Wilbur will become an important player for us this week up forward.

He is about as important as Motlop is for Port.

And Motlop is one of the only players I wouldn’t play ahead of WHE.

Which says a lot about Motlop.

I hope WHE kicks 5 this week and we smash the Dreamons. However, one swallow does not a summer make.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
If mihocek misses he just isn’t replaceable…

Assuming he plays, cox might take a mark or two down there… ditto a resting Cameron

So why not experiment and go smaller in the forward line?

Play McReery

Give Sidebottom a full game there

Maybe young Henry will thrive down at full forward

Going tall and kicking it in long inside 50 is less likely to work with Petty, Lever and Gawn floating down there anyhow
When the defence is set you have to go long to the hotspot and even if you're not going to mark many, you've got to bring some balls to ground.
 
He is about as important as Motlop is for Port.

And Motlop is one of the only players I wouldn’t play ahead of WHE.

Which says a lot about Motlop.

I hope WHE kicks 5 this week and we smash the Dreamons. However, one swallow does not a summer make.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

The last time WHE kicked 4 was in 2019

While his best is very good… his reputation proceeds him

I can handle him being on the list for another year or two and selected when his form is good

What I can’t handle is him… week in, week out… being one of the first 12-15 names selected

Thoroughly overrated on here by some
 
The last time WHE kicked 4 was in 2019

While his best is very good… his reputation proceeds him

I can handle him being on the list for another year or two and selected when his form is good

What I can’t handle is him… week in, week out… being one of the first 12-15 names selected

Thoroughly overrated on here by some
I don't think many, if any, would have him in the first 12-15 named. The reality is that we have no depth and struggle to get to 22 even with him in it. The vfl kids just aren't ready yet.
 
The last time WHE kicked 4 was in 2019

While his best is very good… his reputation proceeds him

I can handle him being on the list for another year or two and selected when his form is good

What I can’t handle is him… week in, week out… being one of the first 12-15 names selected

Thoroughly overrated on here by some

How do you know he’s in the first 12-15 named each week? I’d have thought he’s consistently in last 4-5 but never quite the last, so manages to survive the cut.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
The last time WHE kicked 4 was in 2019

While his best is very good… his reputation proceeds him

I can handle him being on the list for another year or two and selected when his form is good

What I can’t handle is him… week in, week out… being one of the first 12-15 names selected

Thoroughly overrated on here by some

Maybe it's under rated by some on here? That he keeps getting selected suggests this is more likely.
 
The last time WHE kicked 4 was in 2019

While his best is very good… his reputation proceeds him

I can handle him being on the list for another year or two and selected when his form is good

What I can’t handle is him… week in, week out… being one of the first 12-15 names selected

Thoroughly overrated on here by some

You know that’s not how it’s spelt?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
If Mihocek is injured, pay the fine and play Johnson.

Dreaming, I know.
We can make any changes we want before 5om tonight without incurring a fine
More importantly any word on whether the sore Petty will get up for Dees?
If him May and Smith all miss, the out of form Jake Lever could be exposed on Monday
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

We can make any changes we want before 5om tonight without incurring a fine
More importantly any word on whether the sore Petty will get up for Dees?
If him May and Smith all miss, the out of form Jake Lever could be exposed on Monday
We know what out of form means when you play Coll. Jake stringer becomes Dustin Martin 😂
 
Just the 1 change.

IN: Jamie Elliott
OUT: Reef McInnes (shoulder), Tyler Brown (R12 medical substitute)

COLLINGWOOD V MELBOURNE
BBrayden MaynardDarcy MooreNathan Murphy
HBScott PendleburyJeremy HoweIsaac Quaynor
CWill Hoskin-ElliottPatrick LipinskiJohn Noble
HFJack CrispBrody MihocekJordan De Goey
FJack GinnivanJamie ElliottSteele Sidebottom
RDarcy CameronTaylor AdamsJosh Daicos
INTOliver HenryBeau McCreeryNick Daicos
Mason Cox
EMERGTrey RuscoeTyler BrownFinlay Macrae
Isaac Chugg

 
Just the 1 change.

IN: Jamie Elliott
OUT: Reef McInnes (shoulder), Tyler Brown (R12 medical substitute)

COLLINGWOOD V MELBOURNE
BBrayden MaynardDarcy MooreNathan Murphy
HBScott PendleburyJeremy HoweIsaac Quaynor
CWill Hoskin-ElliottPatrick LipinskiJohn Noble
HFJack CrispBrody MihocekJordan De Goey
FJack GinnivanJamie ElliottSteele Sidebottom
RDarcy CameronTaylor AdamsJosh Daicos
INTOliver HenryBeau McCreeryNick Daicos
Mason Cox
EMERGTrey RuscoeTyler BrownFinlay Macrae
Isaac Chugg

Pretty much as expected.
 
Just the 1 change.

IN: Jamie Elliott
OUT: Reef McInnes (shoulder), Tyler Brown (R12 medical substitute)

COLLINGWOOD V MELBOURNE
BBrayden MaynardDarcy MooreNathan Murphy
HBScott PendleburyJeremy HoweIsaac Quaynor
CWill Hoskin-ElliottPatrick LipinskiJohn Noble
HFJack CrispBrody MihocekJordan De Goey
FJack GinnivanJamie ElliottSteele Sidebottom
RDarcy CameronTaylor AdamsJosh Daicos
INTOliver HenryBeau McCreeryNick Daicos
Mason Cox
EMERGTrey RuscoeTyler BrownFinlay Macrae
Isaac Chugg


I reckon that’s about as strong as we get for the rest of the year. Only Grundy now to come back that’s best 22.

Dean, Johnson, Carmichael and Madgen really the others that probably add to that emergency list.

You’d think it’s now all about development for the others.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top