Opinion 2022 Player X vs Y vs Z

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Short or Crisp to Docherty? Leaning towards Short with uncertainty over his role. Something seriously wrong with Crisp though. Can't/won't get/go near it.

have the same choice but was leaning towards keeping Short. Pies have a tough last 3.

the correct answer is to trade out whichever one TheRednWhite is keeping
 
Short or Crisp to Docherty? Leaning towards Short with uncertainty over his role. Something seriously wrong with Crisp though. Can't/won't get/go near it.

I seen something weeks ago Crisp had or still got personal issues.
Was avg 108 .
Now it's under 80 .been like that for a while now.


Doc 3 round avg of 80 odd .
5 rd avg of 92 .

Can you get someone else e.g. H.Young etc ..
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I seen something weeks ago Crisp had or still got personal issues.
Was avg 108 .
Now it's under 80 .been like that for a while now.


Doc 3 round avg of 80 odd .
5 rd avg of 92 .

Can you get someone else e.g. H.Young etc ..
Doch more appealing with Newman cooked.
 
Mills vs Steele vs Walsh
Those are my 3 options for Cripps also.
Mills plays Pies and Saints
Steele plays Bris and Swans
Walsh plays Dees and Pies
That rules out Walsh for me leaving Steele and Mills.
Steele is a C/VC option, Mills is a VC option.
Steele I reckon mate.
 
Who to get rid of out of Short, Rich or Lloyd?

At this stage with the final two trades it's Cripps and one of these defenders for Docherty and Wines.

Or just go Cripps to Dawson and hold the final trade?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Who to get rid of out of Short, Rich or Lloyd?

At this stage with the final two trades it's Cripps and one of these defenders for Docherty and Wines.

Or just go Cripps to Dawson and hold the final trade?
Cripps to Dawson and hold.

Trac or Mills.
I’m sold on Trac.
Talk me out of it!
 
Cripps to Dawson and hold.

Trac or Mills.
I’m sold on Trac.
Talk me out of it!
Petracca. He's in great form, fun to own, and I always prefer to have him in my team if I can, as he's so dangerous (and frustrating as hell). If he can hit the side of a barn he goes 120 in his sleep. Mills feels a bit meh in comparison at the moment.
 
And comes before Ang alphabetically, so message received.
Nah, the first one born.:tearsofjoy:



Nah, the first one to win a Brownlow! (Hopefully!)

Nah F$&k it!

Why Dont We Have Both GIF


To be honest, I think they’re both good picks for the price. Angus has thrived playing mids lately, but I’d lean towards Andy.
He should destroy the WC mids in the derby and should dominate against GWS as well.
 
Last edited:
Nah, the first one born.:tearsofjoy:



Nah, the first one to win a Brownlow! (Hopefully!)

Nah F$&k it!

Why Dont We Have Both GIF


To be honest, I think they’re both good picks for the price. Angus has thrived playing mids lately, but I’d lean towards Andy.
He should destroy the WC mids in the derby and should dominate against GWS as well.
Andy likely to get tagged by Ash vs GWS.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top