Prediction Your top 5 phantom draft.

[Cleric]

With the draft been so even, what's your prediction for the top 5, with the draft picks as they stand today.
Pick 1 - Richmond
Pick 2 - North Melbourne
Pick 3 - Carlton
Pick 4 - Adelaide
Pick 5 - Melbourne

This is mine
Pick 1 Rich - Finn O’Sullivan
Pick 2 North - Sam Lalor
Pick 3 Carlton - Sid Draper
Pick 4 Adel - Harvey Langford
Pick 5 Melb - Jagga Smith

What say ye?

 

[Wild Bill]

With the draft been so even, what's your prediction for the top 5, with the draft picks as they stand today.
Pick 1 - Richmond
Pick 2 - North Melbourne
Pick 3 - Carlton
Pick 4 - Adelaide
Pick 5 - Melbourne

This is mine
Pick 1 Rich - Finn O’Sullivan
Pick 2 North - Sam Lalor
Pick 3 Carlton - Sid Draper
Pick 4 Adel - Harvey Langford
Pick 5 Melb - Jagga Smith

What say ye?

Pick 1 - Richmond - Lalor
Pick 2 - North Melbourne - FOS
Pick 3 - Carlton - Smith
Pick 4 - Adelaide - Draper
Pick 5 - Melbourne - Langford

 

[Mofra]

(Ashcroft bid)
1. Smith
2. FOS
3. Lalor
4. Draper
5. Langford

 

[danster168]

(Ashcroft)
1. FOS
2. Lalor
3. Draper
4. Langford
5. Armstrong. *completely disagree with the choice but I think the dees will reach.

 

[Hodgy]

1. Rich - Lalor
2. NM - Tauru
3. Car - FOS
4. Ade - Smith
5. Mel - Armstrong

 

[bradfisher14]

Pick 1 Rich - Lalor
Pick 2 North - O'Sullivan
Pick 3 Carlton - Smith
~ Ashcroft bid ~
Pick 4 Adel - Draper
Pick 5 Melb - Langford

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

From the noise FOS is making I really think he knows he is going pick 3. With that in mind

Pick 1 - Jagga
--- Ashcroft Bid ----
Pick 2 - Lalor
Pick 3 - FOS
Pick 4 - Draper
Pick 5 - Langford

 

[bradfisher14]

From the noise FOS is making I really think he knows he is going pick 3. With that in mind

What noise are you referring to?

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

What noise are you referring to?

When he was going on about being happy to go to the Eagles and the like before we traded the pick away

 

[sufficientintent]

Pick 1 - Richmond - Lalor
Pick 2 - North Melbourne - Tauru
— Ashcroft bid —
Pick 3 - Carlton - FOS
Pick 4 - Adelaide - Draper
Pick 5 - Melbourne - Reid

 

[yeahfells]

Please make these phantoms Top 10. Intrigued to see who you think st kilda ends up with. Thx

 

[Futbolista]

Please make these phantoms Top 10. Intrigued to see who you think st kilda ends up with. Thx

I wish they were top 40 lists....otherwise WA players wont get a look in.

 

[Kildonan]

I just did a first round showing what I think are "expected" picks

1 Richmond Finn O'Sullivan
2 North Melbourne Levi Ashcroft Brisbane F/S matched
3 North Melbourne Richmond Trade pick for Pick #6 and future 2nd
3 Richmond Harvey Langford
4 Carlton Sam Lalor
5 Adelaide Jagga Smith

6 Melbourne Murphy Reid
7 North Melbourne Alix Tauru
8 St Kilda Sid Draper
9 St Kilda Josh Smillie
10 Melbourne Harry Armstrong
11 Richmond Toby Travaglia
12 Richmond Leo Lombard Gold Coast Academy matched
13 Richmond Bo Allan
14 West Coast Isaac Kako Essendon Academy matched
15 West Coast Taj Hotton
16 Port Adelaide Luke Trainor
17 Fremantle Joe Berry
18 GWS Xavier Lindsay
19 GWS Jack Whitlock
20 Western Bulldogs Jobe Shanahan
21 Richmond Sam Marshall Brisbane Academy matched
22 Richmond Cooper Hynes
23 Sydney Matt Whitlock
24 Richmond Jesse Dattoli
25 GWS Harry Oliver
26 Sydney Jonty Faull
27 Richmond Alex Dodson

 

[Futbolista]

Allan mate....please everybody I need to finally say it's Bo Allan

 

[4tune8]

I just did a first round showing what I think are "expected" picks

1 Richmond Finn O'Sullivan
2 North Melbourne Levi Ashcroft Brisbane F/S matched
3 North Melbourne Richmond Trade pick for Pick #6 and future 2nd
3 Richmond Harvey Langford
4 Carlton Sam Lalor
5 Adelaide Jagga Smith

6 Melbourne Murphy Reid
7 North Melbourne Alix Tauru
8 St Kilda Sid Draper
9 St Kilda Josh Smillie
10 Melbourne Harry Armstrong
11 Richmond Toby Travaglia
12 Richmond Leo Lombard Gold Coast Academy matched
13 Richmond Bo Allen
14 West Coast Isaac Kako Essendon Academy matched
15 West Coast Taj Hotton
16 Port Adelaide Luke Trainor
17 Fremantle Joe Berry
18 GWS Xavier Lindsay
19 GWS Jack Whitlock
20 Western Bulldogs Jobe Shanahan
21 Richmond Sam Marshall Brisbane Academy matched
22 Richmond Cooper Hynes
23 Sydney Matt Whitlock
24 Richmond Jesse Dattoli
25 GWS Harry Oliver
26 Sydney Jonty Faull
27 Richmond Alex Dodson

Nice effort, thanks for posting.

Just from a Tigers perspective, I like the trade of 6 & F2 for pick 2, but I'm sure the North supporters wont If we did trade up then I think it would have to be FOS and Lalor.

When Yze took over he specified that he wanted elite users of the ball, FOS fits that bill, he and Lalor would marry up nicely. If I'm looking for the best users by foot then I'd be taking Lindsay over Travaglia at 11, Berry over Allan at 13 and Oliver over Hynes at 22. I'd also take Gerreyn over Dattoli at 24 and then slide 27 back for a later pick and an F1

 

[Haggas]

1	Richmond	Finn O'Sullivan
2	Brisbane (F/S)	Levi Ashcroft
3	North Melbourne	Harvey Langford
4	Carlton (WC)	Sam Lalor
5	Adelaide	Sid Draper
6	Melbourne	Jagga Smith
7	Richmond (GC)	Josh Smillie
8	St.Kilda	Murphy Reid
9	St.Kilda (Compensation)	Alixzander Tauru
10	Melbourne (Ess)	Harry Armstrong
11	Richmond (Frem)	Tobie Travaglia
12	Richmond (Coll)	Luke Trainor
13	Gold Coast (Academy)	Leonardo Lombard
14	Essendon (NGA)	Isaac Kako
15	West Coast (Carl)	Bo Allan
16	Port Adelaide (WB)	Xavier Lindsay
17	Fremantle (Haw)	Joe Berry
18	GWS Giants	Taj Hotton
19	GWS Giants (Compensation)	Jobe Shanahan
20	W.Bulldogs (Geel)	Jack Whitlock
21	Richmond (PA)	Cooper Hynes
22	Brisbane (Academy)	Samuel Marshall
23	Sydney	Matt Whitlock
24	Richmond (Bris)	Jonty Faull
25	GWS Giants (Compensation)	Jesse Dattoli
26	Sydney (NM Priority)	Harrison Oliver
27	Richmond (NM Priority)	Tom Gross

 

[JuddgementDay]

Pick 1 Rich - Sam Lalor
Pick 2 North - Finn O’Sullivan
Pick 3 Carlton - Jagga Smith
Pick 4 Adel - Sid Draper
Pick 5 Melb - Harvey Langford

 

[The Nostradamus]

Pick 1 - Richmond - Lalor
Pick 2 - North Melbourne - FOS
Pick 3 - Carlton - Smith
Pick 4 - Adelaide - Draper
Pick 5 - Melbourne - Langford

this with ashcroft bid at 1

 

[LB2Snake]

Pick 1 Rich - Sam Lalor
Pick 2 North - Finn O’Sullivan
Pick 3 Carlton - Jagga Smith
Pick 4 Adel - Sid Draper
Pick 5 Melb - Harvey Langford

Actually think Blues could pick up a F2 if Lalor and FOS gone at 1 and 2……Crows will be shitting themselves at that point. Could put serious pressure on them.

 

[Danger in Texas]

Actually think Blues could pick up a F2 if Lalor and FOS gone at 1 and 2……Crows will be shitting themselves at that point. Could put serious pressure on them.

I think we’d just take Smith in that scenario

Don’t think we’re absolutely desperate for Draper

 

[LB2Snake]

I think we’d just take Smith in that scenario

Don’t think we’re absolutely desperate for Draper

Maybe. Maybe not. I like this stuff though.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Maybe. Maybe not. I like this stuff though.

I like Smith a lot.

Would be stoked with either Smith or Draper.

There will be a very good midfielder available with our pick... just not sure who.

 

[LB2Snake]

I like Smith a lot.

Would be stoked with either Smith or Draper.

There will be a very good midfielder available with our pick... just not sure who.

Yeah Jagga gunna def be a star. Has been at both basketball and football since under 12’s. Has always had amazing class.
Draper looks pretty bloody special too though and no go home factor for you. Unfortunately that rubbish has become more relevant these days, particularly after COVID.

 

[Revan11]

1	Richmond	Finn O'Sullivan
2	Brisbane (F/S)	Levi Ashcroft
3	North Melbourne	Harvey Langford
4	Carlton (WC)	Sam Lalor
5	Adelaide	Sid Draper
6	Melbourne	Jagga Smith
7	Richmond (GC)	Josh Smillie
8	St.Kilda	Murphy Reid
9	St.Kilda (Compensation)	Alixzander Tauru
10	Melbourne (Ess)	Harry Armstrong
11	Richmond (Frem)	Tobie Travaglia
12	Richmond (Coll)	Luke Trainor
13	Gold Coast (Academy)	Leonardo Lombard
14	Essendon (NGA)	Isaac Kako
15	West Coast (Carl)	Bo Allan
16	Port Adelaide (WB)	Xavier Lindsay
17	Fremantle (Haw)	Joe Berry
18	GWS Giants	Taj Hotton
19	GWS Giants (Compensation)	Jobe Shanahan
20	W.Bulldogs (Geel)	Jack Whitlock
21	Richmond (PA)	Cooper Hynes
22	Brisbane (Academy)	Samuel Marshall
23	Sydney	Matt Whitlock
24	Richmond (Bris)	Jonty Faull
25	GWS Giants (Compensation)	Jesse Dattoli
26	Sydney (NM Priority)	Harrison Oliver
27	Richmond (NM Priority)	Tom Gross

I'll spew if we take Lindsay.

 

[Haggas]

I'll spew if we take Lindsay.

Yeah its just based of rankings. I hope we take Hynes, fits a need and could be a better replacement for Wines