Banter Who will be better in 2025, Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[WalshistheGOAT]

Nah. He will still be Getting huge $ no matter what. Players get to where they want to go these days. You'll get two good first rounders for him. I'd even throw in Schultz.

Would cost 5 then

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Yes I have no issues with racism. Great call bud

Why don't you have issues with racism? We have one Aboriginal poster on this thread and a bunch of your guys were piling in on him and for instance calling him "a virtue signaller" for daring to be open about his race.
You lot are massive hypocrites and strangely selective about what you find triggering and offensive.

 

[Fadge]

No way Collingwood pitch for De Koning.

We've learnt the hard way that you don't pay big $$ for ruckman.

Given Carlton are 30 years behind us, let them pay him $1 million a year a discover their mistake 3cyears later..

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Yep, I used to throw rocks at all the ugly kids and Carlton supporters at school

Same thing aren't they?

 

[carlton_99]

Why don't you have issues with racism? We have one Aboriginal poster on this thread and a bunch of your guys were piling in on him and for instance calling him "a virtue signaller" for daring to be open about his race.
You lot are massive hypocrites and strangely selective about what you find triggering and offensive.

I didn't see anyone criticising or abusing the poster for their race - stop making stuff up. Race has never been an issue on this thread - don't make it one

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

No way Collingwood pitch for De Koning.

We've learnt the hard way that you don't pay big $$ for ruckman.

Given Carlton are 30 years behind us, let them pay him $1 million a year a discover their mistake 3cyears later..

30 years? Didn't you offer up Grundy a million a year only 4-5 years ago?

You're also using 105% of ur cap this year and next so there wouldn't be any money to throw at him anyway Fudgey

 

[Fadge]

I didn't see anyone criticising or abusing the poster for their race - stop making stuff up. Race has never been an issue on this thread - don't make it one

But 'bullying' has?

I'm still waiting for the evidence when it since it was requested.

 

[carlton_99]

But 'bullying' has?

I'm still waiting for the evidence when it since it was requested.

Never mentioned bullying - not sure what you're on about

 

[Fadge]

30 years? Didn't you offer up Grundy a million a year only 4-5 years ago?

You're also using 105% of ur cap this year and next so there wouldn't be any money to throw at him anyway Fudgey

105% of our Cap this year?

Is that right, or just yet another mistruth?

 

[Scritchyscroony]

No way Collingwood pitch for De Koning.

We've learnt the hard way that you don't pay big $$ for ruckman.

Given Carlton are 30 years behind us, let them pay him $1 million a year a discover their mistake 3cyears later..

Yeah the Grundy contract should forever be a warning to all clubs about making a ruckman one of your highest paid players.
But I'd rather TDK on $850k a year that Perryman if I'm being honest. I hope we pitch for him just to make Carlton up their offer and blow their cap.

 

[Fadge]

Never mentioned bullying - not sure what you're on about

Keep up with the thread.

 

[beerbandit]

No way Collingwood pitch for De Koning.

We've learnt the hard way that you don't pay big $$ for ruckman.

Given Carlton are 30 years behind us, let them pay him $1 million a year a discover their mistake 3cyears later..

Why would we pay TDK big coin to play VFL?

Darcy Cameron and Mason Cox are clearly better

 

[Scritchyscroony]

I didn't see anyone criticising or abusing the poster for their race - stop making stuff up. Race has never been an issue on this thread - don't make it one

It was an issue. I could see it was at the time and it was taken that way by the poster who was being attacked. If you don't understand this....

 

[carlton_99]

Keep up with the thread.

Yep I'm missing out on a lot of quality posts

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

105% of our Cap this year?

Is that right, or just yet another mistruth?

Straight from one of ur list team Fudgington

 

[Fadge]

Yep I'm missing out on a lot of quality posts

No.

You're just picking and choosing what to call out.

Some would regard that as 'hypocritical'.

 

[Fadge]

Straight from one of ur list team Fudgington

How does a club pay 105% of their cap in a given year?

 

[carlton_99]

No.

You're just picking and choosing what to call out.

Some would regard that as 'hypocritical'.

I saw one poster call another poster autistic and you reacted to it with a love heart. I'm not the hypocrite here.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

But 'bullying' has?

I'm still waiting for the evidence when it since it was requested.

It's called salary cap banking. Many clubs do it

 

[Scritchyscroony]

30 years? Didn't you offer up Grundy a million a year only 4-5 years ago?

You're also using 105% of ur cap this year and next so there wouldn't be any money to throw at him anyway Fudgey

Likely retirees next year...
Pendlebury, Side bottom, Howe, Cox, Elliot, Hoskin Elliot, Mihoceck.
You sure we won't have the cap space?

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Likely retirees next year...
Pendlebury, Side bottom, Howe, Cox, Elliot, Hoskin Elliot, Mihoceck.
You sure we won't have the cap space?

Same could be said about us, but according to you lot we're in huge cap trouble despite booting 10 players this off season and having another 16 players out of contract next season?

 

[Scritchyscroony]

How does a club pay 105% of their cap in a given year?

If we are paying 105% it's because we are front loading contracts not because we are stretched.

 

[Fadge]

Likely retirees next year...
Pendlebury, Side bottom, Howe, Cox, Elliot, Hoskin Elliot, Mihoceck.
You sure we won't have the cap space?

Nah, surely they've all got another.3 or 4 years (and a couple of premierships) in them...

 

[beerbandit]

It’s been a fun thread to be apart of guys, let’s just keep it that way.

Above the belt and funny.

Those whom are getting worked up, don’t be afraid to press the reset button and relax.

There’s a reason it’s the greatest rivalry in Australian sport, but let’s keep it clean and fun.

 

[Fadge]

Same could be said about us, but according to you lot we're in huge cap trouble despite booting 10 players this off season and having another 16 players out of contract next season?

So a mid table team is about to become a lower table team (again)?