Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood?

[Arr0w]

In over 6 decades Pies have 3 flags, but in the same time they have more GF losses than Carlton's 8 flags.

Now, back in Mexico

 

[Aphrodite]

In over 6 decades Pies have 3 flags, but in the same time they have more GF losses than Carlton's 8 flags.

Now, back in Mexico

 

[Fadge]

View attachment 2010869

Is that a picture of the Carlton Football Club in the second quarter of the 2023 Preliminary Final?

Or the Carlton Football Club in the last four rounds of 2022?

Or the Carlton Football Club of the 21st century?

 

[Thrawn]

Is that a picture of the Carlton Football Club in the second quarter of the 2023 Preliminary Final?

Or the Carlton Football Club in the last four rounds of 2022?

Or the Carlton Football Club of the 21st century?

Chocolate or salted caramel? Asking for a friend.

 

[The Fantom]

Collingwood have LOST one out of every three Grand Finals they have contested in the history of the game.

EFA

 

[Worm4]

Collingwood have played in one out of every three Grand Finals contested in the history of the game.

Meanwhile, Carlton supporters got their jollies because they finally saw their team qualify for a Preliminary Final in 2023.

Although they got their pants pulled down in that Preliminary Final, with Collingwood winning the premiership in that very year.

Whilst on the history lesson , can you please advise how many of those Grand Finals were against Carlton, and for the cherry on top , how many of those did Collingwood win against Carlton ?
Only correct answers will be appreciated

 

[RPCB]

Carlton are yet to even contend for a premiership, let alone win one, in a year that starts with a '2'.

Post this statement any time anyone needs reminding how pathetic Carlton are as a sporting organisation.

Collingwood have played in one out of every three Grand Finals contested in the history of the game.

Meanwhile, Carlton supporters got their jollies because they finally saw their team qualify for a Preliminary Final in 2023.

Although they got their pants pulled down in that Preliminary Final, with Collingwood winning the premiership in that very year.

Those two statements kind of contradict each other.

In over 6 decades Pies have 3 flags, but in the same time they have more GF losses than Carlton's 8 flags.

Now, back in Mexico

But we did get a nice reminder that outside of those 3 flags, Collingwood have lost one in every 3 Grand Finals on average over the last 6 decades. Thanks to the Collingwood supporter for the reminder.

 

[Fadge]

Whilst on the history lesson , can you please advise how many of those Grand Finals were against Carlton, and for the cherry on top , how many of those did Collingwood win against Carlton ?
Only correct answers will be appreciated

Well we've played in 6 since the turn of the century. Meanwhile Carlton have been accumulating wooden spoons and number one draft picks.

Long live Carlton's ineptitude and inability to appear in Grand Finals.

Just think, if Carlton don't play in a Grand Final for another 100 years, Carlton supporters can still celebrate the 'dominance in Grand Finals over Collingwood since 1910' thing.

Hallelujah!

 

[Fadge]

EFA

Maths not a strength?

 

[Fadge]

Those two statements kind of contradict each other.

Ah, no they don't...

 

[Fadge]

But we did get a nice reminder that outside of those 3 flags, Collingwood have lost one in every 3 Grand Finals on average over the last 6 decades. Thanks to the Collingwood supporter for the reminder.

Huh?

 

[Worm4]

Well we've played in 6 since the turn of the century. Meanwhile Carlton have been accumulating wooden spoons and number one draft picks.

Long live Carlton's ineptitude and inability to appear in Grand Finals.

Just think, if Carlton don't play in a Grand Final for another 100 years, Carlton supporters can still celebrate the 'dominance in Grand Finals over Collingwood since 1910' thing.

Hallelujah!

Nice deflection, again.
How's the hangover treating you. It's not nice having injuries and watching your side get beaten because you team has been decimated is it. You called us out for using it as an excuse , but now the shoe is on the other foot and you can't say anything for fear of getting shot down. Oh well. Good luck against Melbourne although you probably don't need it as they crapped the bed last week as well. Pretty much a non event match 9 v 10 and not one of them in contention for anything apart from early draft picks. Oh wait, Collingwood don't have a first round draft pick. Its getting worse and worse. Hope nothing happens to your golden boy otherwise the club will be royally screwed. You'll have to rely on premiership players like Cox and Lipinski to drag you through bad times. As the saying goes, a rolling stone gathers no moss . The collingwood stone has lost its momentum and has almost completely stopped. What a fall from grace it will be. Make sure you are around when it happens and not go missing like you did for the 2-3 weeks prior to the Carlton game.

 

[Fadge]

Nice deflection, again.
How's the hangover treating you. It's not nice having injuries and watching your side get beaten because you team has been decimated is it. You called us out for using it as an excuse , but now the shoe is on the other foot and you can't say anything for fear of getting shot down. Oh well. Good luck against Melbourne although you probably don't need it as they crapped the bed last week as well. Pretty much a non event match 9 v 10 and not one of them in contention for anything apart from early draft picks. Oh wait, Collingwood don't have a first round draft pick. Its getting worse and worse. Hope nothing happens to your golden boy otherwise the club will be royally screwed. You'll have to rely on premiership players like Cox and Lipinski to drag you through bad times. As the saying goes, a rolling stone gathers no moss . The collingwood stone has lost its momentum and has almost completely stopped. What a fall from grace it will be. Make sure you are around when it happens and not go missing like you did for the 2-3 weeks prior to the Carlton game.

Big talk from a supporter of a club one full game ahead of Collingwood, with the best team your club has assembled in over two decades.

Guess you've got to make hay whilst the sun shines, albeit before either team has played a game in June.

 

[Fadge]

My favourite part of this whole back and forth is learning how gutless Collingwood supporters are for not using injuries as an excuse for being a full game out of third spot on the ladder.

 

[Fadge]

My second favourite part of this whole back and forth is learning how 'royally screwed' Collingwood would be if we didn't have Nick Daicos, despite being told by all and sundry over the last 18 months that he's a squib who doesn't impact games...

 

[Worm4]

My favourite part of this whole back and forth is learning how gutless Collingwood supporters are for not using injuries as an excuse for being a full game out of third spot on the ladder.

Just like Carlton a couple of weeks ago hey ?

 

[Worm4]

My second favourite part of this whole back and forth is learning how 'royally screwed' Collingwood would be if we didn't have Nick Daicos, despite being told by all and sundry over the last 18 months that he's a squib who doesn't impact games...

You said it yourself - pies were 17th when he got there, now they are finals bound. Which is it ?

 

[Fadge]

Just like Carlton a couple of weeks ago hey ?

Nah, I'm pretty sure Carlton supporters were using injuries as an excuse a couple of weeks ago, in the same way you have been for the past five years.

 

[Fadge]

You said it yourself - pies were 17th when he got there, now they are finals bound. Which is it ?

Oh boy...

 

[Worm4]

Oh boy...

Boy oh boy , wow wee

 

[CCurnow3votes]

Definitely plenty on the line

But the big event this weekend is the extremely rare top 5 clash between Carlton and Essendon

Should have saved the 32 cups display for this one

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

What we need is a showpiece game featuring Carlton, Essendon & Collingwood.

All 3 on the field at the same time .

Extra set of goals added, field split into thirds.

Get at it!

 

[CCurnow3votes]

Collingwood have played in one out of every three Grand Finals contested in the history of the game.

Meanwhile, Carlton supporters got their jollies because they finally saw their team qualify for a Preliminary Final in 2023.

Although they got their pants pulled down in that Preliminary Final, with Collingwood winning the premiership in that very year.

He’s fludgellating again!

 

[Robertio]

It's a pretty good thing to have.

REIGNING PREMIERS.

Means nothing right now but it's all Pie supporters have.

 

[Robertio]

Carlton are yet to even contend for a premiership, let alone win one, in a year that starts with a '2'.

Post this statement any time anyone needs reminding how pathetic Carlton are as a sporting organisation.

We are better right now though, you're taking this thread like a six year old.

 

[Robertio]

Nah, I'm pretty sure Carlton supporters were using injuries as an excuse a couple of weeks ago, in the same way you have been for the past five years.

Funny how we got a few players back then Collingwood lost a few and now we are higher on the ladder.