Player Watch Welcome to Collingwood Tim Membrey

Remove this Banner Ad

Interesting to see how he fits in, my guess is he’ll offer a lot to our structure.


Third tall, will kick 50+. Very astute pick up. Can’t believe the aints let him go.

Very excited about this guy…. Cost us nothing, will thrive with our style of play.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Will he be a week in week out best 23 player or cover for Checkers & McStay? Tough to fit everyone in. To do so may mean shifting some players around, like putting Bobby up to the wing, shifting WHE or Crisp to half back alongside Houston which could free up a forward of the ball position for Membrey. I would like to see him as a 3rd banana, get under the guard of a weak defender and have a 50+ goal season, this could work, he has the smarts.
 
The saying “you’ve gotta get up early in the morning to get one past me” doesn’t even apply to Dave.

The bloke can have a sleep in and still get the W.
Clearly DFA doesn’t carry the same level of excitement as Trade/Draft 😉
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Will he be a week in week out best 23 player or cover for Checkers & McStay? Tough to fit everyone in. To do so may mean shifting some players around, like putting Bobby up to the wing, shifting WHE or Crisp to half back alongside Houston which could free up a forward of the ball position for Membrey. I would like to see him as a 3rd banana, get under the guard of a weak defender and have a 50+ goal season, this could work, he has the smarts.
We're unlikely to have everyone fit that often to find out. But considering we looked at Stringer first - I think it's best 22. Membrey into Elliott's role and Elliott, Schultz, Hill and McCreery rotating through Lippa's role as well as the small forward roles
 
I'm not sure I would survive that. That's way too much good news for manic in one day. I'm going to try and get Cumberland to werribee next year so he can win the J.J liston trophy and then come to the Pies.
I'm hearing Owies is already unsettled at WC...
 
To those saying 50+ goals, let’s not get ahead of ourselves here ok? Coming to the pies isn’t going to make him a 10-20 goal per year better forward than he has been previously.

30+ goals while easing the pressure on McStay and Checkers would be a sensational result, we don’t have to set unachievable expectations and then get disappointed that the 30 year old we recruited for free hasn’t become one of the premier forwards of the comp…
 
To those saying 50+ goals, let’s not get ahead of ourselves here ok? Coming to the pies isn’t going to make him a 10-20 goal per year better forward than he has been previously.

30+ goals while easing the pressure on McStay and Checkers would be a sensational result, we don’t have to set unachievable expectations and then get disappointed that the 30 year old we recruited for free hasn’t become one of the premier forwards of the comp…
Were far better off with 3-4 guys all kicking around 30-40 goals than the Carlton model of winning the Coleman every year and **** all else
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Player Watch Welcome to Collingwood Tim Membrey

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top