Top 5 Favourite Pies Players ever? (Not the best, your favourite).

Remove this Banner Ad

Heath Shaw
Darren Millane
Tony Shaw
Dane Swan
James Clement
 
Leon Davis
Alan Didak
Anthony Rocca
John Greening
Des Tuddenham
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Peter Moore
Bill Picken
Peter Daicos
Scott Pendlebury
Nathan Buckley

On SM-N975F using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Mrs Macs excluded;)

A lot to name but here it goes. I won't go too many.

Scott Russell
Tony Francis
Sav Rocca
Peter Daicos
Anthony Rocca
Chris Tarrant
Brad Rowe
Nick Daicos
Josh Daicos
Jack Ginnivan
Pendy
De Goey ( ****ing love him how good was his Grand Final goals )
Bobby Hill ( I ****ing love you mate. Literally won me a packet on the punt Grand Final Day. Thank you )
Ron McKeown


edited - Forgot about Jamie Elliot at the time. Too many to name!
 
Last edited:
Way too hard. No order.

Bobby Hill
Nick Daicos
Jordan De Goey
Darcy Moore
Pendles

Peter Daicos
Sav Rocca
Jamie Elliot
Anthony Rocca
Chris Tarrant


There's 10.
 
James Clement
Peter Daicos
Sav Rocca
Nathan Buckley
Jordon De goey
 
Mick McGuane
Peter Daicos
Paul Licuria
Rupert Betheras
Tony Francis


from my Delorean
 
I'll give it a stab

Loved Brad Rowe
Doug barwick
Nathan Buckley
Saverio Rocca
Paul williams
 
Len Thompson
Rene Kink
Darren Milllane
Scott Pendlebury
Nick Daicos
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

cliffdrabble said:
1. John Greening- was our best player ever in my lifetime IMO, and was the best player in the league in 1972. Consecutive games in 1972- 46 disposals and 6 goals against the Cats and followed by 45 disposals and 4 goals against the Swans, all whilst playing as a midfielder. Was playing the 'modern game' before anyone else.

2 Peter Daicos- made kicking goals an art form.

3. Darren Millane - was the heart and soul of 1990.

4. Scott Pendelbury- for playing at such a high level consistently for so long with such grace and beauty.

5. Cannot split Nathan Buckley, Anthony and Sav Rocca, Gavin Brown, Steele Sidebottom, Leon Davis, Jordan De Goey, Dane Swan Paul Williams and Trav Cloke.
Click to expand...
Add in Greenings 50 disposals and 16 marks in a game the year before as a 20 yo. Worth noting he played 107 of 108 games from when 1st selected as a 17 yo in 1968. We didn't get near seeing his best but the years he had stack up against anyones
 
Gone Critical said:
Add in Greenings 50 disposals and 16 marks in a game the year before as a 20 yo. Worth noting he played 107 of 108 games from when 1st selected as a 17 yo in 1968. We didn't get near seeing his best but the years he had stack up against anyones
Click to expand...
John Greening and Phil Carmen are two of the best I’ve seen. If things had been different we may have had them playing along side each other in the mid to late seventies or beyond. Might have got a few of the missed Hafey premierships and been on 20 or more now.
 
Rene Kink
Wayne Richardson
Peter Daicos
Ronnie Wearmouth
Anthony Rocca

That was bloody tough to do!
 
Gone Critical said:
Add in Greenings 50 disposals and 16 marks in a game the year before as a 20 yo. Worth noting he played 107 of 108 games from when 1st selected as a 17 yo in 1968. We didn't get near seeing his best but the years he had stack up against anyones
Click to expand...
Loved Greening! Saw him kick 7 against the Blues at Princess Park in 1969. I love the way he moved. He could do it all. Damn Jimmy Odea for the thug he was.
 
All in no particular order:

Ronnie Wearmouth
Rene Kink
Ricky Barham
Nathan Buckley
Peter Daicos

Honourable mentions to:
Scott Burns
Daisy Thomas
Heath Shaw
Tony Shaw
Lee Walker

Geez, there's plenty that I could go on with...
 
Abdul_The_Bull said:
Good ol' Scooter! Anyone who sinks the slipper into a WCE player lying on the ground - in his first game mind you - deservces to be on the list! Talk about mongrel.... he had it in spades!
Click to expand...

Interesting that several people have put Scott Russell too. The recruitment of these 2 was sheer brilliance to make the 1990 midfield unstoppable.
 
William picken
Fabulous Phil
Great Dane swan
Slim Jim clement
Macedonian marvels petey and nick

Honorable mention

Jimmy Manson
Twiggy dunne
Benny Johnson
Mighty mick mcguane
Pants
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Top 5 Favourite Pies Players ever? (Not the best, your favourite).

Similar threads

BigVic
Your favourite 2023 Grand Final moments
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
125
Views
7K
Pie eyed
Pie eyed
ellesbells
Favourite game sans Grand Final wins
2
Replies
29
Views
1K
magpienato
magpienato
mhill
AFL Grand Final Best GF ever
Replies
9
Views
682
manicpie
manicpie
T
Your Top 3 Favourite Players - 2023
2
Replies
38
Views
1K
JB1975
JB1975
South of the Yarra
Favourite Collingwood Goals
2 3
Replies
61
Views
3K
Robroy22
Robroy22
ThePhantom777
  • Poll
Opinion Your favourite Collingwood Indigenous guernsey?
2
Replies
36
Views
2K
thebigsaveloy
T
DaddyMac80
Top 50 Collingwood players 21st Century
Replies
10
Views
817
wyalurch
wyalurch

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top