Roast St Kilda in no mans land

[phantom13]

It’s called cutting the list, deep. I even gave you names.

Yet another thing we did, pretty hard mind you, that you want us to go full north with.

But don’t tank.

I actually think you genuinely don’t think you’re advocating for tanking when you obviously are. It’s weird.

 

[BrutThough]

And also, to add to my argument above, this doesn't really scream of a side that thinks they were just a few injuries off the pace.

They'll literally tearing up the coaching structure and starting again.

Rotating the line coaches after multiple years in those roles is hardly unusual. Every club does it to keep things fresh for the players.

 

[EconomicDecline]

It’s called cutting the list, deep. I even gave you names.

It's called being ****ing stupid

 

[EconomicDecline]

Rotating the line coaches after multiple years in those roles is hardly unusual. Every club does it to keep things fresh for the players.

Moving a dual brownlow midfielder from coaching the forwards, the poorest results line, to the midfield.

Promoting the backline coach, the absolute standout of the team, to head of game plan and strategy.

Hiring a 194 game afl defender to coach the defence line.

St Kilda and their wacky shake-up

 

[BIGHAWK23]

Moving a dual brownlow midfielder from coaching the forwards, the poorest results line, to the midfield.

Promoting the backline coach, the absolute standout of the team, to head of game plan and strategy.

Hiring a 194 game afl defender to coach the defence line.

St Kilda and their wacky shake-up

Whilst agreeing that coaching shake ups work

Moving R.Harvey based on his previously poor results coaching midfields to coach your midfield isn't a great move

The rest, no issue

 

[EconomicDecline]

Whilst agreeing that coaching shake ups work

Moving R.Harvey based on his previously poor results coaching midfields to coach your midfield isn't a great move

The rest, no issue

Would you have Buddy coach Midfielders or Forwards?

Harvs is a proven coach having been at 4 different teams. Hawthorn hired him as a mid development coach. He's just moving to a line he's better suited for.

 

[BIGHAWK23]

Would you have Buddy coach Midfielders or Forwards?

Harvs is a proven coach having been at 4 different teams. Hawthorn hired him as a mid development coach. He's just moving to a line he's better suited for.

Wouldn't hire buddy franklin to coach an AFL line, and thats not my point

Robert Harvey has been let go by 3 teams, no matter how you spin it

Whilst he is a legendary player, doesn't mean he is an exceptional coach, and being overlooked so many times for senior roles is an example of that

Hawthorn also got rid of him as a mids coach, as have other clubs

Coaches reach their use by date, just because he is a club legend, doesn't mean you have to give him a job

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Yet another thing we did, pretty hard mind you, that you want us to go full north with.

But don’t tank.

I actually think you genuinely don’t think you’re advocating for tanking when you obviously are. It’s weird.

You’re still doing the strawman thing.

You can trade and cut your list without tanking. I don’t know why it’s that hard to understand.

 

[austinnn]

Wouldn't hire buddy franklin to coach an AFL line, and thats not my point

Robert Harvey has been let go by 3 teams, no matter how you spin it

Whilst he is a legendary player, doesn't mean he is an exceptional coach, and being overlooked so many times for senior roles is an example of that

Hawthorn also got rid of him as a mids coach, as have other clubs

Coaches reach their use by date, just because he is a club legend, doesn't mean you have to give him a job

Harvey wasn't let go by the Hawks, Mitchell wanted to keep him, Ross Lyon poached him upon his return. Check if you don’t believe me.

Having said that I'm not a huge fan of him as a coach but at least he's better coaching mids than forwards, which was aguably our worst line (in terms of play not talent) for the last year or so.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Rotating the line coaches after multiple years in those roles is hardly unusual. Every club does it to keep things fresh for the players.

Every club moves every line coach to new roles every couple of years?

Maybe they do, Cleary certainly didn’t report on it like it was very usual.

 

[phantom13]

You’re still doing the strawman thing.

You can trade and cut your list without tanking. I don’t know why it’s that hard to understand.

Im really not. I listed off all the older guys we cut. It was a pretty substantial list.

Youre suggesting we go further which is North 2016 territory.

I actually dont think you even realise that what your suggesting is tanking but it is.

You seem to think prioritize draft, assess and FA needs ISNT what were doing, when factually you keep being shown youre wrong.

Every club moves every line coach to new roles every couple of years?

Maybe they do, Cleary certainly didn’t report on it like it was very usual.

Tell me you read headlines and not the article without telling me you read headlines and not the article.

Mate, ive seen you around the board, youre actually a really intelligent and thoughtful poster and mod but youre having a proper mare here. I say that with respect too.