Southern Football League (Tas) Thread

[jj15]

James Holmes has played at Clarence since under 10s atleast.

Keegan Ryan played at North Hobart.

 

[KeenObserver24]

I’d say it has nothing to do with their fathers it’s probably because they played juniors there

Yes they are only 1 if they played juniors at the club, Dolliver 1 at Lauderdale, Monks, Williams at Brighton etc.

James Holmes didn’t play juniors at Glenorchy though did he?

I

 

[KeenObserver24]

James Holmes has played at Clarence since under 10s atleast.

Keegan Ryan played at North Hobart.

Keegan Ryan played a couple of years at Glenorchy as a junior, maybe Holmes did? PlayHQ only goes back to 2008 so potentially a year or 2 before he went to Clarence?

 

[The Majestic]

Anyone Know how Dane Swan went?

Kicked 2 goals while he spent most of it playing at half back, but would venture into the middle. Got a few possessions here and there.

 

[BG1616]

Are there many father sons in the comp? Could be an interesting game to play.

Looks like clarence have a lot looking at their team sheet

 

[KeenObserver24]

Are there many father sons in the comp? Could be an interesting game to play.

Looks like clarence have a lot looking at their team sheet

There’s quite a few floating around, not necessarily for the same club as each other though.

 

[jj15]

James Holmes is 1 point as his father played a certain amount of games at Glenorchy.

 

[KeenObserver24]

James Holmes is 1 point as his father played a certain amount of games at Glenorchy.

Any idea what the number of games is?

 

[Barge]

If there’s such a rule then Keegan Ryan and Keegan Wylie would be one pointers at Glenorchy given their Fathers played there in the 90’s.

 

[DR SFL]

If there’s such a rule then Keegan Ryan and Keegan Wylie would be one pointers at Glenorchy given their Fathers played there in the 90’s.

I don’t believe there is a father son rule as such.
All premier players were supposedly reset to 1 point if they were staying put.
1 point also if they played 40 games at their feeder club providing they had an agreement in place.
Also all premier clubs got 40 points to start.

Interesting though points are very odd at some clubs players , dodges for example have many ex TSL players that are clearly under points value, they are also interestingly awarded 38 points which makes no sense as they have hardly missed finals in the past 10 years

 

[TasPie23]

I don’t believe there is a father son rule as such.
All premier players were supposedly reset to 1 point if they were staying put.
1 point also if they played 40 games at their feeder club providing they had an agreement in place.
Also all premier clubs got 40 points to start.

Interesting though points are very odd at some clubs players , dodges for example have many ex TSL players that are clearly under points value, they are also interestingly awarded 38 points which makes no sense as they have hardly missed finals in the past 10 years

There is a “family connection” rule, father or grandfather needs to have played 50 or more senior games, or something like 80 club games, in order to be reduced to 1

 

[BG1616]

There is a “family connection” rule, father or grandfather needs to have played 50 or more senior games, or something like 80 club games, in order to be reduced to 1

Glenorchy have done well then, recruited 1 pointers.

 

[jj15]

There is a “family connection” rule, father or grandfather needs to have played 50 or more senior games, or something like 80 club games, in order to be reduced to 1

Yerp hence James Holmes was 1 point.

Some of the points look out of whack as some have moved to an SFL Div 2 team that is considered in the zone of a Premier League club. If a North Hobart player goes to Hobart for example they are reduced points.

 

[jj15]

Hobart should thank their lucky stars they only lost bye 142 points tonight.

Their fitness levels looked disgraceful. They have spent a lot of money yet started with two 100 point floggings.

 

[Gersman]

Hobart should thank their lucky stars they only lost bye 142 points tonight.

Their fitness levels looked disgraceful. They have spent a lot of money yet started with two 100 point floggings.

CAn't disagree with that. Went in and had a look at that one, their second quarter was good but they desperately lack skill.
What's happened to Christensen? Thought he was supposed to be playing coach?
One thing I did notice was Harvey was still running around playing 1s for Hobart, he'd be getting up towards 50 by now so they've obviously not recruited a lot [or can't because of the PPS, same as Claremont].
Cygnet should be in the premier league but are weak as water and happy to be a huge fish in a small tank. Should be made to go up IMO.

 

[BlueMaster1]

Luke Dunstan

27

Luke Dunstan

Age

30

Ht

185cm

Wt

86kg

Pos.

Mid

Career

Season

Last 5

D

20.7

5star

K

10.1

4star

HB

10.6

5star

M

3.3

3star

T

4.8

5star

CL

4.4

5star

D

21.0

5star

K

13.0

5star

HB

8.0

4star

M

3.0

3star

T

9.0

5star

CL

2.0

4star

D

18.2

5star

K

6.0

3star

HB

12.2

5star

M

2.4

3star

T

6.2

5star

CL

4.2

5star

is a good pick up for north Hobart

 

[Barge]

Especially if they get access to him full time, however I suspect he’s got the week off with the team he’s playing with in Melbourne.

 

[jj15]

CAn't disagree with that. Went in and had a look at that one, their second quarter was good but they desperately lack skill.
What's happened to Christensen? Thought he was supposed to be playing coach?
One thing I did notice was Harvey was still running around playing 1s for Hobart, he'd be getting up towards 50 by now so they've obviously not recruited a lot [or can't because of the PPS, same as Claremont].
Cygnet should be in the premier league but are weak as water and happy to be a huge fish in a small tank. Should be made to go up IMO.

The fact Cygnet weren’t made too shows how weak the leadership is.

Would of made it 7 and 7

 

[Barge]

Even numbers in both comps is ideal - if it’s avoidable, you don’t want anywhere up to approx 175 men and women’s players not playing on any given weekend if the two clubs with the bye both had seniors, reserves, boys colts and a women’s team playing.

 

[NorthHobart4Lyfe]

North Hobart showed a lot of fight today. Tom Reeves second half… wow. Could’ve easily gone their way

 

[BlueMaster1]

North Hobart showed a lot of fight today. Tom Reeves second half… wow. Could’ve easily gone their way

Was very good stiff not to get a mention

Clarence have been pretty good so far considering the amount of players left

 

[jj15]

Maybe Clarence have made the right decision?

They were younger than North Hobart yesterday and looked extremely fit.

North Hobart would be disappointed.

 

[KeenObserver24]

Maybe Clarence have made the right decision?

They were younger than North Hobart yesterday and looked extremely fit.

North Hobart would be disappointed.

Maybe long term they have but would be flag certainties this year if they kept him.

 

[The Majestic]

CAn't disagree with that. Went in and had a look at that one, their second quarter was good but they desperately lack skill.
What's happened to Christensen? Thought he was supposed to be playing coach?
One thing I did notice was Harvey was still running around playing 1s for Hobart, he'd be getting up towards 50 by now so they've obviously not recruited a lot [or can't because of the PPS, same as Claremont].
Cygnet should be in the premier league but are weak as water and happy to be a huge fish in a small tank. Should be made to go up IMO.

He had some surgery before the season and isn't playing this year. I've no idea what happened but he mentioned at the season launch he was out for the season.

Lauderdale were far too good for Glenorchy, the Pies weren't very disciplined at all during the game, getting frustrated and had a few spot fires during the game. They looked a little slow too.

 

[BlueMaster1]

Maybe long term they have but would be flag certainties this year if they kept him.

Kept who??

Lauderdale are very gettable, not to mention Fraser Turner has only played a half of footy this season for the Roos