SNFL Div 3 discussion 2024

[don_draper]

I agree. A star player or not.. you need to earn your spot in the seniors.

I agree. A star player or not.. you need to earn your spot in the seniors.

Agree. Sth Mornington did not apply this policy with Gillis, or with some non 'stars' that joined them this week

 

[Dales14]

Agree. Sth Mornington did not apply this policy with Gillis, or with some non 'stars' that joined them this week

You don't drive a Ferrari on dirt roads. Gillis goes straight in everyday of the week.

 

[don_draper]

You don't drive a Ferrari on dirt roads. Gillis goes straight in everyday of the week.

they played at Narre, it was dirt roads all day unfortunately. i guess they couldn't play him against their 2s, that'd be ridiculous.

 

[Dales14]

they played at Narre, it was dirt roads all day unfortunately. i guess they couldn't play him against their 2s, that'd be ridiculous.

Doesn't matter who you play, he's not a 2s player in any comp in victoria

 

[tiga2017]

Lyndhurst coughed up another game they should've won due to poor decision making. Really should be 10 points ahead of where they are. Potentially another season of missing finals due to shooting themselves in the foot.

Season over?

 

[don_draper]

Season over?

hard to see the 4 changing, Heatherton have clearly improved. round 17 heatherton v lyndhurst the key game, if it's not over by then.

 

[SaintsMagee]

Season over?

They knock the ball out instead of keeping it in vs CPL they win + 2 points
They kick the ball deep instead of trying a short option vs Heatherton they win + 4 points
Some very bad luck/umpiring calls when they lost to BR earlier in the year

big year of what ifs

 

[tiga2017]

They knock the ball out instead of keeping it in vs CPL they win + 2 points
They kick the ball deep instead of trying a short option vs Heatherton they win + 4 points
Some very bad luck/umpiring calls when they lost to BR earlier in the year

big year of what ifs

Very detailed analysis . Let’s hope they can win next two..Ashwood and Narre South.. big big game next weekend though

 

[thunder35]

Season over?

We are done ! 3 games now that should have been ours


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[thunder35]

Top 4 is set unless my boys can pinch a game from either Frankston or south .before playing heatherton . And maybe having to beat CPL at the end .

Like I said previously Ashwood are building nicely , and will finish the year of with one or two more big scalps . ( won’t be 4 points that will be given up easily )
Saints have had a uphill battle ( it’s evident )
My concern- is div 3 Evenly contested without the saints in this division this year .
Who would finish bottom if they weren’t in it ? Bythe fixture and results.
Even thoe Ashwood are Cleary the ones , can any one see black rock winning another game besides the saints ?
And what has happened down there ?
To be fair the only club that seems to have gone backwards this year.
IMO
( love the banter with there crowd, have to be one of the better crowds when it comes to sharing there opinions. I love the raw passion that the players seem to lack )




On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[tiga2017]

We are done ! 3 games now that should have been ours


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

You play for lightning and let me guess..must be a new player?

 

[thunder35]

You play for lightning and let me guess..must be a new player?

Weight would be the main factor for not taking the field along with my acquired brain injury mate .

Yes first year I have watched every game.

I was a Cranbourne supporter and still will be Cranbourne man till I die.

Since the departures of players to the Mpnfl ( rosebud ) . And a few in house problems that myself and a percentage of members will not stand by.

Cranbournes most decorated reserves players Xavier Pauli jumped to Lyndhurst for a small stint , which then caught my attention .

Do I need to put my name and biography down to ask legitimate questions ?

Or is there rules around certain questions or observations .

On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app[/url

 

[2s Hack]

What's been the turn around at Heatherton this season? Have been in the wilderness for a few years & were almost becoming irrelevant. What's sparked the revival?

 

[winger95]

They haven’t spent enough the last two year to purchase the cup

Interesting outlook. The dolphs look to have a fresh and a pretty honest list. 9 players in their most recent 22 that were ex juniors and 6x u21.

Can guarantee Gillis is on more at Sth Mornington than half the dolphins list combined


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Ryan17]

how many of the division 4 sides would beat Narre Sth right now

 

[Billy Blogs]

Berwick springs have voted to come to southern next season would most likely start in Div 3

 

[Tackle Bag]

Berwick springs have voted to come to southern next season would most likely start in Div 3

Smart by them and the continuation of a clean out of that comp to get back to something like their old YVMDFL set up. I reckon Officer and Pakenham will end up in southern in years to come.

 

[tiga2017]

So div 3 next year..could be
Hampton?
Skye?
CPL
Ashwood
BlackRock
Lyndhurst
Heatherton
Berwick Springers?

Frankston(if they win, DIV 2)
Hampton(will come up from Div 4)
Skye(will come down from Div 2)

 

[FootballGuy95]

So div 3 next year..could be
Hampton?
Skye?
CPL
Ashwood
BlackRock
Lyndhurst
Heatherton
Berwick Springers?

Frankston(if they win, DIV 2)
Hampton(will come up from Div 4)
Skye(will come down from Div 2)

Pretty sure it’s 2 down this year from Div 1 and 2 making room for narre Warren

 

[don_draper]

so let's assume no change to ladders from here, and top spot wins it. 1 up to div 2, 2 down from div 2, 1 up from div 4, 1 down to div 4.


sth morn
cpl
heatherton
ashwood
lyndhurst
black rock
skye
highett
berwick springs
hampton

10 teams, perfect.

 

[tiga2017]

Pretty sure it’s 2 down this year from Div 1 and 2 making room for narre Warren

So then it becomes
Ashwood
Black Rock
Berwick Springers
CPL
Highett
Heatherton
Hampton
Lyndhurst
Skye
South Mornington

 

[thunder35]

After next year it should be 2 up 2 down.

Clubs like Frankston this year, beena a few years back who dominated the whole season but fell short on the biggest day should still be rewarded with going up .


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[don_draper]

After next year it should be 2 up 2 down.

Clubs like Frankston this year, beena a few years back who dominated the whole season but fell short on the biggest day should still be rewarded with going up .


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

disagree. if that was the case already, Frankston would be div 2 by now, with next to no chance of winning a flag any time soon. need a balance between moving teams up too quickly and keeping divs competitive. It was smart to move Frankston out of div 4 after they lost that gf, but another move up this year would have been too much, too soon imo.

perhaps some league discretion each year if a 2nd placed club is truly dominant (and wants to go up) and a 2nd bottom club higher up is a basket case, would work better.

 

[Dales14]

So then it becomes
Ashwood
Black Rock
Berwick Springers
CPL
Highett
Heatherton
Hampton
Lyndhurst
Skye
South Mornington

South Mornington will be going up, mark my words.

 

[Bullfroggers]

South Mornington will be going up, mark my words.

The team that lost by 100 at home a couple of weeks ago?