Round 3 Trades (with POLL)

[4tune8]

View attachment 648521

Have 211k in the kitty. Would love some input on whether i should take my chance to go Heeney > Lloyd (via swinging Moore forward) or hold. Would make my Defence pretty rock solid but means my forward line would be pretty weak with just Danger and an underperforming Dunkley holding the fort.

Thoughts?

Hore > Worpel?

 

[Red Syrah]

View attachment 648521

Have 211k in the kitty. Would love some input on whether i should take my chance to go Heeney > Lloyd (via swinging Moore forward) or hold. Would make my Defence pretty rock solid but means my forward line would be pretty weak with just Danger and an underperforming Dunkley holding the fort.

Thoughts?

Heeney to LLoyd is a solid trade - ? over Heeney and Lloyd definite D1. Switching Moore means you are still playing the same number rookies, and Moore has a higher average than Heeney so your fwd line is actually stronger!

 

[pincrusher]

So Mills goes today. Have 3 options.
1. Scrimshaw and bank cash
2. Daniel via Moore
3. Gresham via Moore.

Leaning towards option 1 and the cash grab. Thoughts?

 

[INSECURIOUS]

Ok Limp Dick Uniacle
You're in son
Fire up or **** off

 

[Red Syrah]

So Mills goes today. Have 3 options.
1. Scrimshaw and bank cash
2. Daniel via Moore
3. Gresham via Moore.

Leaning towards option 1 and the cash grab. Thoughts?

View attachment 649058

Depends if you are thinking of bringing in a keeper or a stepping stone.
Scrimshaw gives you cash gen plus the chance to look at who will be a keeper from the mid-pricers but also leaves you exposed to playing 3 out of 4 rookies.
What about Mills to Collins who has good JS and is picking up, will still get cash gen but a little less risky than scrimshaw?
Or worpel, if you think he will continue form and also could be a good m9 later on with his DPP?

 

[LegendLewis]

So Mills goes today. Have 3 options.
1. Scrimshaw and bank cash
2. Daniel via Moore
3. Gresham via Moore.

Leaning towards option 1 and the cash grab. Thoughts?

View attachment 649058

Option 1 I reckon.
Scrimmers is an upgrade on Mills and the cash will be handy.
Daniel and Gresham look tasty but I want to see more of them first.

 

[pincrusher]

Depends if you are thinking of bringing in a keeper or a stepping stone.
Scrimshaw gives you cash gen plus the chance to look at who will be a keeper from the mid-pricers but also leaves you exposed to playing 3 out of 4 rookies.
What about Mills to Collins who has good JS and is picking up, will still get cash gen but a little less risky than scrimshaw?
Or worpel, if you think he will continue form and also could be a good m9 later on with his DPP?

Don't like Collins or Worpel. Collins will be inconsistent and Worpel has only played a dozen games. Yes he's playing full time midfield but the sample size of players that have broken out in their 2nd year is not very big. He may prove me wrong but I would rather pay another $100k for him in 8 weeks knowing he's consistently punching out 100's.

It's either a cash grab or a keeper for me. I see Daniel and Gresham both as potential keepers. Still leaning towards option 1 though.

Thanks for the reply.

 

[pincrusher]

Option 1 I reckon.
Scrimmers is an upgrade on Mills and the cash will be handy.
Daniel and Gresham look tasty but I want to see more of them first.

Yeah this is the only reason I'm leaning towards Scrimshaw.

 

[Nelso]

Happy with my decision to trade out Ridley

Yes he uses the ball well but he does not find enough of it.

Still not convinced he will be in the Essendon team long term.

Saved myself 80k by trading down to Scrimshaw.

 

[toxic]

Don't like Collins or Worpel. Collins will be inconsistent and Worpel has only played a dozen games. Yes he's playing full time midfield but the sample size of players that have broken out in their 2nd year is not very big. He may prove me wrong but I would rather pay another $100k for him in 8 weeks knowing he's consistently punching out 100's.

It's either a cash grab or a keeper for me. I see Daniel and Gresham both as potential keepers. Still leaning towards option 1 though.

Thanks for the reply.

Caleb time 4u

 

[TurtleKid]

So Mills goes today. Have 3 options.
1. Scrimshaw and bank cash
2. Daniel via Moore
3. Gresham via Moore.

Leaning towards option 1 and the cash grab. Thoughts?

View attachment 649058

Mills to Hello Newman

 

[pincrusher]

Mills to Hello Newman

No Newman for me. Will likely have a blinder against his old team today, but playing the long game here. I don't see him as a top 8 defender.

 

[rocker_oz33]

One trade done.

Belta to parker later today is likley my second trade.

Some kents brought in Saad really what a sad trade .

 

[nameless]

Just did my first trade of the year, always feel like vomiting afterwards.

 

[blackshadow]

Just did my first trade of the year, always feel like vomiting afterwards.

That's just soft!

 

[dylan93]

Happy I held Heeney now. Hope Dusty can do the same. Gibbons on the chopping block though at this rate.

 

[balmainforever]

Made an executive decision in moving Greene to Rozee.
Was going to be Worpel but want the $$$$ to get seagull next week.

 

[mochacinolatte]

Heeney is gonna kick 4 goals against our mob and kick the match winner. I can feel my Saturday afternoon misery and joy.

that aged well

 

[BigRang]

Holding Punchy for now, he ain’t dropping so he can warm the pine for a week.
Thoughts on Boak being the real deal? Still think Mundy will be top 8 forward at the end of the year but gee whiz it’s tempting to trade home for Travis and pocket some cash for next week...


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[freddy mercury]

Dusty and Darling.

Two genuine donkeys.

 

[Jiska]

Despite the fact I traded him in by accident (forgot there was a Thursday game so couldn’t reverse) and he hasn’t played since, tempted to turf Joyce for Scrim. Duuursma’s shit and also Moore’s ankle have me worried about cover. Wilkie doesn’t ooze confidence. Or I wait and get Rotham.

Thoughts?

 

[balmainforever]

Made an executive decision in moving Greene to Rozee.
Was going to be Worpel but want the $$$$ to get seagull next week.

Wow. Rozee flying tonight.

 

[Jiska]

Wow. Rozee flying tonight.

 

[Kadog]

Made an executive decision in moving Greene to Rozee.
Was going to be Worpel but want the $$$$ to get seagull next week.

Good call

 

[gutsroy]

Wow. Rozee flying tonight.

What are you doing here mate? You'd best head over to the 'Nailed It' thread. Stellar, Rozee is, going to make cash hand over fist, the DPP-having saucy little minx.